1
00:00:01,250 --> 00:00:04,750
[MUSIC PLAYING]

2
00:01:01,250 --> 00:01:04,708
[COLLECTiVE-AMC]

3
00:01:13,208 --> 00:01:13,792
OK.

4
00:01:14,750 --> 00:01:15,292
You ready?

5
00:01:28,833 --> 00:01:29,542
It's beautiful.

6
00:01:30,750 --> 00:01:31,583
Where'd you find this?

7
00:01:31,833 --> 00:01:32,583
It's cute, right?

8
00:01:33,833 --> 00:01:35,250
Oh, I love this.

9
00:01:35,875 --> 00:01:36,375
So cute.

10
00:01:38,625 --> 00:01:39,375
It's perfect.

11
00:01:43,292 --> 00:01:48,500
It would have been a lot for me.

12
00:01:49,417 --> 00:01:49,917
Thank you.

13
00:01:53,500 --> 00:01:54,000
It's perfect.

14
00:01:55,500 --> 00:01:56,083
You're perfect.

15
00:01:59,250 --> 00:01:59,708
Thank you.

16
00:02:00,042 --> 00:02:00,375
Of course.

17
00:02:04,750 --> 00:02:05,500
They here already?

18
00:02:06,542 --> 00:02:07,917
They're like 30 minutes early.

19
00:02:08,250 --> 00:02:09,042
Why are they-- what?

20
00:02:10,000 --> 00:02:10,417
It's OK.

21
00:02:16,083 --> 00:02:16,583
I love it.

22
00:02:17,292 --> 00:02:17,500
Yeah.

23
00:02:18,708 --> 00:02:19,750
I'll be honest, Ally and I,

24
00:02:19,833 --> 00:02:21,125
we weren't sure about whether

25
00:02:21,208 --> 00:02:22,042
to have this party.

26
00:02:22,833 --> 00:02:24,375
But together, there's

27
00:02:24,458 --> 00:02:25,375
nothing we can't overcome.

28
00:02:25,458 --> 00:02:26,583
You're the strongest woman I know.

29
00:02:26,958 --> 00:02:28,083
I love you more than anything.

30
00:02:29,042 --> 00:02:30,167
And I'm so damn excited to

31
00:02:30,250 --> 00:02:31,750
keep building our lives together.

32
00:02:32,125 --> 00:02:32,500
Me too.

33
00:02:33,125 --> 00:02:33,708
I love you.

34
00:02:33,792 --> 00:02:34,042
Love you.

35
00:02:35,708 --> 00:02:36,458
[APPLAUSE]

36
00:02:36,542 --> 00:02:39,250
Thank you all for being here.

37
00:02:39,708 --> 00:02:42,250
Thank you.

38
00:02:43,750 --> 00:02:44,500
Vitamins are on the table.

39
00:02:44,708 --> 00:02:45,917
Oh, thank you, baby.

40
00:02:49,917 --> 00:02:50,583
This is a nice party.

41
00:02:51,458 --> 00:02:52,500
Think I've heard at a good time?

42
00:02:52,833 --> 00:02:53,042
Yeah.

43
00:02:53,667 --> 00:02:54,333
You deserve it.

44
00:02:56,250 --> 00:02:57,000
You're just buttering me

45
00:02:57,083 --> 00:02:58,417
up before you abandon me.

46
00:02:59,292 --> 00:03:00,417
I wish I could delay it again.

47
00:03:01,833 --> 00:03:02,208
I know.

48
00:03:02,375 --> 00:03:03,417
I don't want to leave you here.

49
00:03:03,500 --> 00:03:04,833
You just go to the judge

50
00:03:04,917 --> 00:03:06,167
and tell him something wildly

51
00:03:06,250 --> 00:03:07,875
inappropriate, and then come back to me.

52
00:03:08,458 --> 00:03:08,875
I will.

53
00:03:09,167 --> 00:03:09,667
Oh, you will?

54
00:03:10,250 --> 00:03:10,875
Oh, you will?

55
00:03:11,042 --> 00:03:11,625
Like what?

56
00:03:11,875 --> 00:03:12,667
I'll say--

57
00:03:12,875 --> 00:03:13,125
What?

58
00:03:13,375 --> 00:03:14,000
I'll say we're having a

59
00:03:14,083 --> 00:03:15,292
big old orgy tomorrow night,

60
00:03:15,375 --> 00:03:16,167
and they're all invited.

61
00:03:17,250 --> 00:03:17,542
Ow.

62
00:03:18,125 --> 00:03:18,875
Oh, no, no, no.

63
00:03:18,958 --> 00:03:19,167
Be careful.

64
00:03:19,250 --> 00:03:19,542
All right.

65
00:03:19,708 --> 00:03:20,583
That got me too excited.

66
00:03:22,750 --> 00:03:22,792
[LAUGHTER]

67
00:03:22,833 --> 00:03:23,250
I'm OK.

68
00:03:25,667 --> 00:03:25,875
Hey.

69
00:03:26,958 --> 00:03:27,000
Sorry.

70
00:03:27,417 --> 00:03:27,875
Sorry, sorry.

71
00:03:30,542 --> 00:03:34,542
[MUSIC PLAYING]

72
00:03:37,458 --> 00:03:38,958
Just a reminder, send in

73
00:03:39,042 --> 00:03:40,250
those mail-in ballots soon.

74
00:03:40,833 --> 00:03:41,750
For only two weeks out

75
00:03:41,833 --> 00:03:42,958
from election day, folks,

76
00:03:43,125 --> 00:03:44,208
and every ballot matters.

77
00:03:44,625 --> 00:03:45,458
So be sure to get

78
00:03:45,542 --> 00:03:46,583
yours in before it's done.

79
00:03:51,458 --> 00:03:52,375
Faith, come on.

80
00:03:52,458 --> 00:03:53,167
I'm polling has she

81
00:03:53,250 --> 00:03:54,542
had a 46-point death log,

82
00:03:54,792 --> 00:03:56,375
with 8% of voters still undecided.

