1 00:00:58,932 --> 00:01:00,665 Mom... 2 00:01:22,500 --> 00:01:26,232 I love you, Libby. 3 00:01:26,234 --> 00:01:28,832 I love you, ladybug. 4 00:01:28,834 --> 00:01:31,031 Don't you ever forget that. 5 00:01:56,132 --> 00:02:02,965 Libby, what you're about to tell us is very, very important. 6 00:02:02,967 --> 00:02:06,632 Did Ben kill your mom and your sisters? 7 00:02:09,333 --> 00:02:12,065 You were in the house when it happened. 8 00:02:14,566 --> 00:02:19,632 So tell us. It was Ben. He killed them, right? 9 00:02:24,899 --> 00:02:27,098 I have a meanness inside me. 10 00:02:28,466 --> 00:02:29,898 Real as an organ. 11 00:02:30,899 --> 00:02:32,931 It's the Day blood. 12 00:02:32,933 --> 00:02:35,065 Something's fuckin' wrong with it. 13 00:02:36,966 --> 00:02:40,165 I was eight the night they were killed and suddenly I was famous. 14 00:02:41,099 --> 00:02:44,532 The little orphan girl of the Kansas Prairie Massacre. 15 00:02:47,966 --> 00:02:50,131 So, strangers send me money. 16 00:02:50,133 --> 00:02:52,565 Just enough for me to do nothing. 17 00:02:52,567 --> 00:02:54,799 Which was exactly what I did. 18 00:02:56,399 --> 00:02:57,865 How much is left? 19 00:02:58,433 --> 00:03:00,599 Do you read the reports I send you? 20 00:03:02,501 --> 00:03:03,699 Sometimes. 21 00:03:04,132 --> 00:03:06,398 Have you at least listened to my messages? 22 00:03:07,233 --> 00:03:08,499 How much? 23 00:03:08,501 --> 00:03:12,365 There is $482 and 12 cents left in your fund. 24 00:03:13,299 --> 00:03:14,499 Now as I have mentioned before... 25 00:03:14,501 --> 00:03:15,499 Jesus... 26 00:03:15,932 --> 00:03:17,532 had you been able to replenish it 27 00:03:17,534 --> 00:03:19,931 with any kind of regular income, 28 00:03:19,933 --> 00:03:21,798 we'd have been able to keep it afloat. 29 00:03:21,800 --> 00:03:23,918 You're also two months behind on your rent. 30 00:03:30,433 --> 00:03:32,798 What about the book? Hmm? 31 00:03:32,800 --> 00:03:34,565 That should have made more money. 32 00:03:34,567 --> 00:03:36,599 - I know. - Any new donations? 33 00:03:36,601 --> 00:03:38,165 Thirtieth anniversary is coming up... 34 00:03:38,167 --> 00:03:41,285 - You know, I could... - People have short attention spans, Libby. 35 00:03:41,299 --> 00:03:44,365 And there's always a new murder, I'm afraid. 36 00:03:44,533 --> 00:03:46,298 They want to help other little girls. 37 00:03:46,300 --> 00:03:49,098 And the truth is, you're not a little girl anymore. 38 00:03:59,600 --> 00:04:01,165 I'm not ready for this. 39 00:04:02,533 --> 00:04:04,332 But in a way, 40 00:04:04,334 --> 00:04:07,599 it could turn out to be a blessing in disguise. 41 00:04:09,266 --> 00:04:12,432 And lead you into an exciting new phase of your life. 42 00:04:14,899 --> 00:04:16,998 What do you want to be when you grow up? 43 00:04:17,666 --> 00:04:19,332 Are you fucking kidding me? 44 00:04:27,566 --> 00:04:32,065 In the past Jim Jeffries used to hand me bulging shoe boxes full of mail. 45 00:04:33,166 --> 00:04:35,998 Most of them letters with checks inside. 46 00:04:38,500 --> 00:04:40,532 In return, donors would receive 47 00:04:40,534 --> 00:04:43,965 a form letter in my blocky handwriting that read... 48 00:04:43,967 --> 00:04:46,298 "Thank you for your donation." 49 00:04:46,300 --> 00:04:51,465 "It's people like you who let me look forward to a brighter future." 50 00:04:51,467 --> 00:04:54,098 "Yours truly, Libby Day." 51 00:05:15,633 --> 00:05:17,831 Hello? 52 00:05:17,833 --> 00:05:19,098 Hello? 53 00:05:19,100 --> 00:05:20,532 Is this Lyle Wirth? 54 00:05:20,534 --> 00:05:21,931 Yeah, who's asking? 55 00:05:24,732 --> 00:05:27,298 It's Libby Day, you wrote me. 56 00:05:27,300 --> 00:05:30,798 Oh, holy cow! Really? Libby Day? 57 00:05:30,800 --> 00:05:32,398 Are you in town? 58 00:05:33,099 --> 00:05:34,998 What do you mean, which town? 59 00:05:35,000 --> 00:05:37,698 Well, you're in Kansas City, that's where you live, right? 60 00:05:39,299 --> 00:05:40,565 Hello? 61 00:05:42,066 --> 00:05:43,298 Hello? 62 00:05:45,032 --> 00:05:47,131 Yeah, I live in Kansas City. 63 00:05:47,133 --> 00:05:49,332 Listen, your offer, is it serious? 64 00:05:54,266 --> 00:05:57,031 Lyle Wirth looked like a serial killer. 65 00:05:57,033 --> 00:05:59,332 Which probably meant he wasn't one. 66 00:05:59,334 --> 00:06:00,432 Lyle? 67 00:06:02,366 --> 00:06:03,798 Libby? 68 00:06:04,132 --> 00:06:06,850 Yeah, what? You were expecting someone else? 69 00:06:07,132 --> 00:06:11,599 Wow, Libby Day. I'm so excited to finally meet you... 70 00:06:11,601 --> 00:06:13,265 Okay, just fucking relax. 71 00:06:16,466 --> 00:06:18,232 There's, uh, no reason to be scared. 72 00:06:18,234 --> 00:06:20,131 I'm not scared of you. 73 00:06:20,133 --> 00:06:21,898 I'm just trying to figure out what kind of a person 74 00:06:21,900 --> 00:06:25,165 wants to meet in a laundromat in the middle of the fucking night. 75 00:06:25,167 --> 00:06:27,631 Oh, no, it's not what you think. I own this place. 76 00:06:27,633 --> 00:06:29,731 I own two of them. I'm an entrepreneur. 77 00:06:31,799 --> 00:06:33,698 - Can I offer you something? - Like what? 78 00:06:33,700 --> 00:06:35,232 Detergent? 79 00:06:35,234 --> 00:06:36,432 I was thinking maybe a coffee... 80 00:06:36,434 --> 00:06:38,965 - Just take a fucking step back, man! - Sorry. 81 00:06:38,967 --> 00:06:40,764 What is it with you and personal space? 82 00:06:40,766 --> 00:06:41,764 All right. 83 00:06:45,500 --> 00:06:46,798 Tell me about this club. 84 00:06:47,299 --> 00:06:50,031 You know how some guys collect baseball cards? 85 00:06:50,033 --> 00:06:51,965 Or women who read gossip magazines 86 00:06:51,967 --> 00:06:54,165 and know everything about some celebrity. 87 00:06:54,167 --> 00:06:56,465 Like their baby's name or the town where they grew up? 88 00:06:56,467 --> 00:06:59,332 This is like that, only it's about murders. 89 00:07:00,799 --> 00:07:02,031 We call it the Kill Club. 90 00:07:03,533 --> 00:07:05,865 It's not as weird as it sounds. 91 00:07:07,500 --> 00:07:11,031 It's like a bunch of people who like true crimes and mysteries. 92 00:07:11,033 --> 00:07:13,764 You know, everyone has a case that they are passionate about. 93 00:07:13,766 --> 00:07:16,831 You and your family are very special. Huge with the club. 94 00:07:19,099 --> 00:07:21,831 I mean, it's a real tragedy what happened. 95 00:07:21,833 --> 00:07:24,265 Your brother in jail, going on 28 years. 96 00:07:26,932 --> 00:07:30,265 Look, if you and your little club 97 00:07:30,267 --> 00:07:33,031 want to convince me that Ben's innocent, you're wasting your time. 98 00:07:33,033 --> 00:07:36,432 Just come along, it's like... Like a convention. 99 00:07:40,032 --> 00:07:41,631 How much? 100 00:07:41,633 --> 00:07:44,598 Five hundred dollars. And there will be a lot of collectors there, 101 00:07:44,600 --> 00:07:46,531 so bring any souvenirs from your childhood... 102 00:07:46,533 --> 00:07:47,532 I want a thousand. 103 00:07:49,032 --> 00:07:50,564 I can give you 700. 104 00:07:50,566 --> 00:07:53,004 And you let us pick your brain about what happened that day. 105 00:07:59,632 --> 00:08:00,831 Fine. 106 00:08:01,499 --> 00:08:02,998 Yeah? 107 00:08:03,000 --> 00:08:04,365 Yeah. Deal. 108 00:08:41,999 --> 00:08:43,598 I betcha can't! 109 00:08:47,465 --> 00:08:49,065 Come on, let's go! 110 00:08:56,266 --> 00:08:58,332 Hey! What about breakfast? 111 00:09:09,665 --> 00:09:12,582 It's a little warm out for that hat, don't you think? 112 00:09:26,933 --> 00:09:30,098 Settle down girls. Settle down. 113 00:09:32,999 --> 00:09:34,065 Hey, Ben. 114 00:09:35,032 --> 00:09:37,664 - Hey, Libby. - I like your salt mountain. 115 00:09:37,666 --> 00:09:38,664 Oh, yeah? 116 00:09:43,132 --> 00:09:45,397 Mom, Ben and Libby are making a mess at the table. 117 00:09:45,399 --> 00:09:46,564 Sweetie, it's fine. 118 00:09:46,566 --> 00:09:47,998 Michelle, can you make sure everyone has juice. 119 00:09:48,000 --> 00:09:51,598 Mom! Libby took my pancake off my plate. 120 00:09:51,600 --> 00:09:53,265 Libby, Ben... 121 00:09:53,267 --> 00:09:54,265 Eggs? 122 00:09:55,532 --> 00:09:59,898 Mom, Ben's wearing a hat inside. It's not even cold. Duh! 123 00:09:59,900 --> 00:10:02,332 Michelle, you're right. Ben, you need to take off your hat. 124 00:10:02,334 --> 00:10:04,411 It's not polite to wear a hat at the table. 125 00:10:05,832 --> 00:10:06,898 Ben. 126 00:10:14,432 --> 00:10:18,031 Mom, Ben looks like some ghoul from one of his metal band posters. 127 00:10:18,432 --> 00:10:19,498 Why? 128 00:10:19,999 --> 00:10:22,531 It's just hair, Mom. Don't freak out. 129 00:10:24,599 --> 00:10:26,265 - I'll be back later. 130 00:10:35,266 --> 00:10:40,298 It wasn't the first time I'd been offered money for conferences or meetings. 131 00:10:43,465 --> 00:10:47,098 I'd been offered all sorts of twisted deals over the years. 132 00:11:09,066 --> 00:11:11,165 Want some sweets, little girl? 133 00:11:15,999 --> 00:11:17,232 Libby! 134 00:11:18,699 --> 00:11:20,965 - Welcome to our club. - What? 135 00:11:20,967 --> 00:11:22,531 I said, "Welcome to our club!" 136 00:11:22,533 --> 00:11:24,411 You want me to show you around? 137 00:11:24,699 --> 00:11:26,364 I want my money. 138 00:11:30,298 --> 00:11:32,731 Come on. I'll show you upstairs. 139 00:11:33,398 --> 00:11:35,198 The Kill Club, 140 00:11:35,200 --> 00:11:39,364 or "KC," as we call it, is basically for solvers and fans of famous murders. 141 00:11:39,366 --> 00:11:41,131 Everyone from Fanny Adams to the killer... 142 00:11:41,133 --> 00:11:42,965 Who's Fanny Adams? 143 00:11:42,967 --> 00:11:46,331 She's an eight-year-old who got chopped to bits in England back in 1867. 144 00:11:46,732 --> 00:11:48,798 - That guy you passed with the sweets downstairs. - Mmm-hmm. 145 00:11:48,800 --> 00:11:51,965 He was playing the role of her murderer, Frederick Baker. 146 00:11:54,967 --> 00:11:56,397 Jesus Christ... 147 00:11:56,399 --> 00:11:57,631 You guys need to get a life. 148 00:11:57,633 --> 00:11:59,798 Yeah, we've been trying to push the role players out, 149 00:11:59,800 --> 00:12:02,031 but, too many guys are into that. 150 00:12:02,033 --> 00:12:04,464 Plus, it's a good source of income for us. 151 00:12:04,466 --> 00:12:06,531 - Us? - The solvers. 152 00:12:07,166 --> 00:12:09,297 We're a serious-minded organization. 153 00:12:09,299 --> 00:12:11,531 Among our ranks are ex-cops, 154 00:12:11,533 --> 00:12:13,698 private and insurance investigators, lawyers. 155 00:12:13,700 --> 00:12:16,065 We solve crimes. It's what we do. 156 00:12:22,700 --> 00:12:25,531 Lyle. Who's your young friend? 157 00:12:25,533 --> 00:12:28,297 Bob Bredella, this is Libby Day. 158 00:12:28,899 --> 00:12:32,664 Whose, uh, family was at the Kansas farm house massacre. 159 00:12:32,666 --> 00:12:33,664 Oh... 160 00:12:33,666 --> 00:12:38,431 If you had a cock you would be in pieces in my garbage right now. 161 00:12:38,433 --> 00:12:40,351 Parts that I didn't use for chili. 162 00:12:41,333 --> 00:12:43,431 Get your fucking hands off me! You freak! 163 00:12:43,433 --> 00:12:44,998 - I'm kidding. I'm sorry. - You think that's funny? 164 00:12:45,000 --> 00:12:46,839 - Only kidding. - You fat fuck! 165 00:12:47,265 --> 00:12:48,931 That wouldn't have been the first fight at Kill Club, 166 00:12:48,933 --> 00:12:50,698 but it would've been the weirdest. 167 00:12:50,700 --> 00:12:51,798 You know what, I'm outta here. 168 00:12:51,800 --> 00:12:52,998 No, no, no. Libby, please. 169 00:12:53,000 --> 00:12:54,431 I don't want to do this anymore. 170 00:12:54,433 --> 00:12:57,931 No, no. I can understand why you wouldn't like it so far. 171 00:12:57,933 --> 00:13:00,598 Okay. But we're not all like that. 172 00:13:00,600 --> 00:13:03,498 Look, just give me a chance. Look at this in here. 173 00:13:04,499 --> 00:13:08,498 It's a bunch of PI's who think they've identified a serial killer. 174 00:13:08,500 --> 00:13:10,331 They're about to catch some guy 175 00:13:10,333 --> 00:13:11,564 who has been crossing states. 176 00:13:11,566 --> 00:13:14,831 You know, Missouri, Kansas, Oklahoma, to help kill people. 177 00:13:15,166 --> 00:13:16,245 What do you mean, help? 178 00:13:16,732 --> 00:13:18,631 They call him the Angel of Debt. 179 00:13:18,633 --> 00:13:20,498 They think he's like a Jack Kevorkian 180 00:13:20,500 --> 00:13:21,965 for people with bad credit, 181 00:13:21,967 --> 00:13:23,885 good life insurance and no way out. 182 00:13:24,665 --> 00:13:27,564 You'll like our group. It's serious, no costumes. 