83
00:03:56,917 --> 00:03:57,792
We need to push her

84
00:03:57,875 --> 00:03:58,833
plan to reduce the crime

85
00:03:58,917 --> 00:04:00,042
rate in order to pull ahead.

86
00:04:00,125 --> 00:04:01,625
This case is my campaign.

87
00:04:02,000 --> 00:04:03,625
He's a dangerous criminal with a long

88
00:04:03,708 --> 00:04:04,458
history of violence.

89
00:04:04,958 --> 00:04:06,250
I put James side the way.

90
00:04:06,333 --> 00:04:06,542
You win.

91
00:04:06,917 --> 00:04:07,917
You'll lose your shot at being DA.

92
00:04:08,250 --> 00:04:08,708
I gotta go.

93
00:04:24,250 --> 00:04:24,417
Hey.

94
00:04:24,875 --> 00:04:25,250
Excuse me.

95
00:04:26,083 --> 00:04:27,875
You, uh, dropped this.

96
00:04:28,875 --> 00:04:30,042
Oh, I did.

97
00:04:30,333 --> 00:04:30,750
Oh, my god.

98
00:04:31,042 --> 00:04:31,417
Thank you.

99
00:04:31,500 --> 00:04:31,917
You were last-saver.

100
00:04:32,250 --> 00:04:32,542
No worries.

101
00:04:32,833 --> 00:04:33,292
Have a good day.

102
00:04:33,375 --> 00:04:33,917
Yeah, you too.

103
00:04:38,375 --> 00:04:43,583
Where do I go for a jury duty?

104
00:04:43,667 --> 00:04:44,167
I'm going to go down there.

105
00:04:46,625 --> 00:04:47,250
Thanks.

106
00:04:52,458 --> 00:04:52,625
Bye.

107
00:05:03,042 --> 00:05:03,792
All right, guys.

108
00:05:04,083 --> 00:05:04,542
Eyes up.

109
00:05:05,458 --> 00:05:06,167
Pay attention.

110
00:05:08,458 --> 00:05:08,667
Hello.

111
00:05:09,167 --> 00:05:10,375
I'd like to welcome you as

112
00:05:10,458 --> 00:05:11,792
a juror in the Georgia court

113
00:05:11,875 --> 00:05:12,292
system.

114
00:05:12,917 --> 00:05:14,375
As a juror, you protect

115
00:05:14,458 --> 00:05:15,667
the right of every person

116
00:05:15,750 --> 00:05:16,958
to a trial by jury.

117
00:05:17,667 --> 00:05:19,708
The right to a trial by jury is a

118
00:05:19,792 --> 00:05:21,250
cornerstone of our democracy.

119
00:05:21,917 --> 00:05:23,917
That right is protected by the United

120
00:05:24,000 --> 00:05:25,208
States Constitution.

121
00:05:28,125 --> 00:05:28,833
There she is.

122
00:05:29,500 --> 00:05:30,750
Sugar-free vanilla with skin.

123
00:05:30,833 --> 00:05:31,458
Oh, you're good.

124
00:05:31,875 --> 00:05:32,667
Can I get you something else?

125
00:05:33,500 --> 00:05:34,333
You got something for me?

126
00:05:35,292 --> 00:05:35,542
OK.

127
00:05:35,792 --> 00:05:37,000
Voluntary manslaughter with a

128
00:05:37,083 --> 00:05:38,208
recommendation of 20 years,

129
00:05:38,292 --> 00:05:39,083
15 to serve, followed

130
00:05:39,167 --> 00:05:39,875
by five for probation.

131
00:05:40,208 --> 00:05:40,417
Wow.

132
00:05:40,625 --> 00:05:41,625
That's a hell of a deal.

133
00:05:41,708 --> 00:05:43,458
I won't even waive the recidivism statute

134
00:05:43,542 --> 00:05:44,917
if you please before I strike the jury.

135
00:05:45,208 --> 00:05:46,625
I admit to something he didn't do.

136
00:05:47,917 --> 00:05:48,833
Save it for the jury.

137
00:05:49,583 --> 00:05:50,708
Better yet, why don't

138
00:05:50,792 --> 00:05:52,083
you plead your guy out

139
00:05:52,167 --> 00:05:53,875
and save a pre-free figure case loan?

140
00:05:55,042 --> 00:05:58,250
Look, my client wants a trial.

141
00:05:59,208 --> 00:06:00,375
Well, then, you're wasting

142
00:06:00,458 --> 00:06:01,708
my time and your clients.

143
00:06:02,500 --> 00:06:02,958
Last chance.

144
00:06:05,333 --> 00:06:05,750
After you.

145
00:06:14,375 --> 00:06:15,208
The case you're about to

146
00:06:15,292 --> 00:06:16,875
hear is an alleged homicide.

147
00:06:18,208 --> 00:06:20,208
The state is charging James Michael

148
00:06:20,292 --> 00:06:23,125
Seith with malice murder for the death of

149
00:06:23,208 --> 00:06:24,708
Kendall Alice Carter.

150
00:06:25,875 --> 00:06:28,167
Now, if you have a personal relationship

151
00:06:28,417 --> 00:06:30,542
with the accused and or the deceased that

152
00:06:30,625 --> 00:06:32,583
will prohibit you from serving on this

153
00:06:32,667 --> 00:06:33,833
panel in an unbiased

154
00:06:33,958 --> 00:06:36,250
manner, please speak now.

155
00:06:44,667 --> 00:06:44,958
Yes.

156
00:06:49,042 --> 00:06:50,042
He used to ride my bus.

157
00:06:51,917 --> 00:06:52,542
And when was this?

158
00:06:55,000 --> 00:06:55,958
I don't know, a few years ago.

159
00:06:57,292 --> 00:06:57,500
OK.

160
00:06:57,792 --> 00:06:58,542
Then there's no reason

161
00:06:58,625 --> 00:06:59,667
we can't leave it there.

162
00:07:01,042 --> 00:07:02,167
I think you'll make a fine juror.

163
00:07:03,333 --> 00:07:05,917
Does anyone else think that they're

164
00:07:06,000 --> 00:07:08,417
incapable of serving on this panel?