183 00:13:30,799 --> 00:13:33,965 Hi everyone. It's my honor to present our special guest, 184 00:13:33,967 --> 00:13:36,431 and the star of this year's Kill Club. 185 00:13:36,433 --> 00:13:37,631 Libby Day. 186 00:13:39,332 --> 00:13:43,164 Around 2:00 a.m. on October the 13th, 1985, 187 00:13:43,166 --> 00:13:48,231 a person or persons killed three members of the Day family 188 00:13:48,233 --> 00:13:50,865 in their farm house in Kinnakee, Kansas. 189 00:13:50,867 --> 00:13:53,297 The youngest child, Libby, 190 00:13:53,299 --> 00:13:56,998 escaped the killer through a window in her mother's room. 191 00:13:57,000 --> 00:14:00,598 The oldest child, Benjamin, never produced an alibi 192 00:14:00,600 --> 00:14:04,098 and was extremely uncooperative with the police. 193 00:14:04,100 --> 00:14:05,664 Libby testified, 194 00:14:05,666 --> 00:14:08,197 she saw Ben commit the murders. 195 00:14:08,199 --> 00:14:11,364 Despite Libby's confused testimony, 196 00:14:11,366 --> 00:14:13,831 and young age, 197 00:14:13,833 --> 00:14:17,731 and despite a startling lack of physical evidence, 198 00:14:17,733 --> 00:14:19,331 Ben Day was convicted. 199 00:14:19,333 --> 00:14:22,898 Based largely on rumors that he was involved in Devil worship. 200 00:14:24,899 --> 00:14:26,164 You done? 201 00:14:26,166 --> 00:14:28,331 I think the general consensus is that Runner Day, 202 00:14:28,333 --> 00:14:29,731 her father, did it. 203 00:14:29,733 --> 00:14:32,297 I mean, he goes to Patty, tries to bully her for money, 204 00:14:32,299 --> 00:14:34,231 as usual gets nothing, and he goes haywire. 205 00:14:34,233 --> 00:14:35,764 I mean, the guy was crazy, right? 206 00:14:36,066 --> 00:14:37,731 Right. I don't know... 207 00:14:39,066 --> 00:14:41,397 Look, I didn't know him, he left when I was, like, two. 208 00:14:41,399 --> 00:14:42,965 - Where is he now? - I don't know. 209 00:14:42,967 --> 00:14:45,231 There was a blood stain on Michelle's bed sheets. 210 00:14:45,233 --> 00:14:47,164 Different blood type than anyone in the family. 211 00:14:47,166 --> 00:14:50,031 But since the sheets were from Goodwill, 212 00:14:50,033 --> 00:14:52,297 prosecutor says that blood could have come from anywhere. 213 00:14:52,299 --> 00:14:53,731 Yeah, we were poor. 214 00:14:53,733 --> 00:14:55,531 A lot of our shit came from Goodwill, okay? 215 00:14:55,533 --> 00:14:58,331 Do you remember anything out of the ordinary 216 00:14:58,333 --> 00:15:00,031 - happening that day? - Like what? 217 00:15:00,033 --> 00:15:03,264 Like, how your mother reacted to the Krissi Cates scandal. 218 00:15:03,565 --> 00:15:05,664 - Who? - Krissi Cates. 219 00:15:06,932 --> 00:15:08,364 I don't know who that is. 220 00:15:08,632 --> 00:15:09,965 You mentioned her in your book. 221 00:15:09,967 --> 00:15:12,898 I didn't write that book. I didn't even read it. 222 00:15:12,900 --> 00:15:14,698 What about Trey Teepano? 223 00:15:14,700 --> 00:15:17,331 What about Ben Day? You want to hear what I have to say about him? 224 00:15:17,333 --> 00:15:20,297 Please, this is the grossest miscarriage of justice ever. 225 00:15:20,299 --> 00:15:21,698 What is this woman's deal? 226 00:15:21,700 --> 00:15:23,831 Magda here is very involved in the effort to free your brother. 227 00:15:23,833 --> 00:15:27,164 He's a wonderful man. He draws, he writes poetry. 228 00:15:27,166 --> 00:15:30,031 You should get to know him, Libby. You really should. 229 00:15:30,033 --> 00:15:32,564 In three weeks, that window is going to close. 230 00:15:33,098 --> 00:15:34,231 What? 231 00:15:34,233 --> 00:15:35,631 In order to solve this crime, 232 00:15:36,265 --> 00:15:39,531 we need to compile new evidence and 233 00:15:39,533 --> 00:15:41,965 if you were inclined, you could recant your testimony 234 00:15:41,967 --> 00:15:46,531 when we file for habeas corpus. But time is of the essence. 235 00:15:46,832 --> 00:15:48,030 What are you talking about? 236 00:15:48,032 --> 00:15:49,664 Oh, because of budget cuts, 237 00:15:49,666 --> 00:15:51,998 they are consolidating departments and disposing of evidence 238 00:15:52,000 --> 00:15:53,878 from cases older than 10 years. 239 00:15:54,065 --> 00:15:57,498 Which means, in three weeks' time, Ben's file will be shredded. 240 00:16:01,332 --> 00:16:02,898 You're just a few people 241 00:16:02,900 --> 00:16:05,297 who like murder mysteries and true crimes... 242 00:16:05,299 --> 00:16:07,097 Libby. Ben is innocent and we're trying to prove it. 243 00:16:07,099 --> 00:16:09,030 He's never even filed for an appeal! 244 00:16:09,032 --> 00:16:12,998 He's had reason enough for eight appeals but he has lost hope. 245 00:16:13,000 --> 00:16:13,998 Good. 246 00:16:15,165 --> 00:16:16,331 - Please help... - No. 247 00:16:16,333 --> 00:16:19,097 - It's not a conspiracy theory... - Hey, don't be like that! 248 00:16:19,099 --> 00:16:20,164 Get your hands off me! 249 00:16:20,166 --> 00:16:21,997 At least stay and try and convince us. 250 00:16:21,999 --> 00:16:24,798 I told you she wouldn't bother, lazy little liar. 251 00:16:26,632 --> 00:16:30,531 Yes, that's what you are and what you've always been. A liar! 252 00:16:38,165 --> 00:16:40,564 You don't know shit about what happened that night. 253 00:16:45,232 --> 00:16:46,364 None of you. 254 00:16:49,799 --> 00:16:51,364 Run! Run! 255 00:16:51,366 --> 00:16:53,197 No! 256 00:16:55,998 --> 00:16:58,498 Libby! Libby! 257 00:17:02,599 --> 00:17:04,197 Libby! 258 00:17:24,332 --> 00:17:25,498 They're all dead! 259 00:17:57,599 --> 00:18:00,764 "Once I was in art class and met a boy named Ben." 260 00:18:00,766 --> 00:18:03,431 "It was his heart I knew I would win." 261 00:18:03,433 --> 00:18:06,631 "He has big blue eyes and really nice skin." 262 00:18:06,633 --> 00:18:08,097 "Are you 'in'?" 263 00:18:09,499 --> 00:18:13,364 "It's Saturday and I'm thinking of you. Guess who?" 264 00:18:42,432 --> 00:18:43,671 Hey, do you know someone here? 265 00:18:45,732 --> 00:18:46,798 Him. 266 00:18:48,332 --> 00:18:50,564 Hey. Hey. 267 00:18:50,566 --> 00:18:52,231 Hey, do you know this kid? 268 00:18:54,198 --> 00:18:56,531 No, I don't hang out with middle-schoolers. 269 00:18:56,533 --> 00:18:57,631 - Fuck off. 270 00:18:57,633 --> 00:18:58,997 Oh, little guy's pissed. 271 00:18:58,999 --> 00:19:01,464 Okay, dude, what's up? Do I know you or what? 272 00:19:01,466 --> 00:19:03,064 I'm a friend of Trey's, I come here all the time. 273 00:19:03,066 --> 00:19:06,097 You liar. That crazy Indian doesn't have any friends. 274 00:19:06,099 --> 00:19:09,264 Is he even really Indian? He looks Asian to me. 275 00:19:09,266 --> 00:19:10,997 I think he's, uh, what do they call it, 276 00:19:10,999 --> 00:19:12,498 like, a mixed blood. He's like two different things. 277 00:19:12,500 --> 00:19:14,997 So, like, his drunken granddad raped a Chinese whore? 278 00:19:14,999 --> 00:19:16,631 You better watch your mouth, 279 00:19:16,633 --> 00:19:18,511 Trey's into some scary ass shit. 280 00:19:18,665 --> 00:19:19,830 Satanic shit. 281 00:19:21,499 --> 00:19:23,698 Yeah, we get into some pretty dark shit sometimes. 282 00:19:23,700 --> 00:19:25,817 You're one of the guys that killed the cows? 283 00:19:28,198 --> 00:19:29,464 We have to. 284 00:19:30,232 --> 00:19:31,631 It's an order. 285 00:19:31,633 --> 00:19:34,598 Bro, that's a weird order. That was my hamburger. 286 00:19:35,766 --> 00:19:37,664 Look at his face. 287 00:19:37,666 --> 00:19:40,731 Sometimes things have to die. We have to kill them. 288 00:19:41,931 --> 00:19:46,930 Just like Jesus requires sacrifice, so does Satan. 289 00:20:05,798 --> 00:20:07,598 Mom, is Ben in trouble? 290 00:20:07,600 --> 00:20:09,664 No, sweetie, Ben's fine. 291 00:20:09,666 --> 00:20:11,783 - Are you sure? - Michelle, what do you want? 292 00:20:12,532 --> 00:20:13,830 I heard rumors. 293 00:20:14,098 --> 00:20:15,498 What kind of rumors? 294 00:20:16,599 --> 00:20:19,331 Mom, there's a car coming! 295 00:20:22,232 --> 00:20:23,397 Who is it? 296 00:20:24,298 --> 00:20:25,364 Morning. 297 00:20:30,965 --> 00:20:32,064 Thank you. 298 00:20:37,165 --> 00:20:38,564 Who's the little spy? 299 00:20:39,298 --> 00:20:40,431 That's Libby. 300 00:20:42,865 --> 00:20:44,823 She's got big blue eyes like her mom. 301 00:20:45,031 --> 00:20:47,231 Where are your people from originally? Ireland? 302 00:20:47,499 --> 00:20:50,364 Germany. My maiden name was Krause. 303 00:20:50,366 --> 00:20:52,331 There was another German farmer near Ark City. 304 00:20:52,333 --> 00:20:54,730 Last summer, his hopper went screwy 305 00:20:54,732 --> 00:20:57,763 and dumped 4000 pounds of wheat on him. 306 00:20:57,765 --> 00:20:59,064 Poor fellow drowned in it. 307 00:20:59,066 --> 00:21:01,197 He suffocated before they could get to him. 308 00:21:01,432 --> 00:21:03,763 - I know the story. - His farm's going under. 309 00:21:04,131 --> 00:21:09,297 He owed us, uh, I mean, the FHA a lot of money. 310 00:21:09,665 --> 00:21:12,662 Why you working on a Saturday, Joseph, is something wrong? 311 00:21:16,098 --> 00:21:17,431 They're going to foreclose. 312 00:21:18,632 --> 00:21:19,697 Why now? 313 00:21:20,365 --> 00:21:22,064 Prices aren't what they used to be. 314 00:21:22,066 --> 00:21:23,297 A strong harvest is what brought 315 00:21:23,299 --> 00:21:25,231 those prices down, that could change next year. 316 00:21:25,233 --> 00:21:27,930 There's no way for you to come out on top. 317 00:21:27,932 --> 00:21:30,231 I could sell the animals, I'll sell some of the machinery. 318 00:21:30,233 --> 00:21:31,697 The animals aren't worth much. 319 00:21:31,699 --> 00:21:34,097 You already sold most of the machinery. 320 00:21:35,599 --> 00:21:37,797 There's got to be a way. 321 00:21:37,799 --> 00:21:41,064 - Banks said they would back... - Your bank's going under, too. 322 00:21:41,764 --> 00:21:43,930 I'm sorry. 323 00:21:43,932 --> 00:21:45,930 They're just trying to get rid of us. 324 00:21:47,332 --> 00:21:48,897 I'm not sure who "they" are. 325 00:21:49,665 --> 00:21:51,864 The only way to fix this is money. 326 00:21:53,098 --> 00:21:54,564 I'm talking beg, 327 00:21:54,566 --> 00:21:56,598 borrow, steal. 328 00:21:56,600 --> 00:21:59,130 Time for pride is over, Patty. 329 00:22:00,499 --> 00:22:05,830 Libby? What you're about to tell us is very, very important. 330 00:22:07,198 --> 00:22:10,730 Did Ben kill your mom and your sisters? 331 00:22:14,565 --> 00:22:18,531 You were in the house when it happened, so tell us. 332 00:22:19,198 --> 00:22:22,498 It was Ben, he killed them, right? 333 00:22:37,432 --> 00:22:38,997 Listen, I've been thinking. 334 00:22:40,265 --> 00:22:42,030 If I were to look into this case some more, 335 00:22:42,032 --> 00:22:44,311 is that something your club would be able to finance? 336 00:22:44,599 --> 00:22:45,830 You changed your mind? 337 00:22:45,832 --> 00:22:48,111 No, as far as I'm concerned Ben is the killer, but... 338 00:22:49,931 --> 00:22:51,830 I need money. 339 00:22:52,599 --> 00:22:55,797 I'm willing to offer your club three weeks of my life in exchange. 340 00:22:58,398 --> 00:22:59,797 That doesn't sound very noble. 341 00:23:00,131 --> 00:23:02,297 - Whatever. - No, wait. Libby. Libby. 342 00:23:03,532 --> 00:23:05,609 Do you really have no contact with Runner? 343 00:23:06,365 --> 00:23:07,564 No. 344 00:23:07,566 --> 00:23:09,297 Well, it might be a good idea to track him down. 345 00:23:09,299 --> 00:23:11,538 Although, personally I don't think Runner did it. 346 00:23:12,965 --> 00:23:14,030 What's your theory? 347 00:23:14,565 --> 00:23:16,030 I'm not quite ready to share that yet. 348 00:23:16,032 --> 00:23:19,364 Oh, come on! If Ben is so innocent, why doesn't he try to get out? 349 00:23:20,165 --> 00:23:22,043 Maybe you should go talk to him. 350 00:23:22,165 --> 00:23:23,397 No. 351 00:23:23,399 --> 00:23:24,964 We start with other people first. 352 00:23:24,966 --> 00:23:26,297 What is it? Is it a money thing? 353 00:23:26,299 --> 00:23:28,337 I just don't like wasting my time, okay? 354 00:23:28,698 --> 00:23:29,864 Okay. 355 00:23:29,866 --> 00:23:32,231 How about... $300? 356 00:23:35,332 --> 00:23:36,797 Where do you get this money? 357 00:23:36,799 --> 00:23:39,231 As treasurer, I have a certain amount of discretionary funds. 358 00:23:39,798 --> 00:23:41,763 This is the project I choose to use them for. 359 00:23:41,765 --> 00:23:44,597 What? What's so funny? 360 00:23:47,332 --> 00:23:49,597 You're a noble embezzler. That's what's funny. 