165
00:07:10,208 --> 00:07:10,500
Yes.

166
00:07:14,125 --> 00:07:15,417
Your Honor, my wife is

167
00:07:15,500 --> 00:07:16,125
in the third trimester

168
00:07:16,333 --> 00:07:17,500
of a high-risk pregnancy.

169
00:07:18,333 --> 00:07:19,542
I'd like to be available to her.

170
00:07:20,625 --> 00:07:21,417
Well, that's commendable.

171
00:07:22,292 --> 00:07:23,958
What hours do you normally work?

172
00:07:25,750 --> 00:07:26,625
Nine to six, typically.

173
00:07:27,292 --> 00:07:28,250
And you have my word

174
00:07:28,333 --> 00:07:29,500
that this court will not

175
00:07:29,583 --> 00:07:31,000
demand one minute more

176
00:07:31,083 --> 00:07:32,708
of your time than that.

177
00:07:33,958 --> 00:07:37,583
See, the fact that you

178
00:07:37,667 --> 00:07:38,750
don't want to be here

179
00:07:38,833 --> 00:07:40,458
is exactly what makes

180
00:07:40,542 --> 00:07:42,042
you the perfect group

181
00:07:42,208 --> 00:07:43,292
to adjudicate this case.

182
00:07:45,000 --> 00:07:46,000
You are impartial.

183
00:07:46,333 --> 00:07:47,208
You have no skin in the

184
00:07:47,292 --> 00:07:48,875
game, nothing to gain or lose.

185
00:07:50,000 --> 00:07:51,083
And that is why I believe

186
00:07:51,167 --> 00:07:53,417
that this process, as flawed

187
00:07:53,625 --> 00:07:55,917
as it may be, is still our

188
00:07:56,000 --> 00:07:58,000
best chance at finding justice.

189
00:08:01,208 --> 00:08:02,458
Do you work, Mrs. Allworth?

190
00:08:03,542 --> 00:08:05,292
Well, I had a toughest job there is.

191
00:08:05,375 --> 00:08:06,250
I raised two kids and just

192
00:08:06,333 --> 00:08:07,042
sent them off to college.

193
00:08:07,375 --> 00:08:08,125
Ah, congratulations.

194
00:08:08,583 --> 00:08:09,000
Thank you.

195
00:08:09,375 --> 00:08:09,958
And have you ever

196
00:08:10,042 --> 00:08:11,083
served on a jury before?

197
00:08:12,250 --> 00:08:13,583
Twice, both were Ms. Charles.

198
00:08:14,833 --> 00:08:16,208
Twice, OK, OK.

199
00:08:16,917 --> 00:08:18,542
Mr. King, have you ever

200
00:08:18,625 --> 00:08:20,250
had a physical altercation

201
00:08:20,500 --> 00:08:21,583
with a significant other?

202
00:08:22,500 --> 00:08:23,125
Are you going to ask

203
00:08:23,208 --> 00:08:24,208
that question to every guy

204
00:08:24,292 --> 00:08:24,792
in this courtroom?

205
00:08:27,125 --> 00:08:28,250
If I have to, I will.

206
00:08:28,708 --> 00:08:30,208
I know these questions

207
00:08:30,292 --> 00:08:31,875
can be very personal.

208
00:08:31,958 --> 00:08:32,500
Nah, man.

209
00:08:33,667 --> 00:08:34,125
Any me.

210
00:08:37,792 --> 00:08:38,292
Thank you, sir.

211
00:08:41,000 --> 00:08:41,750
How long have you lived in

212
00:08:41,833 --> 00:08:43,000
the area, Mr. Tchaikovsky?

213
00:08:43,458 --> 00:08:44,167
About 10 years.

214
00:08:45,375 --> 00:08:47,625
You-- oh, you run a flower shop?

215
00:08:48,250 --> 00:08:49,250
Yeah, with my wife.

216
00:08:50,083 --> 00:08:51,625
Mr. Robinson, it says here your wife

217
00:08:51,708 --> 00:08:53,750
has primary custody of your daughter.

218
00:08:54,458 --> 00:08:54,958
Is that correct?

219
00:08:58,833 --> 00:08:59,000
Yeah.

220
00:09:00,667 --> 00:09:01,333
Do you mind if I ask you

221
00:09:01,417 --> 00:09:02,125
who ended the marriage?

222
00:09:04,917 --> 00:09:05,208
She did.

223
00:09:07,000 --> 00:09:07,333
Thank you.

224
00:09:07,875 --> 00:09:08,250
All you.

225
00:09:08,917 --> 00:09:10,500
Mr. Camp.

226
00:09:12,125 --> 00:09:13,208
And you're a magazine writer.

227
00:09:13,833 --> 00:09:14,167
That's right.

228
00:09:14,708 --> 00:09:15,917
What kind of articles do you write?

229
00:09:16,625 --> 00:09:17,250
Features mostly.

230
00:09:17,875 --> 00:09:19,292
So you write about a variety of topics?

231
00:09:19,583 --> 00:09:19,833
Yes.

232
00:09:20,875 --> 00:09:22,125
Ever written about a murder trial?

233
00:09:24,292 --> 00:09:24,875
Well, I write for

234
00:09:24,958 --> 00:09:26,875
regional lifestyle magazines.

235
00:09:27,250 --> 00:09:28,250
It's not exactly Vanity Fair.

236
00:09:30,625 --> 00:09:31,417
Take that out of the know.

237
00:09:32,250 --> 00:09:34,125
Being a writer, I imagine you read a lot.

238
00:09:34,625 --> 00:09:36,000
You read anything about this case?

239
00:09:37,125 --> 00:09:37,625
No, no.

240
00:09:37,708 --> 00:09:38,708
Today's the first I've heard about it.

241
00:09:39,792 --> 00:09:40,917
Well, then, I think

242
00:09:41,000 --> 00:09:42,083
you'll make a perfectly

243
00:09:42,250 --> 00:09:43,542
acceptable member of this jury.

244
00:09:45,042 --> 00:09:47,042
Does a defense accept our challenge?

245
00:09:48,958 --> 00:09:49,875
We accept him, Your Honor.

246
00:09:51,750 --> 00:09:52,000
Good.

247
00:09:52,708 --> 00:09:53,917
Please enter Justin

248
00:09:54,000 --> 00:09:55,958
Camp as juror number two.

249
00:09:59,042 --> 00:09:59,250
Hey.

250
00:09:59,750 --> 00:10:00,125
Hi.

251
00:10:00,542 --> 00:10:00,792
Hi.

252
00:10:00,875 --> 00:10:01,542
How did it go?

253
00:10:02,583 --> 00:10:02,958
So--

254
00:10:03,708 --> 00:10:04,167
I got picked.

255
00:10:04,833 --> 00:10:05,000
No.

256
00:10:05,917 --> 00:10:06,750
I'm so sorry.

257
00:10:07,708 --> 00:10:09,000
What happened to wildly inappropriate?

258
00:10:09,917 --> 00:10:10,958
I'm saving that for you.

259
00:10:11,042 --> 00:10:11,292
I am?

260
00:10:12,708 --> 00:10:13,750
They said it'll be a short trial.

261
00:10:15,000 --> 00:10:15,667
I feel like they always

262
00:10:15,750 --> 00:10:17,333
say that, but I hope so.

263
00:10:18,458 --> 00:10:19,042
How was your day?

264
00:10:19,750 --> 00:10:20,208
It was OK.

265
00:10:20,708 --> 00:10:21,375
I did this.

266
00:10:22,125 --> 00:10:22,542
Yeah.

267
00:10:22,833 --> 00:10:23,333
It's good progress.

268
00:10:23,667 --> 00:10:24,000
It's good.

269
00:10:24,958 --> 00:10:25,333
All day?

270
00:10:26,417 --> 00:10:27,792
No, this did not take me all day.

271
00:10:28,083 --> 00:10:28,750
I watched a

272
00:10:28,833 --> 00:10:33,042
documentary, and I peed 94 times.

273
00:10:33,500 --> 00:10:33,583
94?

274
00:10:33,667 --> 00:10:35,417
And I ate some ice.

275
00:10:36,500 --> 00:10:37,125
Can I have some more?

276
00:10:37,542 --> 00:10:38,000
Ice? Yeah.

277
00:10:38,292 --> 00:10:38,750
Ice, coming up.

278
00:10:39,042 --> 00:10:39,292
All right.

279
00:10:53,083 --> 00:10:54,667
The people need to know how

280
00:10:54,750 --> 00:10:56,000
I'll make this city safer.

281
00:10:56,250 --> 00:10:58,500
And women need to know that if they're

282
00:10:58,583 --> 00:11:00,083
in an abusive relationship, their

283
00:11:00,167 --> 00:11:01,417
community has their back.

284
00:11:01,625 --> 00:11:03,083
The rest-- the rest is noise.

285
00:11:03,833 --> 00:11:04,750
So thank you.

286
00:11:07,458 --> 00:11:11,167
[APPLAUSE]

287
00:11:12,625 --> 00:11:12,958
Thank you.

288
00:11:13,625 --> 00:11:13,875
Thank you.

289
00:11:14,625 --> 00:11:15,917
Thank you so much.

290
00:11:16,208 --> 00:11:17,125
Thank you.

291
00:11:17,500 --> 00:11:18,125
Thank you so much.

292
00:11:20,625 --> 00:11:22,250
[APPLAUSE]

293
00:11:22,333 --> 00:11:23,750
Hi.

294
00:11:27,500 --> 00:11:27,583
Hi.

295
00:11:29,167 --> 00:11:29,333
Hey.

296
00:11:29,417 --> 00:11:29,708
Nice speech.

297
00:11:33,625 --> 00:11:34,083
Thanks.

298
00:11:35,125 --> 00:11:37,125
Justice is truth in action?

299
00:11:38,458 --> 00:11:39,250
Professor Nielsen.

300
00:11:39,500 --> 00:11:39,750
Yeah.

301
00:11:39,833 --> 00:11:41,000
Yeah, I remember.

302
00:11:42,875 --> 00:11:44,083
You still believe it?

303
00:11:45,917 --> 00:11:46,375
Of course.

304
00:11:47,958 --> 00:11:48,917
All right.

305
00:11:49,292 --> 00:11:50,375
As long as it doesn't get in

306
00:11:50,458 --> 00:11:51,542
the way of a win, though, right?

307
00:11:51,875 --> 00:11:52,458
Oh my god.

308
00:11:52,542 --> 00:11:53,083
If you got something to

309
00:11:53,167 --> 00:11:54,333
say, Eric, just say it.

310
00:11:55,000 --> 00:11:55,208
Hmm.

311
00:11:56,042 --> 00:11:56,542
Say it.

312
00:11:56,708 --> 00:11:58,417
He loves you.

313
00:11:58,500 --> 00:11:59,625
You were his favorite student.

314
00:12:01,333 --> 00:12:02,542
Are you really going there?

315
00:12:02,875 --> 00:12:03,667
Yeah, I'm going there.

316
00:12:03,875 --> 00:12:04,500
Oh my god.

317
00:12:05,625 --> 00:12:07,875
And now you're a--

318
00:12:08,833 --> 00:12:09,000
What?

319
00:12:10,583 --> 00:12:11,000
I'm a what?

320
00:12:12,000 --> 00:12:12,750
A politician.

321
00:12:17,958 --> 00:12:18,375
Good morning.

322
00:12:19,042 --> 00:12:20,792
We will begin with opening statements.

323
00:12:21,167 --> 00:12:21,792
Ms. Killebrude.

324
00:12:25,250 --> 00:12:27,208
OK, the facts of the case are these.

325
00:12:28,000 --> 00:12:29,000
One year ago, on

326
00:12:29,083 --> 00:12:30,583
October 25, the defendant,

327
00:12:30,875 --> 00:12:32,208
James Sath, and his then

328
00:12:32,292 --> 00:12:33,625
girlfriend, Kendall Carter,

329
00:12:34,000 --> 00:12:35,042
went drinking a rowdy's

330
00:12:35,125 --> 00:12:36,958
hideaway on O'Brien Road.