361 00:23:50,031 --> 00:23:52,797 - That makes you almost likable. - Thanks. 362 00:23:52,799 --> 00:23:55,397 I need 500 more. An advance. 363 00:23:55,698 --> 00:23:56,897 Why? 364 00:23:56,899 --> 00:23:58,977 'Cause I got to get my car out of the shop. 365 00:23:59,031 --> 00:24:01,230 It's been held hostage for the last six months. 366 00:24:03,065 --> 00:24:04,297 I'm going to need a car. 367 00:24:07,764 --> 00:24:08,830 All right. 368 00:24:12,631 --> 00:24:15,297 - You better play ball. - Yeah, yeah, I will. 369 00:24:15,299 --> 00:24:16,397 Go see Ben. 370 00:24:17,065 --> 00:24:18,231 It all starts with him. 371 00:24:18,233 --> 00:24:20,271 No, it all ends with him. He killed them. 372 00:24:21,731 --> 00:24:23,397 I'm serious, Libby, go talk to him... 373 00:24:23,399 --> 00:24:24,730 Fine! I'll talk to him! 374 00:24:25,165 --> 00:24:27,597 Just to prove you freaks wrong. 375 00:24:27,599 --> 00:24:29,930 Make that fat bitch Magda cry. 376 00:24:51,664 --> 00:24:53,697 I think... 377 00:24:53,699 --> 00:24:58,264 I saw Ben as I was standing at the door of my mom's room. 378 00:24:58,898 --> 00:25:02,064 He was threatening her with our shotgun. 379 00:25:38,564 --> 00:25:41,530 Satan encourages you to do what feels good. 380 00:25:41,532 --> 00:25:43,490 Because we're all basically animals. 381 00:25:44,465 --> 00:25:47,231 - Settle down. Quiet. 382 00:25:47,233 --> 00:25:50,897 Benjamin, you do understand this is very serious, don't you? 383 00:26:06,898 --> 00:26:08,197 Hi, Libby. 384 00:26:08,199 --> 00:26:09,197 Hey, Ben. 385 00:26:10,464 --> 00:26:11,964 I never thought I'd see you here. 386 00:26:11,966 --> 00:26:13,964 Yeah well, I never thought I'd come. 387 00:26:13,966 --> 00:26:16,730 Turns out you got a couple of fans outside. 388 00:26:16,732 --> 00:26:19,396 People who take you for the victim, well played. 389 00:26:19,398 --> 00:26:21,563 I thought about you a lot over the years. 390 00:26:23,332 --> 00:26:25,430 Every once in a while, someone tells me about you 391 00:26:25,432 --> 00:26:26,897 but it's not the same. 392 00:26:29,332 --> 00:26:30,830 How's it in there? 393 00:26:30,832 --> 00:26:34,663 I'm fine. Really, I am. I have my high school diploma. 394 00:26:34,665 --> 00:26:37,797 I'm even part way to a college degree. English. 395 00:26:38,298 --> 00:26:40,430 I read fucking Shakespeare now. 396 00:26:45,397 --> 00:26:46,463 Good for you. 397 00:26:50,731 --> 00:26:52,609 Man, Libby, you're so beautiful. 398 00:26:53,464 --> 00:26:54,697 You've got Mom's eyes. 399 00:26:55,131 --> 00:26:56,697 You must hear that all the time. 400 00:26:56,898 --> 00:26:59,597 Who would tell me that? 401 00:26:59,599 --> 00:27:02,663 Runner's gone, don't know where. 402 00:27:02,665 --> 00:27:03,663 Diane's dead. 403 00:27:04,065 --> 00:27:05,363 There's no one. 404 00:27:05,365 --> 00:27:07,430 That's not good. They should've taken better care of you. 405 00:27:07,432 --> 00:27:10,930 You're born again? Hmm? 406 00:27:10,932 --> 00:27:13,264 You found Jesus in there? Why are you being so nice to me? 407 00:27:13,266 --> 00:27:14,563 I'm not that nice, Libby. 408 00:27:14,565 --> 00:27:16,297 I got a lot of anger for a lot of people. 409 00:27:16,299 --> 00:27:18,430 Just, you're not one of them. 410 00:27:23,798 --> 00:27:24,864 What? 411 00:27:28,598 --> 00:27:31,630 You're different. 412 00:27:31,632 --> 00:27:33,550 You're different than I imagined. 413 00:27:36,198 --> 00:27:37,964 You know, we don't have to stay in this room. 414 00:27:37,966 --> 00:27:40,097 This room is designated for death row inmates. 415 00:27:40,099 --> 00:27:41,830 We can be in an open room. 416 00:27:45,198 --> 00:27:47,064 Unless you requested this one? 417 00:27:55,865 --> 00:27:57,297 Remember that horse, Yellow? 418 00:27:57,731 --> 00:27:58,830 Yellow? 419 00:27:59,464 --> 00:28:01,964 The famous horse that refused to be ridden? 420 00:28:01,966 --> 00:28:03,997 - What, did he bite you? - Nothing that dramatic. 421 00:28:03,999 --> 00:28:05,497 Just thought I had a good hold of him, 422 00:28:05,499 --> 00:28:06,930 he threw me against the fence 423 00:28:06,932 --> 00:28:08,997 and slammed my hand against a nail. 424 00:28:10,431 --> 00:28:11,697 Runner been in here? 425 00:28:12,965 --> 00:28:14,164 You know where he is? 426 00:28:14,166 --> 00:28:16,763 The last letter came care of 427 00:28:16,765 --> 00:28:19,530 Bert Nolan's Group Home for Men somewhere in Oklahoma. 428 00:28:19,532 --> 00:28:22,430 He asked me for $500 to carry on his research 429 00:28:22,432 --> 00:28:25,430 on my behalf. Good ol' Runner. 430 00:28:26,865 --> 00:28:28,164 What's the tat on your arm? 431 00:28:28,731 --> 00:28:31,264 Oh, it's a old flame. 432 00:28:32,198 --> 00:28:34,997 We started out as pen pals. 433 00:28:37,865 --> 00:28:40,263 I thought I loved her. Thought we'd get married. 434 00:28:41,397 --> 00:28:43,355 How about you? You got a boyfriend? 435 00:28:45,631 --> 00:28:46,697 Don't do that. 436 00:28:47,631 --> 00:28:51,263 How dare you? You don't get to do that. 437 00:28:51,965 --> 00:28:53,396 Libby, I'm... 438 00:28:53,398 --> 00:28:56,130 No, you don't get to ask me fucking questions. 439 00:28:58,798 --> 00:29:00,797 I mean, here comes my little sister 440 00:29:00,799 --> 00:29:03,197 after all these years. And I'm thinking, 441 00:29:03,199 --> 00:29:05,463 "Maybe this one thing will work out." 442 00:29:06,198 --> 00:29:08,156 Maybe I won't be so fucking lonely. 443 00:29:08,931 --> 00:29:11,330 We can talk about a goddamn horse, 444 00:29:11,332 --> 00:29:12,663 that's all I'm asking for, 445 00:29:12,665 --> 00:29:14,504 something just as tiny as that. 446 00:29:15,065 --> 00:29:16,463 I don't remember the horse. 447 00:29:16,865 --> 00:29:18,097 Yellow? 448 00:29:18,531 --> 00:29:21,296 It was a dirty old farm horse. But it was your horse. 449 00:29:21,298 --> 00:29:22,530 How come I can't remember him? 450 00:29:22,532 --> 00:29:24,930 You were pretty young when Mom had to sell him. 451 00:29:24,932 --> 00:29:27,830 Broke her heart, but she needed the money. 452 00:29:27,832 --> 00:29:29,497 I can tell you all about him. 453 00:29:37,831 --> 00:29:39,296 Go ahead, ask the question. 454 00:29:39,631 --> 00:29:44,763 I don't need to ask. I know you killed them. 455 00:29:44,765 --> 00:29:45,830 No, I did not. 456 00:29:45,832 --> 00:29:49,363 Of course not, I was a teenage boy in a house full of girls. 457 00:29:49,365 --> 00:29:52,396 At school I was the kid that nobody paid attention to. 458 00:29:52,398 --> 00:29:54,296 In that court room, people were scared of me. 459 00:29:54,298 --> 00:29:55,730 I was a bad ass. 460 00:29:55,732 --> 00:29:57,697 A bad ass who killed his family. 461 00:29:57,699 --> 00:29:58,797 Libby, I was a fool, 462 00:29:58,799 --> 00:30:01,964 but I did not kill Mom or Debby or Michelle. 463 00:30:02,165 --> 00:30:04,530 Then why have you never filed for an appeal? 464 00:30:05,965 --> 00:30:07,030 Hmm? 465 00:30:07,032 --> 00:30:10,164 You like it so much in there, you want to stay there? 466 00:30:12,131 --> 00:30:14,663 You know what I think? I think you're full of shit. 467 00:31:02,965 --> 00:31:06,030 You look awesome. Told ya. 468 00:31:14,798 --> 00:31:17,196 You don't think I might be too old for you, huh? 469 00:31:18,898 --> 00:31:21,830 Means that 17 might just be too old for your taste. 470 00:31:23,998 --> 00:31:25,129 Come on. 471 00:31:40,130 --> 00:31:43,096 Come on, Ben. Focus on me. Come on, baby. 472 00:31:44,031 --> 00:31:45,396 Is that all you got? 473 00:31:57,498 --> 00:32:00,497 You know, I saw a couple of friends today at the mall. 474 00:32:01,431 --> 00:32:04,330 You know a little girl named Krissi Cates? 475 00:32:06,798 --> 00:32:09,830 Um, yeah. 476 00:32:09,832 --> 00:32:13,069 She's in that art class I've been helping out with after school. Why? 477 00:32:13,931 --> 00:32:16,463 You never told me about no art class, Ben. 478 00:32:17,564 --> 00:32:20,096 Yeah, well, I'm just helping kids. 479 00:32:20,098 --> 00:32:22,063 One of my old teachers asked me to. 480 00:32:25,231 --> 00:32:27,730 Well, they say the police are looking for ya. 481 00:32:27,732 --> 00:32:30,864 They say you did some naughty things to some little girls. 482 00:32:30,866 --> 00:32:32,705 Everyone's calling you a perv. 483 00:32:33,197 --> 00:32:35,230 What are you talking about? 484 00:32:37,764 --> 00:32:38,830 I love you. 485 00:32:40,164 --> 00:32:41,497 Shh... 486 00:32:46,965 --> 00:32:48,763 The baby's kicking. 487 00:33:02,297 --> 00:33:04,763 It's Aunt Diane! 488 00:33:06,365 --> 00:33:07,630 There are more bags in the car, 489 00:33:07,632 --> 00:33:09,550 with some surprises! Go get them. 490 00:33:13,798 --> 00:33:16,196 - You shouldn't have. - It's what I do. 491 00:33:16,198 --> 00:33:17,663 Are you okay? 492 00:33:18,698 --> 00:33:20,730 The wolves are at the door. 493 00:33:26,965 --> 00:33:28,697 That's too much. 494 00:33:31,231 --> 00:33:32,897 I love the land. 495 00:33:35,598 --> 00:33:37,763 It's like loving your kids. 496 00:33:38,531 --> 00:33:40,430 I know you probably don't know what I mean, 497 00:33:40,432 --> 00:33:42,350 but it's this overwhelming feeling. 498 00:33:43,931 --> 00:33:48,163 Watching it grow and produce. And reproduce. 499 00:33:50,231 --> 00:33:52,063 But you can only work so many hours a day, 500 00:33:52,065 --> 00:33:54,396 and so many days a week, Patty. 501 00:33:54,398 --> 00:33:57,763 All by yourself, you never stood a chance. 502 00:33:57,765 --> 00:33:59,830 You should have done like me and left this place. 503 00:33:59,832 --> 00:34:01,597 You should have gone to college, you're the brains. 504 00:34:01,599 --> 00:34:02,930 It's Mom and Dad's farm. 505 00:34:02,931 --> 00:34:03,963 I know. 506 00:34:05,364 --> 00:34:09,129 It's time to let it go. I don't see Ben. 507 00:34:10,564 --> 00:34:12,597 He left early this morning. 508 00:34:12,599 --> 00:34:14,129 How are things with him? 509 00:34:16,431 --> 00:34:18,063 Difficult. 510 00:34:18,065 --> 00:34:19,063 Where is he? 511 00:34:21,764 --> 00:34:23,563 I don't know, why? 512 00:34:24,698 --> 00:34:27,163 So what do you think, is it a boy or a girl? 513 00:34:30,231 --> 00:34:32,070 I don't know. How would I know? 514 00:34:32,164 --> 00:34:34,430 Oh, so you're saying you don't care. 515 00:34:34,865 --> 00:34:37,396 - No, I do care. - Mmm-hmm. 516 00:34:37,398 --> 00:34:39,996 I was actually thinking of some names if it's a girl. 517 00:34:39,998 --> 00:34:41,497 Well, do you care to share? 518 00:34:41,499 --> 00:34:42,896 Mmm, not yet. 519 00:34:46,165 --> 00:34:48,163 Are you sure Michelle hasn't found out? 520 00:34:49,197 --> 00:34:50,697 She hasn't said anything. 521 00:34:51,197 --> 00:34:53,230 That little weasel. 522 00:34:53,232 --> 00:34:55,163 You know, I swear if I ever get my hands on her... 523 00:34:55,165 --> 00:34:56,497 Shut up. 524 00:34:57,664 --> 00:35:00,430 You know I've promised my Dad, Ben. 525 00:35:00,432 --> 00:35:03,908 He said if he ever found out I wasn't a virgin anymore he'd shoot me in the head. 526 00:35:07,664 --> 00:35:09,396 So you tell your nosy little sister 527 00:35:09,398 --> 00:35:11,396 to stop talking shit about me at school. 528 00:35:11,398 --> 00:35:13,763 - Before he finds out. 529 00:35:13,765 --> 00:35:15,063 Hey, it's Trey! 530 00:35:15,065 --> 00:35:16,996 Quit fucking around and get out of there. 531 00:35:16,998 --> 00:35:18,163 You don't know him, Ben. 532 00:35:18,165 --> 00:35:20,123 You don't know what he's capable of. 533 00:35:27,197 --> 00:35:29,996 You know, I think we should leave town before our parents get back. 534 00:35:30,264 --> 00:35:31,497 Okay. 535 00:35:31,631 --> 00:35:34,630 Really? That easy. 536 00:35:34,632 --> 00:35:37,310 - What? - How are you going to support us? 537 00:35:41,397 --> 00:35:43,430 You'll have to get a job or... 538 00:35:43,432 --> 00:35:45,396 I don't know, ask Runner for money. 539 00:35:45,398 --> 00:35:46,929 Runner? My dad? 540 00:35:46,931 --> 00:35:48,463 Yeah. He makes money, right? 541 00:36:02,631 --> 00:36:05,597 He does handyman stuff, for work, labor... 542 00:36:05,599 --> 00:36:07,563 - He works on farms. - Are you kidding? 543 00:36:07,565 --> 00:36:09,443 Well, yeah, what did you expect? 544 00:36:09,798 --> 00:36:12,563 Trey! Ben doesn't know about his dad! 545 00:36:16,631 --> 00:36:18,363 You sorry sack of shit. 546 00:36:19,431 --> 00:36:22,363 You don't know about your dad? What the fuck, dude? 547 00:36:23,464 --> 00:36:26,263 Hey, Ben. You're smoking your dad's weed, buddy. 548 00:36:26,930 --> 00:36:28,169 What are you guys talking about? 549 00:36:28,297 --> 00:36:31,230 It's crap and he overcharges. Said he got it in Texas. 550 00:36:31,364 --> 00:36:32,896 Let's go find Runner, honey. 551 00:36:33,664 --> 00:36:36,630 So we can get some money. Get the hell out of here. 552 00:36:36,864 --> 00:36:39,296 Teenagers across America are playing 553 00:36:39,298 --> 00:36:41,463 with a new and frightening game. 554 00:36:41,465 --> 00:36:42,663 Satanism. 555 00:36:42,665 --> 00:36:44,796 Their school books are marked up by Satanic symbols. 556 00:36:44,798 --> 00:36:47,063 They are seduced by heavy metal heroes, 557 00:36:47,065 --> 00:36:48,963 many of whom feature Satanic imagery 558 00:36:48,965 --> 00:36:51,530 in their songs and album covers. 559 00:36:51,532 --> 00:36:54,096 The fixation on violence, evil and death 560 00:36:54,098 --> 00:36:56,330 leads them to commit abominable crimes, 561 00:36:56,332 --> 00:36:59,863 including human sacrifice and sexual abuse of children. 562 00:36:59,865 --> 00:37:02,129 We're in the very throes of a new Satanic age... 563 00:37:02,131 --> 00:37:05,630 Everyone at the time. Police, judges, the psychiatric community, 564 00:37:05,632 --> 00:37:07,330 they were seeing Satanists everywhere. 565 00:37:07,332 --> 00:37:08,663 And there weren't? 566 00:37:08,665 --> 00:37:11,196 A few lost, frustrated kids take those lyrics too literally? 567 00:37:11,198 --> 00:37:13,829 Yes, but real criminal Satanists? 568 00:37:14,564 --> 00:37:16,363 What did the investigation say? 569 00:37:16,365 --> 00:37:18,029 The crime scene was contaminated. 570 00:37:18,031 --> 00:37:19,829 People traipsing in and out of the house all day 571 00:37:19,831 --> 00:37:22,463 was against all the rules of police procedure, but no one cared. 572 00:37:22,465 --> 00:37:23,896 They had the perfect culprit, 573 00:37:23,898 --> 00:37:26,296 a strange teenage boy that no one in town liked much 574 00:37:26,298 --> 00:37:28,896 and listened to heavy metal. You know, it was convenient. 575 00:37:30,763 --> 00:37:33,363 I've got the files so you can take a look. 576 00:37:36,730 --> 00:37:39,029 Libby, it's not a request. It's part of the job. 577 00:37:39,031 --> 00:37:42,063 Seriously? It's like you guys want Ben out 578 00:37:42,065 --> 00:37:44,129 more than he does. It's ridiculous. 579 00:37:44,131 --> 00:37:45,263 What did you think of him? 580 00:37:45,265 --> 00:37:46,963 I don't know, Lyle. 581 00:37:46,965 --> 00:37:49,863 Did you ever hear about him with his serious girlfriend? 582 00:37:50,730 --> 00:37:53,597 Molly or Polly? Something like that. 583 00:37:53,897 --> 00:37:55,863 No. It doesn't ring a bell. 584 00:37:56,698 --> 00:37:59,796 It's probably nothing. 585 00:37:59,798 --> 00:38:01,396 He had a tattoo of it on his arm. 586 00:38:01,398 --> 00:38:03,163 It's probably another Magda. 587 00:38:04,631 --> 00:38:06,563 Will you just tell me? 588 00:38:07,697 --> 00:38:09,963 Just tell me, who do you think did it? 589 00:38:09,965 --> 00:38:12,829 I think Lou Cates did it. 590 00:38:12,831 --> 00:38:14,396 Krissi Cates' father. 591 00:38:14,398 --> 00:38:16,396 Found out he had a history of violence, 592 00:38:16,398 --> 00:38:18,356 went to jail for aggravated battery. 593 00:38:21,064 --> 00:38:23,343 You still have no idea who Krissi Cates is, do you? 594 00:38:23,431 --> 00:38:24,563 No. 595 00:38:24,565 --> 00:38:26,029 Libby... 596 00:38:26,031 --> 00:38:28,829 Come on, I know you hate doing this, but could you try? 597 00:38:28,831 --> 00:38:32,463 You're stuck with us anyway, just try. You're smart, 598 00:38:32,465 --> 00:38:35,662 you'll see for yourself that something's not right. Just... 599 00:38:35,664 --> 00:38:37,563 Just take a look at the folder. 600 00:38:38,598 --> 00:38:40,963 Come on, you'll see. Please. 601 00:38:48,097 --> 00:38:52,263 Since I was seven I'd only seen flashes of Ben. 602 00:38:52,265 --> 00:38:55,662 Like some evil entity in a haunted house. 603 00:38:57,598 --> 00:39:02,029 But I'd forgotten there was once just Ben. 604 00:39:02,031 --> 00:39:03,896 My brother. 605 00:39:03,898 --> 00:39:06,563 Shy. Serious. 606 00:39:08,797 --> 00:39:11,196 Couldn't have done what they said. 607 00:39:11,198 --> 00:39:12,629 What I said. 608 00:39:16,197 --> 00:39:21,796 The molestation of Krissi Cates and the murders weren't legally linked. 609 00:39:21,798 --> 00:39:25,896 But everyone had heard the rumors and the jury was surely poisoned against him. 610 00:39:26,397 --> 00:39:28,696 Oddly, 611 00:39:28,698 --> 00:39:32,929 all the little girls backed down and the Cates family never pressed charges. 612 00:39:34,964 --> 00:39:39,430 The Kill Club found Krissi Cates mother in Emporia, Kansas. 613 00:39:39,432 --> 00:39:41,863 But she'd never returned their calls. 614 00:39:43,930 --> 00:39:48,263 You never leave a message for someone you really want to reach. 615 00:39:48,265 --> 00:39:53,129 You keep calling and calling until somebody picks up. 616 00:39:54,298 --> 00:39:58,696 Out of anger, curiosity or just fear. 617 00:39:58,698 --> 00:40:00,096 - Hello? 618 00:40:02,564 --> 00:40:03,629 Hello? 619 00:40:04,231 --> 00:40:06,497 I'm so sorry, did I just wake you up? 620 00:40:06,499 --> 00:40:08,396 I didn't realize how late it was. 621 00:40:08,398 --> 00:40:10,263 I can call back later. 622 00:40:10,265 --> 00:40:11,696 Who is this? 623 00:40:12,663 --> 00:40:16,662 My name is Stephanie Adams, I'm an old friend of Krissi's, 624 00:40:16,664 --> 00:40:19,296 - I was just looking for her... - Christ! You people won't stop calling 625 00:40:19,298 --> 00:40:20,729 until I give you what you want, right? 626 00:40:20,731 --> 00:40:22,963 I have no idea what you're talking about, ma'am. 627 00:40:22,965 --> 00:40:24,729 I'm just an old friend looking for her, 628 00:40:24,731 --> 00:40:26,649 I thought maybe you could help me. 629 00:40:28,864 --> 00:40:30,562 What was your name? Sally? 630 00:40:30,564 --> 00:40:32,729 Yeah, my name is Sally Adams. 631 00:40:32,731 --> 00:40:34,263 Listen, Sally, 632 00:40:34,265 --> 00:40:37,396 I've remarried and I have very little contact with my previous family. 633 00:40:37,398 --> 00:40:38,929 Got it. 634 00:40:38,931 --> 00:40:43,096 You don't by chance have a number for Lou or know where I can find him? 635 00:40:45,498 --> 00:40:49,762 Lou would be in some bar in Kansas, I'd guess. 636 00:40:49,764 --> 00:40:55,596 As for Krissi, drive west on I-70. Just past Columbia. 637 00:40:55,598 --> 00:40:58,929 Take a left into the giant strip club. 638 00:40:58,931 --> 00:41:00,529 You'll find her. 639 00:41:00,531 --> 00:41:02,196 Don't call again. 640 00:41:16,964 --> 00:41:19,662 Mrs. Day. I've called you down to the precinct 641 00:41:19,664 --> 00:41:22,230 due to some serious allegations about your son. 642 00:41:22,232 --> 00:41:24,896 How's he regarded in school? Is he a popular kid? 643 00:41:25,930 --> 00:41:27,010 He has lots of friends. 644 00:41:28,130 --> 00:41:30,363 From what we understand, he's a bit of a loner. 645 00:41:30,365 --> 00:41:31,484 So what does that prove? 646 00:41:32,231 --> 00:41:34,330 You have four children, correct? 647 00:41:34,332 --> 00:41:35,430 Yes. 648 00:41:35,432 --> 00:41:36,529 Same father? 649 00:41:36,864 --> 00:41:37,929 Yes. 650 00:41:39,597 --> 00:41:41,896 Mrs. Day, 651 00:41:41,898 --> 00:41:46,929 we've got four little girls who say that Ben touched them in their private areas. 652 00:41:46,931 --> 00:41:50,363 That he took them to some farm and performed certain... 653 00:41:50,365 --> 00:41:55,163 acts associated with ritualistic Devil worship. 654 00:41:56,930 --> 00:42:00,330 Some farm? Ben doesn't even have a car. 655 00:42:00,332 --> 00:42:01,331 You don't know Ben. 656 00:42:05,264 --> 00:42:08,629 Satanic worship is not uncommon. 657 00:42:08,631 --> 00:42:11,196 It's made its way into all areas of the community, 658 00:42:11,198 --> 00:42:14,996 and part of their rituals involve the degradation of children. 659 00:42:14,998 --> 00:42:16,963 Do you have any evidence? Any witnesses? 660 00:42:16,965 --> 00:42:18,662 Besides some 12-year-old girls... 661 00:42:18,664 --> 00:42:21,029 We got the note Ben left in Krissi Cates' locker. 662 00:42:22,830 --> 00:42:24,330 We need to speak to a lawyer. 663 00:42:24,332 --> 00:42:28,396 You do realize that abuse usually starts at home. 664 00:42:28,398 --> 00:42:34,296 Mrs. Day, with three little girls, 665 00:42:34,298 --> 00:42:37,255 if I were you, I'd want the truth out more than anyone. 666 00:42:42,897 --> 00:42:44,896 - Mrs. Cates? - Yes? 667 00:42:44,898 --> 00:42:47,829 I'm Patty Day. Ben Day's mother. 668 00:42:50,563 --> 00:42:52,596 It's Ben Day's mother. 669 00:42:55,030 --> 00:42:57,462 Can you take these and show me 670 00:42:57,464 --> 00:42:59,163 exactly what happened? 671 00:43:06,331 --> 00:43:07,395 Thank you. 672 00:43:11,763 --> 00:43:13,163 Krissi? 673 00:43:14,763 --> 00:43:16,462 Krissi, I'm Patty Day. 674 00:43:17,497 --> 00:43:18,896 I'm Ben's mom. 675 00:43:21,065 --> 00:43:22,263 I don't want her here. 676 00:43:23,197 --> 00:43:25,363 - I don't want her here! You promised! - Okay. Okay. 677 00:43:25,530 --> 00:43:27,462 We're not safe! 678 00:43:28,030 --> 00:43:30,063 We've heard about you. 679 00:43:30,065 --> 00:43:31,963 Got four kids at home, can't afford one of them! 680 00:43:31,965 --> 00:43:34,696 Their daddy's a drunk, if not worse. 681 00:43:34,698 --> 00:43:36,395 You're on welfare! 682 00:43:36,397 --> 00:43:39,263 Your meals come from a food bank and Jesus Christ, 683 00:43:39,265 --> 00:43:41,362 you've let your son do this! 684 00:43:41,563 --> 00:43:44,963 I hope you're not hiding him. Police are looking for him. 685 00:43:44,965 --> 00:43:46,843 I'm trying to find him, I swear. 686 00:43:46,864 --> 00:43:48,330 Ben is going to hell! 687 00:44:01,930 --> 00:44:02,996 Krissi? 688 00:44:04,463 --> 00:44:05,662 Yeah? 689 00:44:05,664 --> 00:44:07,963 - Do you have time for a little chat? - About what? 690 00:44:07,965 --> 00:44:10,395 To be frank, it's about Ben Day. 691 00:44:10,397 --> 00:44:12,296 - Buy me a drink. - Sure. 692 00:44:17,430 --> 00:44:18,496 Who's this? 693 00:44:18,498 --> 00:44:22,429 This is Libby. She's with me. What can I get you? 694 00:44:23,297 --> 00:44:25,096 Vodka cranberry, double. 695 00:44:25,098 --> 00:44:26,395 Make it two. 696 00:44:26,397 --> 00:44:29,529 So... Ben Day, hmm? 697 00:44:30,297 --> 00:44:31,896 He really fucked up my life. 698 00:44:33,297 --> 00:44:35,295 You maintain you were molested by him? 699 00:44:37,330 --> 00:44:40,662 I was 11 and he was 16. 700 00:44:41,164 --> 00:44:43,322 He started hanging around with me after school. 701 00:44:43,997 --> 00:44:45,063 I got that a lot. 702 00:44:45,430 --> 00:44:47,629 I was a cute kid. And we had lots of money. 703 00:44:48,064 --> 00:44:49,230 Go on. 704 00:44:49,232 --> 00:44:51,462 He would take me into the closet 705 00:44:51,464 --> 00:44:53,796 and make me perform oral sex on him 706 00:44:53,798 --> 00:44:56,129 while making me pledge allegiance to Satan. 707 00:44:57,197 --> 00:44:59,195 Hey, baby, let me get a bag of chips. 708 00:45:01,264 --> 00:45:02,829 You don't mind, do you? 709 00:45:03,697 --> 00:45:06,295 Anyway, Ben was pretty sneaky with me. 710 00:45:06,297 --> 00:45:08,429 I mean, he had an altar in there. 711 00:45:08,431 --> 00:45:11,462 Upside-down cross. Some dead animals. 712 00:45:11,464 --> 00:45:12,896 Sacrificed things. 713 00:45:12,898 --> 00:45:15,729 That's why I thought that he was working his way up to killing me, 714 00:45:15,731 --> 00:45:17,609 but he killed his family instead. 715 00:45:17,897 --> 00:45:19,895 His whole family was devil worshiping. 716 00:45:20,797 --> 00:45:22,295 Um... 717 00:45:22,297 --> 00:45:25,896 How did your dad react when you told him what Ben had done to you? 718 00:45:25,898 --> 00:45:28,629 God, he was so over-protective. He went totally ballistic. 719 00:45:28,864 --> 00:45:31,462 Sometimes I think, had my dad had found Ben, 720 00:45:31,464 --> 00:45:34,096 he would have killed him and Ben's family would still be alive. 721 00:45:34,363 --> 00:45:35,596 Your dad live around here? 722 00:45:36,030 --> 00:45:37,496 No, we lost touch. 723 00:45:38,430 --> 00:45:40,629 Hey, can you lend me 20 bucks? 724 00:45:40,631 --> 00:45:41,896 Can we get your dad's address? 725 00:45:41,898 --> 00:45:44,163 I just told you. That we're out of touch. 