331
00:12:45,750 --> 00:12:47,500
What's all the way up there, guys?

332
00:12:47,583 --> 00:12:48,333
I'm already drunk.

333
00:12:48,750 --> 00:12:48,958
Bye.

334
00:13:05,625 --> 00:13:06,500
Things got tense.

335
00:13:07,458 --> 00:13:08,125
They had a fight.

336
00:13:08,875 --> 00:13:09,667
Not a fair opportunity.

337
00:13:10,167 --> 00:13:10,583
Leave it alone.

338
00:13:12,042 --> 00:13:16,292
I'm not-- what is this?

339
00:13:16,375 --> 00:13:17,250
Stop pushing me.

340
00:13:17,333 --> 00:13:18,167
I'm not pushing you.

341
00:13:18,625 --> 00:13:21,625
Stop pushing me.

342
00:13:21,708 --> 00:13:25,917
Jesus Christ.

343
00:13:26,375 --> 00:13:27,458
Chief stormed out of the

344
00:13:27,542 --> 00:13:29,333
bar, and he followed her.

345
00:13:30,042 --> 00:13:33,458
The fight escalated, and

346
00:13:33,542 --> 00:13:35,083
things quickly got out of control.

347
00:13:35,833 --> 00:13:37,458
Hey.

348
00:13:38,917 --> 00:13:39,667
What the hell are you doing?

349
00:13:40,625 --> 00:13:41,875
Get away from me.

350
00:13:42,750 --> 00:13:43,458
Don't ask me.

351
00:13:43,917 --> 00:13:44,500
Where are you?

352
00:13:44,792 --> 00:13:45,917
Are you kidding me?

353
00:13:52,292 --> 00:13:53,500
It was par for the course.

354
00:13:54,417 --> 00:13:54,958
They'd argue.

355
00:13:55,375 --> 00:13:56,000
They'd break up.

356
00:13:56,625 --> 00:13:56,875
And they'd make up the next day
after they both had calmed down.

357
00:13:56,958 --> 00:14:01,458
It was basically a game.

358
00:14:02,917 --> 00:14:03,792
Now, this couple had a

359
00:14:03,875 --> 00:14:05,583
history of violent interactions,

360
00:14:05,667 --> 00:14:07,958
but this time she was serious.

361
00:14:08,792 --> 00:14:10,042
She was done with him.

362
00:14:10,292 --> 00:14:10,917
So she left and headed
down the road from foot.

363
00:14:26,958 --> 00:14:29,208
So this was just another

364
00:14:29,292 --> 00:14:30,625
typical night of drama.

365
00:14:31,125 --> 00:14:32,333
So James Site got in

366
00:14:32,417 --> 00:14:34,292
his car and he drove home.

367
00:14:36,500 --> 00:14:40,083
He flew into a violent rage and followed

368
00:14:40,167 --> 00:14:42,167
Kendall Carter down the road,

369
00:14:44,042 --> 00:14:46,208
where he proceeded to kill her.

370
00:14:57,917 --> 00:14:59,250
Ever.

371
00:15:05,917 --> 00:15:07,542
He beat her viciously.

372
00:15:09,000 --> 00:15:10,208
He pushed her over a

373
00:15:10,292 --> 00:15:11,333
rail into the creek below

374
00:15:11,917 --> 00:15:14,000
and left her to die.

375
00:15:56,917 --> 00:16:00,833
(wind blowing)

376
00:16:02,125 --> 00:16:03,542
James Seif didn't attack her

377
00:16:03,958 --> 00:16:05,500
and he couldn't have pushed her

378
00:16:05,833 --> 00:16:07,917
because he wasn't there.

379
00:16:13,750 --> 00:16:14,875
James Seif

380
00:16:14,958 --> 00:16:19,083
took an innocent life.

381
00:16:20,792 --> 00:16:23,458
James Seif is an innocent man.

382
00:16:28,000 --> 00:16:30,000
Thank you.

383
00:16:35,792 --> 00:16:41,542
(coughing)

384
00:16:41,625 --> 00:16:51,417
(water splashing)

385
00:16:54,542 --> 00:16:55,083
Damn man.

386
00:16:56,750 --> 00:16:57,458
You alright?

387
00:16:59,542 --> 00:17:01,500
Yeah, just those crime scene pictures.

388
00:17:03,042 --> 00:17:03,917
Never had a strong stomach.

389
00:17:05,458 --> 00:17:05,667
Yeah.

390
00:17:06,833 --> 00:17:08,250
Alright, good night.

391
00:17:09,000 --> 00:17:09,375
Good.

392
00:17:13,167 --> 00:17:20,750
(knocking)

393
00:17:21,375 --> 00:17:23,750
(door opening)

394
00:17:24,625 --> 00:17:25,875
God grant me the serenity

395
00:17:26,042 --> 00:17:27,083
to accept the things

396
00:17:27,167 --> 00:17:28,667
that I cannot change,

397
00:17:28,750 --> 00:17:29,833
the courage to change

398
00:17:29,917 --> 00:17:31,042
the things that I cannot,

399
00:17:31,667 --> 00:17:33,500
and the wisdom to know the difference.

400
00:17:35,292 --> 00:17:36,042
(clapping) Good work, everybody.

401
00:17:36,917 --> 00:17:37,917
He's coming back.

402
00:17:38,167 --> 00:17:39,292
It works if you work.

403
00:17:40,333 --> 00:17:41,083
Great job, everybody.

404
00:17:43,750 --> 00:17:45,042
(crowd chattering)

405
00:17:45,458 --> 00:17:47,167
Thank you, Justin.

406
00:17:48,000 --> 00:17:49,250
Hey, you okay?

407
00:17:49,333 --> 00:17:49,583
You okay?

408
00:17:50,500 --> 00:17:50,667
Yeah.

409
00:17:51,042 --> 00:17:52,583
You got a lot of remindin'?