726 00:45:44,165 --> 00:45:46,395 - Yeah, I know, but I'm sure there's a way... - Lyle. 727 00:45:46,397 --> 00:45:47,896 Take care of the check. 728 00:45:50,697 --> 00:45:52,129 How much did you say? 729 00:45:53,363 --> 00:45:56,462 You know what, make it 50. I'll totally pay you back. 730 00:45:56,464 --> 00:46:00,863 I'll give you a pen, you can write down your name and address. 731 00:46:02,464 --> 00:46:03,462 Here. 732 00:46:05,497 --> 00:46:07,929 Libby Day. 733 00:46:08,897 --> 00:46:12,163 My name is Libby Day you lying whore. 734 00:46:12,396 --> 00:46:13,462 Don't lose that. 735 00:46:19,798 --> 00:46:21,229 Burt Nolan Home. 736 00:46:21,231 --> 00:46:24,779 Hey, I was looking a Runner, or a Ronald Day. 737 00:46:24,805 --> 00:46:26,629 Is he staying with you? 738 00:46:26,631 --> 00:46:31,096 Well, he's been in and out. But I'd be happy to give him a message. 739 00:46:31,098 --> 00:46:33,996 Could you ask him to call me back? My name's Libby Day. 740 00:46:33,998 --> 00:46:35,896 It's kind of important. 741 00:46:37,530 --> 00:46:41,662 Would you tell him I need to talk to him about Ben and what happened that night? 742 00:46:41,664 --> 00:46:45,229 Ben and that night. Okay. 743 00:46:48,164 --> 00:46:49,896 That night. 744 00:47:14,330 --> 00:47:16,129 That night. 745 00:47:18,064 --> 00:47:20,295 I'd been a sleepwalker since I could walk. 746 00:47:20,297 --> 00:47:23,662 My mom usually didn't move when I got in bed with her. 747 00:47:23,664 --> 00:47:29,496 But, that night, she turned to me and told me she loved me. 748 00:47:31,064 --> 00:47:33,096 She hardly ever told us she loved us. 749 00:47:36,463 --> 00:47:38,195 That's why I remember it. 750 00:47:46,697 --> 00:47:49,662 I can't dwell on these thoughts. 751 00:47:49,664 --> 00:47:54,195 I've labeled these memories as if they were a particularly dangerous region. 752 00:47:55,763 --> 00:47:57,195 Dark place. 753 00:48:12,430 --> 00:48:14,162 Michelle's diary. 754 00:48:15,330 --> 00:48:18,696 I'd forgotten what a rotten busy-body Michelle was. 755 00:48:19,997 --> 00:48:23,796 In her last pages, she kept writing about Ben's girlfriend, Diondra, 756 00:48:23,798 --> 00:48:25,362 as an evil whore. 757 00:48:41,530 --> 00:48:44,863 I don't ever remember Ben ever having a girlfriend. 758 00:48:58,129 --> 00:49:00,662 Diondra Wertzner. 759 00:49:17,430 --> 00:49:19,162 I'm a bad mother. 760 00:49:19,563 --> 00:49:22,128 What are you talking about? 761 00:49:22,130 --> 00:49:24,208 You're Superwoman as far as I'm concerned. 762 00:49:24,497 --> 00:49:27,062 You keep the farm going, you raise four kids, 763 00:49:27,064 --> 00:49:28,395 get them to school every day 764 00:49:28,397 --> 00:49:30,496 and you don't drink a gallon of bourbon to do it. 765 00:49:30,498 --> 00:49:32,162 No, that cop was right. 766 00:49:34,063 --> 00:49:35,996 If things weren't bad at home, 767 00:49:35,998 --> 00:49:37,916 Ben wouldn't be in so much trouble. 768 00:49:42,563 --> 00:49:44,596 Fundamentally he's a good boy. 769 00:49:51,730 --> 00:49:54,028 Sometimes I think it'd be better if I disappeared. 770 00:49:54,030 --> 00:49:55,128 Oh, yeah? 771 00:49:55,130 --> 00:49:56,829 And what about the kids? 772 00:49:57,263 --> 00:49:58,662 They could go with you. 773 00:49:59,563 --> 00:50:02,829 They'd be better off in Kansas City. 774 00:50:04,630 --> 00:50:09,329 Father's a nut job and I'm a failure. 775 00:50:19,630 --> 00:50:20,762 That's Runner's new car. 776 00:50:25,763 --> 00:50:27,429 Do you want me to come in with you? 777 00:50:27,963 --> 00:50:29,462 No, I'll be okay. 778 00:50:30,430 --> 00:50:33,462 Mommy! Daddy's here! 779 00:50:33,464 --> 00:50:35,929 And he brought doughnuts! 780 00:50:41,430 --> 00:50:44,329 Nothing concentrates the attention more 781 00:50:44,331 --> 00:50:46,170 than an animal that can kill you. 782 00:50:48,330 --> 00:50:49,796 Girls, you know you're not supposed 783 00:50:49,798 --> 00:50:51,128 to let anyone in the house when I'm away. 784 00:50:51,130 --> 00:50:53,729 - But, Mom, it's Daddy. - And now Daddy needs to leave. 785 00:50:53,731 --> 00:50:54,729 Come on! 786 00:50:56,029 --> 00:50:57,128 Let's talk! 787 00:51:02,929 --> 00:51:04,262 I'm in no mood, Runner. 788 00:51:04,264 --> 00:51:07,162 Vern Evelee told me. You just sold the tiller. 789 00:51:07,730 --> 00:51:10,395 Yeah, and that money's gone. 790 00:51:10,397 --> 00:51:13,262 That money is gone as quick as I get it. You should know that. 791 00:51:13,264 --> 00:51:15,162 You're never as broke as you say. 792 00:51:17,864 --> 00:51:21,128 I just need enough cash to get to Texas. 793 00:51:21,130 --> 00:51:22,362 I'm sorry, I can't help you. 794 00:51:22,830 --> 00:51:24,629 Patty, I'm in a real jam here. 795 00:51:25,763 --> 00:51:27,128 This is life or death stuff. 796 00:51:27,130 --> 00:51:29,629 Runner... 797 00:51:29,631 --> 00:51:32,562 I am dealing with some really bad stuff. 798 00:51:32,564 --> 00:51:33,662 Oh, really? 799 00:51:33,664 --> 00:51:35,362 Ben is in big trouble. 800 00:51:36,029 --> 00:51:39,128 It's bad. He'll need a lawyer. 801 00:51:40,263 --> 00:51:41,829 So you do have money. 802 00:51:43,196 --> 00:51:44,562 No, I don't. 803 00:51:45,530 --> 00:51:46,829 Lawyers cost money. 804 00:51:47,763 --> 00:51:50,462 Okay, so you got jewelry, don't you? 805 00:51:50,464 --> 00:51:52,128 You got some jewelry, what about that ring I gave you? 806 00:51:52,130 --> 00:51:53,662 - The engagement ring? - Yeah, the engagement ring. 807 00:51:53,664 --> 00:51:56,395 If what was worth anything I would have pawned it off years ago. 808 00:51:56,397 --> 00:51:58,895 What about this? What about this? 809 00:51:58,897 --> 00:52:00,295 Those are real rubies, right? 810 00:52:00,297 --> 00:52:02,262 That is my grandmothers cross and you know how much 811 00:52:02,264 --> 00:52:04,423 that means to me and that stays in my family. 812 00:52:04,497 --> 00:52:07,162 You're going to be really sorry, Patty. 813 00:52:08,530 --> 00:52:10,895 I've been sorry a long time. 814 00:52:28,697 --> 00:52:29,762 Bye, girls. 815 00:52:30,730 --> 00:52:33,862 Your mom is a cunt! 816 00:52:36,396 --> 00:52:38,562 Thanks for fucking nothing! 817 00:53:07,697 --> 00:53:10,329 We don't open for another hour. 818 00:53:12,396 --> 00:53:16,729 Oh, I'm sorry, honey. This is a men's hostel. 819 00:53:16,731 --> 00:53:20,729 I'm looking for someone. Runner Day. Are you the manager? 820 00:53:20,731 --> 00:53:23,496 Manager, accountant, priest. 821 00:53:23,498 --> 00:53:25,095 But he's gone again. 822 00:53:25,097 --> 00:53:28,496 I don't allow drinkers here, and he just got his third strike. 823 00:53:28,498 --> 00:53:29,962 You know where I could find him? 824 00:53:29,964 --> 00:53:33,329 Well, I would bet anything he's living at that toxic waste site. 825 00:53:33,331 --> 00:53:36,995 That's an old dumping spot for grasshopper bait. 826 00:53:36,997 --> 00:53:38,761 Loaded with arsenic. 827 00:53:39,597 --> 00:53:42,329 Just prepare yourself for some disappointment. 828 00:53:49,796 --> 00:53:52,128 I wonder what it said about me? 829 00:53:55,029 --> 00:53:58,429 That my own father was living in a toxic waste dump. 830 00:55:11,963 --> 00:55:13,262 Don't even think about... 831 00:55:13,264 --> 00:55:16,962 Put the gun down! It's your daughter! 832 00:55:19,762 --> 00:55:20,828 Prove it. 833 00:55:23,163 --> 00:55:24,496 I can't prove it. 834 00:55:32,662 --> 00:55:34,995 Well, well, come on down. 835 00:55:44,363 --> 00:55:45,895 Come on down! 836 00:56:00,762 --> 00:56:01,895 No, don't touch me. 837 00:56:01,897 --> 00:56:03,496 - Daddy's got ya. - Get your hands off me! 838 00:56:03,498 --> 00:56:04,761 Remember when you were a little girl? 839 00:56:04,763 --> 00:56:06,661 - No! No! - Say uncle! 840 00:56:06,663 --> 00:56:08,828 - No! Let me go! - Say uncle! 841 00:56:08,830 --> 00:56:10,695 - No! Uncle! - Say uncle! 842 00:56:11,163 --> 00:56:12,262 Fuck! 843 00:56:22,530 --> 00:56:23,595 Jesus. 844 00:56:26,796 --> 00:56:29,229 How long has it been since I've seen you? 845 00:56:31,029 --> 00:56:34,262 Do you remember that flamingo ashtray I sent you? 846 00:56:35,497 --> 00:56:38,728 Yeah, when I was 10 years old and a non-smoker. 847 00:56:38,929 --> 00:56:40,262 Nice, huh? 848 00:56:45,096 --> 00:56:46,995 You know why I'm here, Runner. 849 00:56:49,762 --> 00:56:52,429 It's time you tell the truth about the murders. 850 00:56:58,096 --> 00:57:00,028 Ben was no babe in the woods. 851 00:57:00,030 --> 00:57:03,307 You hang with the devil and sooner or later you're going to have to pay. 852 00:57:04,629 --> 00:57:08,262 I should have known it, as soon as I saw him with that goddamn Injun. 853 00:57:08,264 --> 00:57:10,262 - Who? - Trey Teepano. 854 00:57:13,431 --> 00:57:14,429 You know what... 855 00:57:14,431 --> 00:57:18,761 People don't know shit about what really happened that night. 856 00:57:21,963 --> 00:57:24,062 Who ended up with the money, huh? 857 00:57:25,796 --> 00:57:27,695 'Cause it sure as hell wasn't me. 858 00:57:27,697 --> 00:57:30,429 - You know we had no money. - Your mom had money. 859 00:57:30,431 --> 00:57:31,761 Your queen bitch mom! 860 00:57:33,096 --> 00:57:35,695 What happened to Patty's life insurance money, huh? 861 00:57:35,697 --> 00:57:36,995 Because I sure as shit didn't get it. 862 00:57:36,997 --> 00:57:39,395 You know it went to Diane. She used it to defend Ben. 863 00:57:39,397 --> 00:57:42,695 I worked years on that farm and I never received a dime! 864 00:57:43,096 --> 00:57:45,095 That bitch even asked me for alimony! 865 00:57:47,463 --> 00:57:50,528 Is that what happened? Hmm? 866 00:57:51,996 --> 00:57:54,114 You go there that night, ask her for money? 867 00:57:56,330 --> 00:57:57,528 Get in a fight. 868 00:57:58,662 --> 00:58:00,162 What I'm trying to tell you 869 00:58:00,164 --> 00:58:03,495 is that Trey was a bookie who needed to get paid. 870 00:58:03,829 --> 00:58:05,262 And what, you owed him money? 871 00:58:05,696 --> 00:58:09,395 No, no, no. You want everything for free. 872 00:58:10,796 --> 00:58:14,195 And you wrote that book. You wrote a book, right? 873 00:58:14,197 --> 00:58:15,277 So you have got money! 874 00:58:15,662 --> 00:58:16,928 - I haven't got... - You've got money. 875 00:58:16,930 --> 00:58:18,995 Get your fucking hands off me! 876 00:58:22,463 --> 00:58:23,661 Fuck! 877 00:58:28,296 --> 00:58:30,162 Are you scared of me? 878 00:58:39,996 --> 00:58:42,028 Where were you that night, Runner? 879 00:58:44,096 --> 00:58:45,928 I don't remember a thing. 880 00:59:04,796 --> 00:59:07,561 Hey, did they ever find Diadra? 881 00:59:11,163 --> 00:59:12,528 You mean Diondra? 882 00:59:12,530 --> 00:59:14,862 I always wondered if they killed her that night. 883 00:59:17,029 --> 00:59:18,761 What are you talking about? 884 00:59:19,596 --> 00:59:21,474 That's what they do, don't they? 885 00:59:21,829 --> 00:59:23,528 Devil worshipers? 886 00:59:24,096 --> 00:59:26,895 They kill pregnant ladies and their babies. 887 00:59:40,763 --> 00:59:41,761 You are. 888 00:59:44,796 --> 00:59:46,262 Hey, Runner. 889 00:59:48,929 --> 00:59:49,995 Come here. 890 00:59:49,997 --> 00:59:54,895 I don't have it, man. I tried to scrape it together. 891 00:59:54,897 --> 00:59:56,795 I did, but I just don't. 892 00:59:56,797 --> 00:59:58,895 Hey, honey. You gonna say hi to me? 893 00:59:58,897 --> 01:00:01,561 Oh, Diondra. 894 01:00:01,563 --> 01:00:03,128 I must be oblivious here, 895 01:00:03,130 --> 01:00:05,828 I'm drinking myself cross-eyed because I'm so worried about this situation. 896 01:00:05,830 --> 01:00:07,062 See, I don't get it Runner. 897 01:00:07,064 --> 01:00:08,329 You say you don't have any money, 898 01:00:08,331 --> 01:00:10,862 but you had that giant stack of weed just a few weeks ago. 899 01:00:10,864 --> 01:00:12,229 I didn't charge you nothin'. 900 01:00:13,096 --> 01:00:14,561 Because you owe me! 901 01:00:14,696 --> 01:00:16,761 You guys love to gamble, but you never want to pay! 902 01:00:16,763 --> 01:00:19,095 I'd say that's an exaggeration, Trey. 903 01:00:19,097 --> 01:00:21,628 I know someone else who needs money. 904 01:00:24,662 --> 01:00:26,028 God. 905 01:00:26,030 --> 01:00:28,428 Look at this black hair you have. 906 01:00:28,696 --> 01:00:30,895 I didn't know you knew Trey. You owe him money? 907 01:00:31,263 --> 01:00:32,828 No, I don't owe him anything. 908 01:00:33,296 --> 01:00:36,262 - He wants money for his girl. - Tomorrow night. 909 01:00:36,863 --> 01:00:41,095 Here. Or so help me, Runner, I will hurt you. 910 01:00:44,496 --> 01:00:46,414 Hey, I want to tell you something. 911 01:00:46,963 --> 01:00:48,162 What? 912 01:00:48,164 --> 01:00:51,162 I got Diondra... She's... 913 01:00:52,196 --> 01:00:54,595 I got her pregnant. We're having a baby. 914 01:00:58,462 --> 01:00:59,795 Make sure it's yours. 915 01:01:01,163 --> 01:01:03,062 Okay. 'Cause I doubt it is. 916 01:01:05,496 --> 01:01:06,928 Look... 917 01:01:06,930 --> 01:01:08,928 Why would a rich slut like her 918 01:01:08,930 --> 01:01:10,862 hang around a loser like you? 919 01:01:13,163 --> 01:01:14,495 Think about it. 920 01:01:29,196 --> 01:01:30,595 You okay, baby? 921 01:01:33,196 --> 01:01:34,928 Someone should fucking die. 922 01:01:38,629 --> 01:01:39,895 You got anything? 923 01:01:41,929 --> 01:01:43,528 In the glove compartment. 924 01:01:59,696 --> 01:02:01,062 What is that stuff? 925 01:02:01,496 --> 01:02:03,661 Devil's rush. Ever had it? 926 01:02:13,362 --> 01:02:14,862 Come on. 927 01:02:14,864 --> 01:02:16,229 No, man. I don't need it. 928 01:02:16,231 --> 01:02:19,394 You're gonna need it, do it. Maybe later you become a man? 929 01:02:20,429 --> 01:02:21,728 Maybe. 930 01:02:21,730 --> 01:02:23,695 Come on, baby. Come on. 931 01:02:28,496 --> 01:02:29,795 Yeah! 932 01:02:33,163 --> 01:02:34,862 No, I want the axe! 933 01:02:34,864 --> 01:02:36,328 Too heavy for you. 934 01:02:41,762 --> 01:02:44,195 It's sharp, so don't fuck around. 935 01:03:00,496 --> 01:03:03,561 To Satan, we bring our sacrifices. 936 01:03:04,295 --> 01:03:07,394 - We bring pain, blood, fear... 937 01:03:08,829 --> 01:03:09,995 Rage. 938 01:03:09,997 --> 01:03:11,328 Basis of human life. 939 01:03:12,829 --> 01:03:15,895 In your power, we become more powerful. 940 01:03:16,429 --> 01:03:17,495 That one! 941 01:03:18,662 --> 01:03:22,062 In your exaltation, we become exalted. 942 01:03:25,463 --> 01:03:29,162 We're going to make your baby a fucking warrior tonight, Dio! 943 01:03:36,796 --> 01:03:38,361 Come on, baby! 944 01:03:38,363 --> 01:03:41,481 You can't just fucking stand there, it's time to get your kill! 945 01:03:43,362 --> 01:03:45,661 This is your chance, dude. Be a man! 946 01:03:45,996 --> 01:03:47,394 I used to be like you. 947 01:03:47,963 --> 01:03:50,041 I don't ever want to go back there again! 948 01:03:50,529 --> 01:03:53,895 Don't be a scared, dickless boy the rest of your life! 949 01:03:53,897 --> 01:03:55,895 Aren't you tired of being scared? Huh? 950 01:03:56,629 --> 01:03:57,728 Come on! 951 01:04:04,696 --> 01:04:07,161 - You trust Runner over me? - I don't trust anyone. 952 01:04:07,429 --> 01:04:10,261 How much? How much money are they paying you? 953 01:04:11,262 --> 01:04:12,761 I don't know what you're talking about. 954 01:04:12,763 --> 01:04:14,127 What, you thought I didn't know about that? 955 01:04:14,129 --> 01:04:15,328 Yeah, I got paid. 956 01:04:15,496 --> 01:04:16,995 It's not about that anymore. 957 01:04:16,997 --> 01:04:18,294 What is it about, the truth? 958 01:04:18,429 --> 01:04:19,995 Listen, there's no way you can win this. 959 01:04:19,997 --> 01:04:23,928 If I tell you I'm innocent, that means you ruined my life, sister. 960 01:04:24,395 --> 01:04:25,661 And if I tell you I'm guilty, 961 01:04:25,663 --> 01:04:27,062 well, that doesn't make you feel much better now... 962 01:04:27,064 --> 01:04:28,828 - Where's Diondra? - Oh, let it go. I have. 963 01:04:28,830 --> 01:04:30,161 What'd you do with the baby, Ben? 964 01:04:30,163 --> 01:04:31,328 What baby? 965 01:04:31,829 --> 01:04:33,095 Are you going to keep bullshitting me? 966 01:04:33,097 --> 01:04:34,127 Let it go, Libby. 967 01:04:34,329 --> 01:04:35,595 What about Trey Teepano? 968 01:04:35,729 --> 01:04:37,928 He said what he had to say on the witness stand. 969 01:04:38,696 --> 01:04:39,761 That's too easy. 970 01:04:41,496 --> 01:04:46,761 You listen to me. Today, I can forgive your past lie. 971 01:04:47,662 --> 01:04:49,728 For being confused as a kid. 972 01:04:50,562 --> 01:04:52,795 But god damn it, you're a grown up now. 973 01:04:53,229 --> 01:04:55,728 Do you really think that our blood could do something like that? 974 01:04:55,730 --> 01:04:58,328 I totally believe our blood could do something like that. 975 01:04:58,330 --> 01:05:00,761 I've beaten the shit out of people, Ben. 976 01:05:00,763 --> 01:05:03,680 I've busted in doors and windows, I've killed things! 977 01:05:06,329 --> 01:05:08,608 Half the time I look down and my hands are in fists. 978 01:05:10,896 --> 01:05:13,127 Do you really believe we're that bad? 979 01:05:13,129 --> 01:05:14,127 I do. 980 01:05:14,662 --> 01:05:15,962 Even with Mom's blood. 981 01:05:18,362 --> 01:05:19,201 Even with. 982 01:05:22,429 --> 01:05:24,294 Then I'm sad for you, little girl. 983 01:05:24,296 --> 01:05:25,294 Go fuck yourself! 984 01:05:26,596 --> 01:05:29,561 - Is that funny to you? - No. It's ironic. 985 01:05:29,563 --> 01:05:30,728 What? 986 01:05:31,496 --> 01:05:33,962 You're just as imprisoned as I am. 987 01:06:10,929 --> 01:06:12,261 It's okay, sweetie. 988 01:06:12,263 --> 01:06:15,361 No, it's not. I want Ben back. 989 01:06:15,363 --> 01:06:18,994 Why can't we find him? Is he in trouble because of his hair? 990 01:06:19,963 --> 01:06:22,495 No, it's because of sex. Everyone at school knows. 991 01:06:23,863 --> 01:06:25,161 What are you talking about? 992 01:06:27,929 --> 01:06:30,094 Ben is your brother, you don't talk hateful about your brother. 993 01:06:30,096 --> 01:06:32,994 But Mom, I don't like Ben! He's bad... 994 01:06:32,996 --> 01:06:34,728 He does bad things! 995 01:06:39,562 --> 01:06:43,328 Has he ever touched you in a strange way or an unbrotherly way? 996 01:06:43,729 --> 01:06:47,161 The only time he touches me is when he's pushing me or pulling my hair. 997 01:06:47,429 --> 01:06:48,761 Mom, he's a freak! 998 01:06:49,062 --> 01:06:50,828 It's embarrassing, just go in his room, 999 01:06:50,830 --> 01:06:52,748 he's got all sorts of weird stuff. 1000 01:06:53,362 --> 01:06:54,728 You snooped in his room? 1001 01:08:17,429 --> 01:08:19,561 - Hello? - Patty? 1002 01:08:19,563 --> 01:08:21,761 It's Joseph, from the FHA. 1003 01:08:21,763 --> 01:08:25,261 Joseph, I can't find the money. I've had a rough day. 1004 01:08:25,263 --> 01:08:27,695 Yes, I heard about Ben. 1005 01:08:27,697 --> 01:08:32,528 I wasn't going to phone you. But how should I say this. Patty, I trust you. 1006 01:08:32,530 --> 01:08:36,428 I pray for you. I may have a solution to your problem. 1007 01:08:37,295 --> 01:08:39,795 I thought we were out of options. 1008 01:08:40,062 --> 01:08:41,595 Not entirely. 1009 01:08:44,028 --> 01:08:45,495 - Yeah. - Libby, Libby. 1010 01:08:45,497 --> 01:08:46,961 We found Diondra Sue Wertzner. 1011 01:08:46,963 --> 01:08:48,927 Born on March 28th, 1968. 1012 01:08:48,929 --> 01:08:53,828 Was officially reported missing on October 19th, 1985, and has never been found. 1013 01:08:53,830 --> 01:08:56,261 So what the fuck does that mean? She's dead? 1014 01:08:56,263 --> 01:08:59,300 I don't know, we can't be sure. But did Ben tell you anything? 1015 01:09:01,196 --> 01:09:02,194 Hang on. 1016 01:09:16,229 --> 01:09:19,595 Hey, told you I'd pay you back. 1017 01:09:21,262 --> 01:09:23,961 When I saw your name on that note... 1018 01:09:23,963 --> 01:09:25,795 I should have recognized you right away, 1019 01:09:25,797 --> 01:09:28,595 but I kinda followed your story, 1020 01:09:28,597 --> 01:09:30,261 but it's been such a long time ago. 1021 01:09:30,263 --> 01:09:31,294 What do you want? 1022 01:09:34,029 --> 01:09:36,661 You're not gonna make this easy for me, are you? 1023 01:09:39,429 --> 01:09:40,528 Fair enough. 1024 01:09:43,295 --> 01:09:45,695 I was a pretty girl. 1025 01:09:45,697 --> 01:09:48,595 I was good in school, and Ben... 1026 01:09:48,597 --> 01:09:50,794 He did volunteer work. 1027 01:09:50,796 --> 01:09:52,328 He gave drawing lessons. 1028 01:09:53,262 --> 01:09:54,861 I had a big crush on him. 1029 01:09:56,095 --> 01:09:58,561 We started hanging out together. 1030 01:09:58,563 --> 01:10:01,661 I know we were both kids, but he was old enough. 1031 01:10:01,663 --> 01:10:02,961 To not have encouraged me. 1032 01:10:08,062 --> 01:10:10,561 It was my first big grown-up kiss. 1033 01:10:11,496 --> 01:10:14,161 It only lasted about a second. 1034 01:10:14,163 --> 01:10:18,228 And afterwards, of course, he told me that we should never do it again, 1035 01:10:18,230 --> 01:10:19,495 'cause it was wrong. 1036 01:10:21,395 --> 01:10:24,061 But he kept writing me notes. 1037 01:10:24,063 --> 01:10:26,428 But he refused to spend any more time with me. 1038 01:10:27,395 --> 01:10:29,961 - And I was furious. 1039 01:10:29,963 --> 01:10:34,760 Then, about a week later I went to a slumber party 1040 01:10:34,762 --> 01:10:37,428 and I told all the girls about my high school boyfriend. 1041 01:10:38,329 --> 01:10:42,595 All proud. And I made up things that we did. 1042 01:10:43,562 --> 01:10:46,495 And from there it just snowballed. 1043 01:10:46,497 --> 01:10:48,727 We made up this whole imaginary world, 1044 01:10:48,729 --> 01:10:50,827 where Ben was a devil worshiper. 1045 01:10:51,696 --> 01:10:55,661 Kind of stories we saw on the news every day when we were kids. 1046 01:11:21,162 --> 01:11:22,428 Ma'am. 1047 01:11:24,695 --> 01:11:27,861 Your son is about to be arrested, and I know what for. 1048 01:11:27,863 --> 01:11:29,994 In this next year you will need some money 1049 01:11:29,996 --> 01:11:32,027 so you can keep your children at home. 1050 01:11:32,029 --> 01:11:33,907 And you will need a good lawyer. 1051 01:11:34,229 --> 01:11:37,661 'Cause you don't want your son going to prison labeled a child molester. 1052 01:11:38,295 --> 01:11:39,794 What do you have to offer? 1053 01:11:41,062 --> 01:11:43,194 Now I myself was once a farmer. 1054 01:11:43,196 --> 01:11:45,428 My dad before me and his dad before him. 1055 01:11:46,395 --> 01:11:48,495 But we farmers, we'd been swindled. 1056 01:11:48,497 --> 01:11:51,294 "Plant fence post to fence post," they said. 1057 01:11:51,296 --> 01:11:52,927 "Oh, and then buy more land, because," 1058 01:11:52,929 --> 01:11:54,967 "well, they ain't making any more of it." 1059 01:11:55,295 --> 01:11:59,495 Then, whoops. "We're sorry, we gave you some bad advice." 1060 01:12:00,262 --> 01:12:01,927 "We'll just take your farm." 1061 01:12:03,229 --> 01:12:05,495 What does this have to do with my son? 1062 01:12:07,597 --> 01:12:08,961 Ma'am. 1063 01:12:08,963 --> 01:12:12,660 I'm no businessman. And I'm no judge. 1064 01:12:14,195 --> 01:12:15,961 I'm certainly no politician. 1065 01:12:16,795 --> 01:12:19,294 But if you're brave enough. 1066 01:12:19,296 --> 01:12:21,961 I'll give you a real chance to help your family. 1067 01:13:42,229 --> 01:13:43,794 Your brother needs you, Libby. 1068 01:13:43,796 --> 01:13:46,461 He doesn't, and he's been pretty clear about that. 1069 01:13:46,463 --> 01:13:49,660 Now that you've explored the case with all its inconsistencies, 1070 01:13:49,662 --> 01:13:52,495 don't you think that Ben deserves a new, fair trial? 1071 01:13:53,028 --> 01:13:56,261 Based on what evidence? What do we know for sure? 1072 01:13:56,263 --> 01:13:57,961 He's lying about Diondra. Why? 1073 01:13:57,963 --> 01:14:01,261 But, everybody's a liar. I lied to get you to KC. 1074 01:14:02,329 --> 01:14:04,294 You lied when you said you saw what happened that day, 1075 01:14:04,296 --> 01:14:05,495 it doesn't make us murderers. 1076 01:14:05,962 --> 01:14:08,294 What makes you so sure I lied? 1077 01:14:11,995 --> 01:14:15,294 Why are you so obsessed with this case? 1078 01:14:15,296 --> 01:14:17,428 It's not even your story, it's mine. 1079 01:14:19,362 --> 01:14:23,361 It's a fascinating puzzle, a mystery with lots of different theories. 1080 01:14:23,363 --> 01:14:26,560 Most of all, there's you and Ben and Krissi. 1081 01:14:27,128 --> 01:14:30,794 Kids who started events that became bigger than them and had major repercussions. 1082 01:14:31,661 --> 01:14:34,061 - I'm fascinated by that. - Why? 1083 01:14:38,862 --> 01:14:42,461 You ever heard about those wildfires near San Bernardino in 1999? 1084 01:14:42,463 --> 01:14:45,594 They destroyed, like, 80 homes and about 90,000 acres? 1085 01:14:46,395 --> 01:14:49,061 I don't know, seems like California is always burning. 