410
00:17:52,833 --> 00:17:53,458
Yeah, I can tell.

411
00:17:54,250 --> 00:17:55,500
I wanna talk about it.

412
00:17:57,333 --> 00:17:58,500
Okay, look, whatever it is,

413
00:17:58,875 --> 00:17:59,917
my advice is the same.

414
00:18:00,500 --> 00:18:01,875
You know what to do.

415
00:18:02,417 --> 00:18:03,667
We're only as sick as our secrets.

416
00:18:06,167 --> 00:18:07,417
Okay, I'm always here for you.

417
00:18:08,917 --> 00:18:12,875
(door opening)

418
00:18:12,958 --> 00:18:13,958
(soft music)

419
00:18:21,042 --> 00:18:23,458
(soft music)

420
00:18:51,042 --> 00:18:54,583
(soft music)

421
00:18:56,083 --> 00:18:56,333
Good night.

422
00:18:58,167 --> 00:18:59,167
Be out of your way in a minute.

423
00:18:59,500 --> 00:19:00,333
Take as long as you want.

424
00:19:00,542 --> 00:19:01,000
I'll come back.

425
00:19:04,417 --> 00:19:08,167
(soft music)

426
00:19:08,250 --> 00:19:14,417
(door opening)

427
00:19:21,042 --> 00:19:23,708
(door opening)

428
00:19:27,042 --> 00:19:27,250
Hey.

429
00:19:27,583 --> 00:19:27,833
Hey.

430
00:19:29,042 --> 00:19:29,625
Sorry, wait.

431
00:19:30,125 --> 00:19:30,667
It was okay.

432
00:19:31,500 --> 00:19:32,167
How was the meeting?

433
00:19:32,792 --> 00:19:33,125
It was good.

434
00:19:34,250 --> 00:19:35,833
Stayed after the talk of Larry for a bit.

435
00:19:37,750 --> 00:19:38,167
You okay?

436
00:19:38,375 --> 00:19:38,583
Hard.

437
00:19:40,417 --> 00:19:40,750
You okay?

438
00:19:42,875 --> 00:19:43,250
Yeah, I'm good.

439
00:19:45,250 --> 00:19:46,292
Everything's gonna be fine.

440
00:19:48,250 --> 00:19:49,750
We're gonna be a family soon.

441
00:19:52,167 --> 00:19:53,000
Very soon, I hope.

442
00:19:55,708 --> 00:19:56,083
(laughs)

443
00:19:56,167 --> 00:20:04,500
(engine revving)

444
00:20:22,250 --> 00:20:22,917
I'd seen them in there

445
00:20:23,000 --> 00:20:24,250
before a couple times.

446
00:20:25,458 --> 00:20:26,667
It was always the same thing.

447
00:20:27,208 --> 00:20:28,875
They would start off fun and flirty

448
00:20:28,958 --> 00:20:30,708
and then after a few

449
00:20:30,792 --> 00:20:32,333
drinks things would change.

450
00:20:33,333 --> 00:20:33,917
Change how?

451
00:20:34,875 --> 00:20:37,125
That night she came in trying

452
00:20:37,208 --> 00:20:39,417
to talk to him like seriously,

453
00:20:40,083 --> 00:20:43,083
you know, but he wasn't having it.

454
00:20:44,958 --> 00:20:46,583
(engine revving) What do
you want me to disagree with?

455
00:20:46,667 --> 00:20:48,167
I want you to say I love you too.

456
00:20:49,500 --> 00:20:50,000
I basically did.

457
00:20:50,083 --> 00:20:51,542
I want you to say I love you too.

458
00:20:51,625 --> 00:20:52,417
Read between the

459
00:20:52,500 --> 00:20:54,000
goddamn lines, I said yeah.

460
00:20:54,333 --> 00:20:54,833
What lines?

461
00:20:55,083 --> 00:20:56,125
I'm sick of this shit.

462
00:20:56,208 --> 00:20:57,375
What lines are you talking?

463
00:20:57,458 --> 00:20:58,375
Hey, get out of my face.

464
00:20:59,125 --> 00:20:59,167
(glass shatters)

465
00:20:59,917 --> 00:21:02,542
He got mad, like scary.

466
00:21:04,000 --> 00:21:04,833
She leaves.

467
00:21:07,500 --> 00:21:08,125
He follows her

468
00:21:08,208 --> 00:21:09,792
outside, so I start coming.

469
00:21:11,000 --> 00:21:13,333
Hey, what the hell are you doing?

470
00:21:14,167 --> 00:21:14,750
What are you doing?

471
00:21:15,792 --> 00:21:16,500
I wanna go home.

472
00:21:17,625 --> 00:21:20,333
I don't wanna do this anymore.

473
00:21:20,417 --> 00:21:20,750
You what?

474
00:21:21,000 --> 00:21:22,500
I'm sorry, you're embarrassing.

475
00:21:23,125 --> 00:21:24,417
What are you talking about?

476
00:21:24,500 --> 00:21:25,833
Who cares if he's idiots, they can't.

477
00:21:27,708 --> 00:21:28,917
What are you gonna do, hit me?

478
00:21:30,042 --> 00:21:31,833
Relax, I'm sorry, it's okay.

479
00:21:32,750 --> 00:21:33,292
Who are you?

480
00:21:33,583 --> 00:21:34,458
Are you kidding me?

481
00:21:34,542 --> 00:21:35,208
Bring it on.

482
00:21:37,917 --> 00:21:38,583
Better get the fuck

483
00:21:38,667 --> 00:21:39,375
out of here right now.

484
00:21:41,708 --> 00:21:44,750
If I walk home in the

485
00:21:44,833 --> 00:21:44,958
rain, you stupid bitch,

486
00:21:45,042 --> 00:21:51,042
the candle we're in over.

487
00:21:51,125 --> 00:21:51,917
I'm done, baby.

488
00:22:01,333 --> 00:22:03,958
So she lived, then what happened?

489
00:22:04,958 --> 00:22:06,833
He followed her out of the parking lot

490
00:22:06,917 --> 00:22:08,333
and onto old Quarry Road.

491
00:22:09,125 --> 00:22:10,542
Thank you, no further

492
00:22:10,625 --> 00:22:11,500
questions, your honor.

493
00:22:11,917 --> 00:22:13,250
So you saw him walk down on the road

494
00:22:13,333 --> 00:22:14,686
and you were in the
parking lot? No, I didn't.

495
00:22:14,698 --> 00:22:15,917
So you saw him walk
down old Quarry Road?

496
00:22:16,667 --> 00:22:16,875
Yes.

497
00:22:18,458 --> 00:22:19,583
Did you know that his car was

498
00:22:19,667 --> 00:22:20,917
parked down old Quarry Road?

499
00:22:22,500 --> 00:22:22,667
No.

500
00:22:24,875 --> 00:22:25,042
No.

501
00:22:26,083 --> 00:22:27,125
Were you drinking that night?

502
00:22:27,833 --> 00:22:28,500
Objection, your honor.

503
00:22:29,792 --> 00:22:30,208
Elvirole.

504
00:22:31,333 --> 00:22:32,458
Were you drinking that night?

505
00:22:34,083 --> 00:22:34,292
Yes.

506
00:22:35,292 --> 00:22:38,292
So you don't know how far he followed her

507
00:22:38,375 --> 00:22:40,792
down old Quarry Road, do you?

508
00:22:42,125 --> 00:22:44,333
No, at that point I had stopped filming

509
00:22:44,417 --> 00:22:45,375
and I went back inside.

510
00:22:47,208 --> 00:22:47,792
No more questions.

511
00:22:49,417 --> 00:22:50,875
Does the state have any more questions?

512
00:22:51,958 --> 00:22:52,917
No more questions, your honor.

513
00:22:57,708 --> 00:22:59,000
Thank you, you may step down.

514
00:23:00,333 --> 00:23:01,542
I was at the bar till close.

515
00:23:02,708 --> 00:23:03,375
I didn't see either

516
00:23:03,458 --> 00:23:04,375
one of them come back in.

517
00:23:05,500 --> 00:23:06,500
And then the next day I

518
00:23:06,583 --> 00:23:08,000
opened and I did what I always do.

519
00:23:08,833 --> 00:23:09,583
I took the night's

520
00:23:09,667 --> 00:23:10,667
trash out to the dumpster.

521
00:23:14,500 --> 00:23:17,125
Miss, miss, I'm sorry, I need your help.

522
00:23:17,750 --> 00:23:19,583
Because of the rain the night before,

523
00:23:20,500 --> 00:23:22,333
the trails were all muddy and wet.

524
00:23:25,542 --> 00:23:26,458
I had to cut up to

525
00:23:26,542 --> 00:23:27,708
old Quarry by the bridge

526
00:23:28,083 --> 00:23:29,375
in order to get back to the room.

527
00:23:30,792 --> 00:23:33,458
(eerie music)

528
00:23:38,875 --> 00:23:45,167
(crickets chirping)

529
00:23:45,250 --> 00:23:47,208
(crickets chirping)

530
00:23:47,750 --> 00:23:48,833
All right, and just to be clear,

531
00:23:49,125 --> 00:23:49,875
when you found

532
00:23:49,958 --> 00:23:52,417
Candlecaught her, she was dead?

533
00:23:55,500 --> 00:23:57,833
Her head was in a pool of blood.

534
00:23:59,208 --> 00:23:59,792
It was awful.

535
00:24:03,625 --> 00:24:05,208
Thank you for your testimony, Mr. Reed.

536
00:24:05,292 --> 00:24:06,000
I know it isn't easy.

537
00:24:07,958 --> 00:24:08,417
For half.

538
00:24:11,250 --> 00:24:12,583
Mr. Resnick, your witness.

539
00:24:14,208 --> 00:24:17,125
Mr. Reed, you hike those trails

540
00:24:17,208 --> 00:24:18,833
in the woods frequently, don't you?

541
00:24:20,000 --> 00:24:22,125
Yes, sir, twice a week at least.

542
00:24:22,667 --> 00:24:23,833
In your opinion, is the hike

543
00:24:23,917 --> 00:24:25,000
down the hillside difficult?

544
00:24:26,542 --> 00:24:26,667
Yes.

545
00:24:28,208 --> 00:24:28,958
I assume you wear

546
00:24:29,042 --> 00:24:30,792
hiking boots when you hike,

547
00:24:30,875 --> 00:24:31,583
Mr. Reed, is that correct?

548
00:24:33,792 --> 00:24:34,125
Of course.

549
00:24:35,292 --> 00:24:37,167
This is a picture of Kendall Carter.

550
00:24:38,458 --> 00:24:39,250
The morning you found

551
00:24:39,333 --> 00:24:40,708
her below Old Quarry Road.

552
00:24:42,542 --> 00:24:43,417
Can you please tell us what

553
00:24:43,500 --> 00:24:44,542
kind of shoes she's wearing?

554
00:24:47,917 --> 00:24:48,542
Looks like heels.

555
00:24:50,917 --> 00:24:51,250
Heels?

556
00:24:52,917 --> 00:24:54,125
And if she's walking along

557
00:24:54,208 --> 00:24:55,500
the edge of Old Quarry Road

558
00:24:55,583 --> 00:24:56,250
in a blinding

559
00:24:56,333 --> 00:24:59,542
rainstorm at night in heels,

560
00:25:00,500 --> 00:25:03,708
and she suddenly lost her footing,

561
00:25:03,792 --> 00:25:04,875
it'd be next to impossible

562
00:25:05,125 --> 00:25:06,042
to prevent herself from

563
00:25:06,125 --> 00:25:07,083
falling, isn't that correct?

564
00:25:10,625 --> 00:25:10,792
Yes.

565
00:25:14,625 --> 00:25:15,542
Thank you.

566
00:25:17,542 --> 00:25:19,708
She landed in a posterior position

567
00:25:19,792 --> 00:25:20,917
which suggests she was

568
00:25:21,000 --> 00:25:23,042
pushed as opposed to a fall.