1086 01:14:50,462 --> 01:14:52,861 I was the kid who set that fire. 1087 01:14:57,028 --> 01:14:59,261 Then shouldn't you have become a firefighter or something, 1088 01:14:59,263 --> 01:15:01,428 overcome your trauma that way? 1089 01:15:07,962 --> 01:15:09,294 So, did you? 1090 01:15:09,661 --> 01:15:10,727 Did I what? 1091 01:15:11,495 --> 01:15:13,460 Did you lie that day in court? 1092 01:15:32,828 --> 01:15:34,061 Hello! 1093 01:15:40,495 --> 01:15:41,727 Hello? 1094 01:15:51,495 --> 01:15:53,174 - Can I help you? - Hey. 1095 01:15:53,295 --> 01:15:55,134 We're looking for Trey Teepano. 1096 01:15:55,728 --> 01:15:57,228 That'd be me. 1097 01:15:57,230 --> 01:15:59,988 Want to talk to you about Ben Day. My brother. 1098 01:16:13,329 --> 01:16:16,261 You're the one who lived, huh? Debbie? 1099 01:16:16,828 --> 01:16:18,061 Libby. 1100 01:16:18,895 --> 01:16:20,527 You remember Runner Day? 1101 01:16:21,561 --> 01:16:24,438 He said you were a bookie or something, back then. 1102 01:16:24,461 --> 01:16:26,627 Yeah. Runner owed me a lot of money. 1103 01:16:28,561 --> 01:16:30,393 Still does, I guess, huh. 1104 01:16:32,362 --> 01:16:35,027 It doesn't mean I know what happened in your house that night. 1105 01:16:35,362 --> 01:16:37,201 You were into devil worshiping? 1106 01:16:37,295 --> 01:16:41,061 I'm reformed now. I'm a good God-fearin' Indian. 1107 01:16:44,329 --> 01:16:46,294 You remember Diondra Wertzner? 1108 01:16:47,995 --> 01:16:49,861 Your brother. 1109 01:16:49,863 --> 01:16:51,901 Your brother was crazy about that girl. 1110 01:16:52,295 --> 01:16:56,061 Parents neglected her, so she was always creating drama. 1111 01:16:56,063 --> 01:16:58,061 She'd run away, come back home. 1112 01:16:58,063 --> 01:16:59,460 Total soap opera. 1113 01:16:59,828 --> 01:17:02,027 This time, I guess, she just ran away for good, huh? 1114 01:17:02,029 --> 01:17:05,261 She's been listed as a missing person for 25 years. 1115 01:17:05,695 --> 01:17:07,393 Yeah, she was one of them girls 1116 01:17:07,395 --> 01:17:09,094 who was always trying to be someone else. 1117 01:17:09,096 --> 01:17:13,393 She'd talk in an English accent one day and next day it'd be Southern. 1118 01:17:14,128 --> 01:17:16,027 She liked to use her porn name, too. 1119 01:17:16,029 --> 01:17:17,560 - She did porn? - No. 1120 01:17:17,562 --> 01:17:21,061 It was that game. What was the name of your childhood pet? 1121 01:17:24,329 --> 01:17:26,894 And what was the name of the street you grew up on? 1122 01:17:26,896 --> 01:17:28,027 Rural Route 2. 1123 01:17:30,394 --> 01:17:32,061 Well, that's not going to work. 1124 01:17:32,063 --> 01:17:34,127 It's supposed to sound slutty. 1125 01:17:34,129 --> 01:17:37,427 You know, like Bambi Evergreen. What was Diondra's... 1126 01:17:37,429 --> 01:17:39,427 It was, uh, Polly something... 1127 01:17:41,628 --> 01:17:43,061 Polly Palm. 1128 01:17:44,628 --> 01:17:47,460 What was the name your brother had tattooed on his arm? 1129 01:17:47,462 --> 01:17:49,861 - Oh, my God! - It was Polly, right? 1130 01:17:51,561 --> 01:17:54,061 I got her. Polly Palm in Kearney, Missouri. 1131 01:17:54,063 --> 01:17:55,694 The only one listed in the whole country 1132 01:17:55,696 --> 01:17:57,734 apart for a nail boutique in Shreveport. 1133 01:18:12,394 --> 01:18:15,094 Something like me, with open arms, I tell you... 1134 01:18:17,695 --> 01:18:21,293 I don't feel good. I think I need something to eat. 1135 01:18:26,294 --> 01:18:27,560 What? 1136 01:18:29,461 --> 01:18:31,094 You're fucked. 1137 01:18:32,662 --> 01:18:35,228 Hey, Dio, it's Megan. I'm totally freaked out about Ben Day. 1138 01:18:35,230 --> 01:18:37,267 Did you hear he molested all these girls? 1139 01:18:38,929 --> 01:18:42,194 Hey, Diondra, it's Jenny. I hear Ben's running from the cops. 1140 01:18:42,196 --> 01:18:45,527 You're not with him, are you? Please tell me you're not with him. 1141 01:18:54,828 --> 01:18:56,094 I guess I should go home. 1142 01:18:56,096 --> 01:18:58,027 Okay, and what? 1143 01:18:58,695 --> 01:19:00,613 Leave me here while you go to jail? 1144 01:19:00,795 --> 01:19:02,027 What do you want me to do? 1145 01:19:02,029 --> 01:19:03,228 We're leaving town tonight. 1146 01:19:03,229 --> 01:19:05,094 I have like $200 left from my parents. 1147 01:19:05,096 --> 01:19:07,014 How much do you have at your place? 1148 01:19:08,162 --> 01:19:09,293 I've got some saved up. 1149 01:19:09,295 --> 01:19:11,961 My mom, she's got, like, 500 or 600 lying around. 1150 01:19:12,394 --> 01:19:13,827 But I don't know where. 1151 01:19:13,829 --> 01:19:15,267 Yeah, all right we'll go there. Okay. 1152 01:19:15,728 --> 01:19:18,027 If we don't see a cop car outside, we'll go inside, 1153 01:19:18,029 --> 01:19:19,961 we'll get the cash, we'll pack a bag 1154 01:19:19,963 --> 01:19:21,727 and we'll get the fuck out of here, okay? 1155 01:19:21,962 --> 01:19:24,927 Then what? What fucking planet are you on? 1156 01:19:25,862 --> 01:19:27,780 Are you even sure this kid's mine? 1157 01:19:28,628 --> 01:19:30,627 How dare you! 1158 01:19:39,995 --> 01:19:41,260 Ben. 1159 01:19:43,028 --> 01:19:45,694 Ben, baby, I love you, you know. 1160 01:19:46,795 --> 01:19:48,393 And I swear to God this child's yours. 1161 01:19:48,395 --> 01:19:50,760 I swear to God, but you got to get me out of town, okay? 1162 01:19:50,762 --> 01:19:53,927 And we gotta head west. Otherwise you're in jail. 1163 01:19:55,028 --> 01:19:56,694 You're in jail and I'm dead from my daddy. 1164 01:19:56,696 --> 01:20:00,061 He'll make me have the baby, then he'll kill me. 1165 01:20:35,128 --> 01:20:36,293 Yeah? 1166 01:20:38,328 --> 01:20:40,061 You know who I am? 1167 01:20:43,328 --> 01:20:45,560 Holy crap! Libby. 1168 01:20:46,995 --> 01:20:49,193 I always thought you'd find me someday. 1169 01:20:49,728 --> 01:20:51,193 Smart girl. 1170 01:20:53,528 --> 01:20:54,760 Stay! 1171 01:20:55,528 --> 01:20:57,794 So, this is out of the blue. 1172 01:20:57,796 --> 01:20:59,754 I mean, why come looking for me now? 1173 01:21:00,194 --> 01:21:01,727 Did Ben say something to you? 1174 01:21:02,695 --> 01:21:04,460 No, that's why I'm here. 1175 01:21:04,462 --> 01:21:07,694 So you think that once you know the truth, 1176 01:21:07,696 --> 01:21:09,126 you'll find peace? 1177 01:21:09,495 --> 01:21:11,627 Like, somehow that will fix you? 1178 01:21:17,228 --> 01:21:18,727 I was with Ben that night. 1179 01:21:20,661 --> 01:21:23,027 We were going to skip town. 1180 01:21:23,029 --> 01:21:26,093 And he went to his house to get some money. 1181 01:21:26,095 --> 01:21:28,061 An hour goes by, two hours. 1182 01:21:29,062 --> 01:21:31,293 Finally, I thought he lost his nerve. 1183 01:21:32,461 --> 01:21:34,460 Cried myself to sleep that night. 1184 01:21:37,194 --> 01:21:41,193 In the morning, when I heard about the murders. 1185 01:21:42,695 --> 01:21:45,494 Packed my bags, left a note for my father 1186 01:21:45,496 --> 01:21:48,126 telling him I was not his little girl anymore. 1187 01:21:49,695 --> 01:21:51,861 Skipped town for good. 1188 01:21:51,863 --> 01:21:54,427 Ben never gave my name to the police. 1189 01:21:57,194 --> 01:21:58,760 After all these years. 1190 01:22:00,194 --> 01:22:01,861 He protected me. 1191 01:22:08,361 --> 01:22:11,238 So, no one but him knows what happened that night. 1192 01:22:11,995 --> 01:22:14,794 I do think you that you could find this peace 1193 01:22:14,796 --> 01:22:17,393 that you're looking for if you accept that. 1194 01:22:18,328 --> 01:22:20,260 Look, I hate to say this, 1195 01:22:20,262 --> 01:22:23,694 but whatever happened, and as much as I loved Ben, 1196 01:22:26,194 --> 01:22:28,861 he needed to be in that prison. 1197 01:22:28,863 --> 01:22:31,126 There was something inside your brother 1198 01:22:31,128 --> 01:22:33,260 that was not right for the outside world. 1199 01:22:41,394 --> 01:22:43,193 You were pregnant. 1200 01:22:48,661 --> 01:22:50,293 What happened to the baby? 1201 01:22:51,394 --> 01:22:52,794 I'm here. 1202 01:23:34,361 --> 01:23:37,227 What are you doing? I told you to wait in the car. 1203 01:23:39,528 --> 01:23:41,527 I know you did, but... 1204 01:23:43,027 --> 01:23:45,126 Baby, I'm hearing voices in my head. 1205 01:23:45,128 --> 01:23:46,293 Shh, Shh. You got to be quiet, okay. 1206 01:23:46,295 --> 01:23:47,427 I don't want to be alone. 1207 01:23:47,429 --> 01:23:48,861 I know. 1208 01:23:48,863 --> 01:23:50,980 It's just the drugs. They'll wear off, okay. 1209 01:23:53,561 --> 01:23:54,894 I like your house. 1210 01:24:02,695 --> 01:24:03,894 Be quiet. 1211 01:24:14,828 --> 01:24:16,460 What's going on? 1212 01:24:17,294 --> 01:24:18,794 Somebody's been in my room. 1213 01:24:20,461 --> 01:24:21,694 Oh, God. You don't... 1214 01:24:23,328 --> 01:24:25,894 You don't think it's the cops, do you? 1215 01:24:25,896 --> 01:24:27,026 I don't know. 1216 01:24:28,561 --> 01:24:30,861 I got a present for you, for the baby. 1217 01:24:34,294 --> 01:24:36,727 - You got me a present? - Yeah, but it's not here. 1218 01:24:41,128 --> 01:24:42,960 Who is that? 1219 01:24:42,962 --> 01:24:45,360 It's okay, it's just Libby, she's going into Mom's room. 1220 01:25:03,728 --> 01:25:05,527 There's less than I thought. 1221 01:25:06,394 --> 01:25:08,393 I fucking know it was Michelle. 1222 01:25:10,528 --> 01:25:13,766 It was Michelle that stole my fucking present, that nosy little bitch. 1223 01:25:19,661 --> 01:25:21,694 This doesn't feel right. 1224 01:25:31,628 --> 01:25:33,694 I knew it! I heard everything! 1225 01:25:33,696 --> 01:25:34,694 Come here! 1226 01:25:35,828 --> 01:25:37,126 Get out of my way. 1227 01:25:38,528 --> 01:25:40,646 You don't say another word, you little bitch! 1228 01:25:40,695 --> 01:25:42,126 Stop! Stop! She's not gonna say anything. 1229 01:25:42,128 --> 01:25:43,427 Ben, get off me. 1230 01:25:43,894 --> 01:25:44,960 Come here. 1231 01:25:51,127 --> 01:25:52,860 Diondra, stop it! Stop! 1232 01:25:55,061 --> 01:25:57,460 Dio, stop. You'll wake up the whole fucking house. 1233 01:25:57,462 --> 01:25:59,260 If you think I'm going to spend my entire fucking life 1234 01:25:59,262 --> 01:26:01,293 worrying about this little bitch, you're wrong, Ben! 1235 01:26:01,295 --> 01:26:03,794 Get off of her. Dio, stop. Listen to me. 1236 01:26:04,328 --> 01:26:06,567 We'll talk to her, okay? She'll understand. Stop. 1237 01:26:08,194 --> 01:26:09,260 Ben? 1238 01:26:10,161 --> 01:26:11,926 Hey! It's okay. Okay? 1239 01:26:22,027 --> 01:26:24,527 I was never supposed to meet you. 1240 01:26:25,961 --> 01:26:27,393 I'm a secret, you know. 1241 01:26:31,361 --> 01:26:33,093 A secret love child. 1242 01:26:34,361 --> 01:26:35,694 That's right, baby. 1243 01:26:36,294 --> 01:26:39,260 Crystal knows the whole story. I tell her everything. 1244 01:26:39,628 --> 01:26:40,926 We're best friends. 1245 01:26:41,961 --> 01:26:43,393 I read your book, too. 1246 01:26:44,861 --> 01:26:48,026 I even have a little scrapbook of photos of all of you. 1247 01:26:48,994 --> 01:26:50,594 Clipped out of magazines and stuff. 1248 01:26:50,596 --> 01:26:53,126 It's like a fake family photo album. 1249 01:26:58,294 --> 01:27:00,126 Can I call you Aunt Libby? 1250 01:27:03,161 --> 01:27:06,393 I know that this is a lot to take in. 1251 01:27:09,461 --> 01:27:10,727 Want a drink? 1252 01:27:12,495 --> 01:27:16,893 - I need to use your bathroom. - It's just up the stairs. 1253 01:27:36,161 --> 01:27:37,494 - Yeah? - Libby. 1254 01:27:37,496 --> 01:27:39,734 Libby, I know the whole story now. You need to hear this. 1255 01:27:39,961 --> 01:27:41,120 What are you talking about? 1256 01:27:41,394 --> 01:27:42,960 You remember the theory the Kill Club had 1257 01:27:42,962 --> 01:27:45,280 about the serial killer they called the Angel of Debt? 1258 01:27:45,294 --> 01:27:46,826 Yeah? 1259 01:27:46,828 --> 01:27:48,227 They got him, I mean, we got him. 1260 01:27:48,229 --> 01:27:50,460 One of our members posed as a bankrupt 1261 01:27:50,462 --> 01:27:52,627 hedge fund manager in a suburb of Chicago 1262 01:27:52,629 --> 01:27:55,527 and this guy Calvin Diehl, tried to help him stage his death. 1263 01:27:55,529 --> 01:27:56,860 Diehl used to be a farmer 1264 01:27:56,862 --> 01:27:58,860 who lost everything to the banks in the Soviet embargo. 1265 01:27:58,862 --> 01:28:00,060 So what? 1266 01:28:00,062 --> 01:28:01,693 He's been at it since the '80s. 1267 01:28:01,695 --> 01:28:04,293 Making suicides look like accidents or murders. 1268 01:28:04,727 --> 01:28:06,685 What the fuck are you talking about? 1269 01:28:07,394 --> 01:28:09,860 Your mother had hired him for that night. 1270 01:28:13,495 --> 01:28:14,926 Are you sure? 1271 01:28:18,027 --> 01:28:21,060 Listen, Lyle, can you come get me? 1272 01:28:21,827 --> 01:28:23,026 Okay. 1273 01:28:23,861 --> 01:28:25,327 - Libby? - Yeah? 1274 01:28:25,329 --> 01:28:26,494 Is everything okay? 1275 01:28:26,496 --> 01:28:28,454 Yeah, I'm fine. I just need a second. 1276 01:28:30,027 --> 01:28:32,193 I'm sorry, but I really need to go. 1277 01:28:32,195 --> 01:28:34,026 I'll be out in a second, okay? 1278 01:28:40,428 --> 01:28:41,726 Fuck! 1279 01:29:11,061 --> 01:29:12,726 Libby? 1280 01:29:14,027 --> 01:29:16,826 Yeah. Yeah, I'm coming. 1281 01:29:28,827 --> 01:29:30,327 You okay? 1282 01:29:30,329 --> 01:29:31,659 Yeah, I'm fine. 1283 01:29:32,861 --> 01:29:35,594 Listen, I'm gonna wait outside, my friend is coming for me. 1284 01:29:35,596 --> 01:29:38,384 I really need you to keep this a secret, okay? 1285 01:29:38,410 --> 01:29:39,393 I can't risk it. 1286 01:29:39,395 --> 01:29:41,593 Them thinking I'm an accomplice, you understand? 1287 01:29:41,927 --> 01:29:45,560 Why would they think that? Were you at the house that night? 1288 01:29:52,861 --> 01:29:53,993 No! 1289 01:30:35,827 --> 01:30:39,260 Don't worry, it'll all be over in about 30 seconds. 1290 01:30:42,694 --> 01:30:44,160 Go tell Mom. 1291 01:30:44,162 --> 01:30:45,427 Come here! 1292 01:30:45,429 --> 01:30:46,926 Get the fuck off her! 1293 01:30:52,094 --> 01:30:53,360 What the hell? 1294 01:30:53,362 --> 01:30:55,494 Mom, they're hurting Michelle! 1295 01:30:55,660 --> 01:30:57,726 Run! Run! 1296 01:31:01,660 --> 01:31:03,093 No! No, please don't! 1297 01:31:03,428 --> 01:31:04,559 No! 1298 01:31:07,429 --> 01:31:09,093 - Why'd you make me do this? 1299 01:31:09,095 --> 01:31:11,133 - Don't do it. No! - This wasn't the plan. 1300 01:31:13,362 --> 01:31:14,593 Get the fuck off of her. 1301 01:31:26,694 --> 01:31:28,093 Oh, my God! 1302 01:32:00,460 --> 01:32:03,993 Mom, I'm sorry. I saw the cross was gone and I panicked. 1303 01:32:03,995 --> 01:32:05,260 It's okay, sweetie. 1304 01:32:05,262 --> 01:32:07,826 Go get the gun. It's in the cabinet. 1305 01:32:10,361 --> 01:32:12,227 Where is it? I can't find it! 1306 01:32:12,229 --> 01:32:14,060 - It's in the box on the left side. 1307 01:32:14,062 --> 01:32:15,427 I'm looking there, Mom, it's not there. 1308 01:32:15,429 --> 01:32:17,526 - Well, look harder! - I am looking! 1309 01:32:26,094 --> 01:32:27,659 What did you do to her? 1310 01:32:29,527 --> 01:32:32,060 - I'm calling the police. - Wait, listen. 1311 01:32:32,062 --> 01:32:34,060 She wouldn't shut up, all right? 1312 01:32:34,062 --> 01:32:35,693 It's her fault, she wouldn't shut up! 1313 01:32:35,695 --> 01:32:38,493 Where's the little one? 1314 01:32:38,827 --> 01:32:42,327 Oh, shit! Libby! Libby! 1315 01:32:44,660 --> 01:32:46,360 It's gotta be in here! 1316 01:32:46,362 --> 01:32:47,826 I know it's here! 1317 01:32:51,694 --> 01:32:52,860 Stop yelling at me! 1318 01:32:52,862 --> 01:32:55,061 How am I supposed to find anything in this crap? 1319 01:32:55,594 --> 01:32:58,360 - I see it, it's right there. - Okay, where are the bullets? 1320 01:32:58,362 --> 01:32:59,426 Where are the bullets? 1321 01:32:59,428 --> 01:33:01,126 No, it's loaded, it's fine! 1322 01:33:01,128 --> 01:33:02,559 Mom! Mom! 1323 01:33:11,494 --> 01:33:12,693 Libby? 1324 01:33:37,660 --> 01:33:38,860 Fuck. 1325 01:33:59,294 --> 01:34:01,252 Hey, hey! Let me do it! Let me do it! 1326 01:34:03,161 --> 01:34:04,726 Bitch blocked the door! 1327 01:34:05,794 --> 01:34:07,026 Christ! 1328 01:34:08,194 --> 01:34:09,326 Can you squeeze through? 1329 01:34:24,261 --> 01:34:26,299 - Oh, my God! She got out! - Grab the gun! 1330 01:34:35,927 --> 01:34:37,227 Damn it! 1331 01:34:40,527 --> 01:34:42,426 Libby! Libby! 1332 01:34:42,428 --> 01:34:46,359 Ben, if she saw something, we got a problem! Ben, baby... 1333 01:34:46,361 --> 01:34:48,392 - What? - Don't you see how this isn't a coincidence? 1334 01:34:48,394 --> 01:34:50,060 We need money, then we do the ritual and then, pow! 1335 01:34:50,062 --> 01:34:51,493 Someone kills your entire family! 1336 01:34:51,495 --> 01:34:52,893 What are you talking about? 1337 01:34:53,494 --> 01:34:55,726 You inherit all your mom's life insurance! 1338 01:34:55,728 --> 01:34:57,926 Whatever you want to do, baby, you want to go to California, 1339 01:34:57,928 --> 01:35:00,693 you want to live on the beach, we can do it! Together! 1340 01:35:04,293 --> 01:35:06,759 If you want me to, I can take care of her myself. 1341 01:35:09,594 --> 01:35:11,260 No, I'll get her. 1342 01:36:20,193 --> 01:36:23,359 Mom, we're not going to find her. She could be anywhere by now. 1343 01:36:24,494 --> 01:36:26,093 She can't be far. 1344 01:36:26,095 --> 01:36:30,060 Her friend is coming. What if he called the cops? We have to go. 1345 01:36:32,694 --> 01:36:34,326 What if they find us? 1346 01:36:50,660 --> 01:36:54,726 Libby? Stay where you are, sweetheart, okay. Stay there. 1347 01:37:48,861 --> 01:37:49,926 Libby! 1348 01:37:55,260 --> 01:37:56,493 Libby! 1349 01:38:06,293 --> 01:38:08,092 I love you, Libby. 1350 01:38:10,126 --> 01:38:11,893 I love you, ladybug. 1351 01:38:12,594 --> 01:38:14,759 Don't you ever forget that. 1352 01:38:18,561 --> 01:38:19,893 Libby! 1353 01:38:23,660 --> 01:38:24,926 Libby! 1354 01:38:29,527 --> 01:38:31,359 Libby, you okay? What happened? 1355 01:38:31,361 --> 01:38:32,359 Where are they? 1356 01:38:33,360 --> 01:38:35,438 There's no one here, I checked the house. 1357 01:38:36,194 --> 01:38:38,526 It's okay. Everything's okay. 1358 01:38:46,293 --> 01:38:48,659 Diondra Wertzner, also known as Polly Palm 1359 01:38:48,661 --> 01:38:50,926 was arrested last night in Amarillo, Texas. 1360 01:38:50,928 --> 01:38:55,392 This is the latest development in the 1985 Kansas Prairie Massacre case. 1361 01:38:55,394 --> 01:38:59,026 Ms. Wertzner was wanted in relation to the murder of Michelle Day 1362 01:38:59,028 --> 01:39:00,593 for which Ben Day, her brother, 1363 01:39:00,595 --> 01:39:03,526 has been in prison for the last 28 years. 1364 01:39:03,528 --> 01:39:07,426 She denies any involvement while DNA analysis is pending. 1365 01:39:07,428 --> 01:39:09,159 But it was announced this morning that Ben Day 1366 01:39:09,161 --> 01:39:11,426 will be released from prison shortly. 1367 01:39:11,428 --> 01:39:14,259 Their daughter, Crystal, is still at large. 1368 01:39:14,261 --> 01:39:17,326 As a reminder, this is the latest twist in a larger case, 1369 01:39:17,328 --> 01:39:19,159 that of serial killer Calvin Diehl, 1370 01:39:19,161 --> 01:39:22,226 aka the Angel of Debt who has killed, 1371 01:39:22,228 --> 01:39:25,259 or as he claims, "Helped to die in dignity," 1372 01:39:25,261 --> 01:39:28,292 more than 50 people since the early 1980s. 1373 01:39:28,294 --> 01:39:31,025 He had each of his victims sign what he termed 1374 01:39:31,027 --> 01:39:33,159 a "permission to kill" form 1375 01:39:33,161 --> 01:39:35,192 along with a letter to loved ones. 1376 01:39:39,360 --> 01:39:42,759 Dear Ben, Michelle, Libby and Debby. 1377 01:39:42,761 --> 01:39:45,459 I don't think this letter will ever reach you. 1378 01:39:45,461 --> 01:39:48,159 But Mr. Diehl said he'd hold it for me. 1379 01:39:48,161 --> 01:39:51,426 And I guess that gives me some comfort. 1380 01:39:51,428 --> 01:39:55,159 Your grandparents always told me, "Make a useful life." 1381 01:39:55,161 --> 01:39:59,159 I don't think I've really done that, but I can make a useful death. 1382 01:40:00,160 --> 01:40:03,926 My life has been determined so much by accidents. 1383 01:40:03,928 --> 01:40:07,025 It seems nice now that an accident on purpose 1384 01:40:07,027 --> 01:40:09,226 will make things right again. 1385 01:40:10,026 --> 01:40:12,159 I hope you all forgive me. 1386 01:40:13,660 --> 01:40:16,359 Take care of yourselves. 1387 01:40:16,361 --> 01:40:18,693 I know Diane will do right by you. 1388 01:40:19,260 --> 01:40:21,359 I'm only sad I won't get to see 1389 01:40:21,361 --> 01:40:23,259 the wonderful people you've become. 1390 01:40:24,427 --> 01:40:26,759 Although I don't need to. 1391 01:40:26,761 --> 01:40:28,600 That's how sure I am of my kids. 1392 01:40:56,427 --> 01:40:59,464 Diondra was always sure you'd find her. She was sure of it. 1393 01:41:00,427 --> 01:41:02,226 Guess she was right. 1394 01:41:05,827 --> 01:41:07,493 So you met my daughter. 1395 01:41:10,861 --> 01:41:11,925 Mmm-hmm. 1396 01:41:12,827 --> 01:41:14,992 I've heard different things. Is she... 1397 01:41:15,794 --> 01:41:18,192 Is she like Diondra? Is she bad? 1398 01:41:20,327 --> 01:41:21,992 I don't know. 1399 01:41:23,627 --> 01:41:25,125 How does a girl deal with the fact 1400 01:41:25,127 --> 01:41:26,687 that she knows her mother is a murderer? 1401 01:41:26,960 --> 01:41:30,025 She can't disappear for long, I can find her. 1402 01:41:30,760 --> 01:41:33,159 She's not going to go to jail because of me. 1403 01:41:36,527 --> 01:41:38,092 You'd really give her a pass? 1404 01:41:38,094 --> 01:41:39,392 I know a little bit about people 1405 01:41:39,394 --> 01:41:43,025 trying to do the right thing and completely fucking up. 1406 01:41:43,027 --> 01:41:45,092 Are you talking about me or Mom? 1407 01:41:45,094 --> 01:41:46,892 I'm talking about me. 1408 01:41:47,627 --> 01:41:49,705 You could've been talking about any of us. 1409 01:41:50,293 --> 01:41:52,925 28 years I've been shutting up and taking it. 1410 01:41:54,594 --> 01:41:57,493 28 years I've been protecting a kid that I never met. 1411 01:41:58,193 --> 01:42:00,326 By leaving her with your sister's murderer? 1412 01:42:00,328 --> 01:42:01,726 I never said I did the right thing, 1413 01:42:01,728 --> 01:42:03,593 but I made a choice and I had to live with it. 1414 01:42:03,595 --> 01:42:05,759 Yeah, I had to live with it, too. 1415 01:42:07,126 --> 01:42:10,759 But I do wish there was something I could say to make it better. 1416 01:42:11,893 --> 01:42:14,092 There's nothing left to say. 1417 01:42:15,760 --> 01:42:18,459 You lied. I lied. 1418 01:42:21,860 --> 01:42:22,925 We're even. 1419 01:42:30,594 --> 01:42:32,125 What about us? 1420 01:42:35,594 --> 01:42:37,593 You don't know me, Ben. 1421 01:42:38,460 --> 01:42:40,859 You think you do, but you don't. 1422 01:42:42,227 --> 01:42:44,793 Just like I don't know you. 1423 01:42:46,794 --> 01:42:49,659 Or Mom. Or Debby, or Michelle. 1424 01:42:53,193 --> 01:42:55,426 Whatever sliver of a memory I had of them 1425 01:42:55,428 --> 01:42:57,192 died with them that night. 1426 01:43:03,260 --> 01:43:05,659 I'm so angry at you. 1427 01:43:13,360 --> 01:43:15,526 But you're still my brother. 1428 01:43:17,527 --> 01:43:19,426 You're still my blood. 1429 01:43:20,960 --> 01:43:24,159 I won't let what happened that night, drive my life anymore. 1430 01:43:27,460 --> 01:43:29,526 I just want to be normal. 1431 01:43:34,893 --> 01:43:39,925 I'm sorry. I'm sorry, Libby. I'm sorry. 1432 01:43:56,060 --> 01:43:58,326 You know that horse you were talking about, Yellow? 1433 01:43:58,328 --> 01:43:59,659 Yeah, what about him? 1434 01:44:01,793 --> 01:44:03,626 I don't get it. 1435 01:44:05,193 --> 01:44:06,626 Why Yellow? 1436 01:44:09,060 --> 01:44:11,259 I don't know. Mom named him. 1437 01:44:11,261 --> 01:44:14,326 It's not like he was a yellow horse or anything. 1438 01:44:15,726 --> 01:44:18,259 I guess she'll keep that secret with her, huh? 1439 01:44:18,261 --> 01:44:20,593 There's a lot of other stories, Libby. 1440 01:44:21,393 --> 01:44:25,292 Beautiful ones. Wasn't all bad, you know. 1441 01:44:31,759 --> 01:44:34,459 I didn't get straight on the highway. 1442 01:44:34,461 --> 01:44:37,626 But slowly drove to where our farm had once been. 1443 01:44:39,926 --> 01:44:44,992 Still standing. That unsafe place. 1444 01:44:47,926 --> 01:44:52,159 That blanked-out space where my mother so desperately invited death. 1445 01:45:02,759 --> 01:45:04,593 Maybe Ben was right. 1446 01:45:07,893 --> 01:45:09,292 It wasn't all bad. 1447 01:45:19,693 --> 01:45:23,459 Ben learned something in his prison that I never learned in mine. 1448 01:45:31,726 --> 01:45:33,326 Forgiveness. 1449 01:45:40,193 --> 01:45:44,159 My mom told us to make a useful life. 1450 01:45:47,860 --> 01:45:49,326 Nothing big. 1451 01:45:54,893 --> 01:45:56,493 Nothing grand. 1452 01:45:58,494 --> 01:46:00,059 Just a start. 1453 01:46:04,826 --> 01:46:07,526 Finally, a start.