569
00:25:23,875 --> 00:25:24,708
Rigamort has indicated

570
00:25:24,792 --> 00:25:25,917
the victim had been dead

571
00:25:26,042 --> 00:25:27,250
for around nine hours.

572
00:25:29,000 --> 00:25:29,875
And the cause of death?

573
00:25:30,542 --> 00:25:32,250
The severity of her skull fractures

574
00:25:32,500 --> 00:25:33,667
suggest she was struck

575
00:25:33,875 --> 00:25:35,750
with a nonspecific blunt instrument.

576
00:25:37,417 --> 00:25:38,708
And the manner of death?

577
00:25:40,792 --> 00:25:41,083
Homicide.

578
00:25:43,917 --> 00:25:44,292
Thank you.

579
00:25:44,917 --> 00:25:45,458
No more questions.

580
00:25:49,542 --> 00:25:51,167
Witnesses, yours, Mr. Resnick.

581
00:25:52,000 --> 00:25:53,292
Is it possible that she

582
00:25:53,375 --> 00:25:54,500
sustained her head injuries

583
00:25:54,583 --> 00:25:55,375
from hitting the rocks?

584
00:25:55,958 --> 00:25:57,500
Possible, sure, but in

585
00:25:57,583 --> 00:25:58,500
my professional opinion,

586
00:25:58,583 --> 00:25:59,458
it's not likely.

587
00:25:59,542 --> 00:26:00,083
But possible.

588
00:26:03,958 --> 00:26:04,542
That's all for me.

589
00:26:09,875 --> 00:26:11,000
Thank you for your testimony.

590
00:26:11,667 --> 00:26:12,583
You may step down.

591
00:26:16,917 --> 00:26:18,542
On October 25th of last year,

592
00:26:18,625 --> 00:26:20,208
you lived on Old Quarry Road, correct?

593
00:26:20,542 --> 00:26:20,833
Yes.

594
00:26:21,250 --> 00:26:22,667
And do you remember anything unusual

595
00:26:22,750 --> 00:26:23,500
happened in that evening?

596
00:26:24,042 --> 00:26:25,167
I saw a man get out

597
00:26:25,250 --> 00:26:26,458
of his car in a storm.

598
00:26:27,292 --> 00:26:28,292
Do you remember what time that was?

599
00:26:28,917 --> 00:26:30,458
11.48 on the button.

600
00:26:31,667 --> 00:26:32,542
I looked at the clock.

601
00:26:33,583 --> 00:26:34,417
I heard the thunder,

602
00:26:35,250 --> 00:26:36,167
so I went to the window

603
00:26:36,250 --> 00:26:37,667
and lightning lit up the sky.

604
00:26:39,292 --> 00:26:39,833
There he was.

605
00:26:40,250 --> 00:26:40,750
What was he doing?

606
00:26:42,000 --> 00:26:43,792
He looked around, he went

607
00:26:43,875 --> 00:26:45,375
over to the side of the road,

608
00:26:47,792 --> 00:26:50,375
peered over the railing, got

609
00:26:50,458 --> 00:26:52,792
back in his car, drove off.

610
00:26:54,250 --> 00:26:55,875
And is that man you saw that night here

611
00:26:55,958 --> 00:26:56,958
in the courtroom today?

612
00:26:57,042 --> 00:26:57,250
Do you know?

613
00:26:57,333 --> 00:26:58,125
Can you point him out?

614
00:27:01,250 --> 00:27:01,458
Okay.

615
00:27:03,458 --> 00:27:04,625
Yes, he is here today.

616
00:27:06,708 --> 00:27:07,458
That's him right there.

617
00:27:09,000 --> 00:27:10,292
Let the record reflect that

618
00:27:10,375 --> 00:27:11,375
the witness has identified

619
00:27:11,458 --> 00:27:12,833
the man he saw as the

620
00:27:12,917 --> 00:27:14,875
defendant, James Michael Seid.

621
00:27:16,500 --> 00:27:17,542
No more questions, Your Honor.

622
00:27:19,542 --> 00:27:22,000
All right, this feels like a good time

623
00:27:22,167 --> 00:27:23,333
to break for the day.

624
00:27:24,083 --> 00:27:25,333
This court is in recess

625
00:27:25,417 --> 00:27:27,250
until 9 a.m. tomorrow morning

626
00:27:27,333 --> 00:27:28,917
when we will pick up

627
00:27:29,000 --> 00:27:29,958
here where we left off.

628
00:27:31,250 --> 00:27:35,542
(birds chirping)

629
00:27:42,500 --> 00:27:43,208
Jesse, what's going on?

630
00:27:45,625 --> 00:27:46,083
I need a lawyer.

631
00:27:48,833 --> 00:27:50,500
Okay, give me a dollar.

632
00:27:50,708 --> 00:27:51,917
I'm not joking, that gives us

633
00:27:52,000 --> 00:27:52,958
attorney-client privilege.

634
00:27:53,167 --> 00:27:53,625
Take a seat.

635
00:27:57,542 --> 00:27:59,250
So I went to clear my head

636
00:27:59,500 --> 00:28:01,417
and found myself at Rowdy's hideaway.

637
00:28:03,542 --> 00:28:05,458
Wore the drink and sat there for a while.

638
00:28:05,542 --> 00:28:06,625
Then I got up and left.

639
00:28:07,125 --> 00:28:08,708
I got to the car, it was raining.

640
00:28:10,125 --> 00:28:11,458
I turned back onto old Corey.

641
00:28:11,667 --> 00:28:12,458
I went about a quarter of

642
00:28:12,542 --> 00:28:14,667
a mile and I hit something.

643
00:28:16,667 --> 00:28:17,417
I got out of the car and I

644
00:28:17,500 --> 00:28:18,250
looked around, I checked,

645
00:28:18,333 --> 00:28:19,000
I didn't see anything

646
00:28:19,083 --> 00:28:20,750
and I figured it was a deer

647
00:28:21,042 --> 00:28:22,875
that ran off and then I got

648
00:28:22,958 --> 00:28:24,500
back in the car and went home.

649
00:28:28,042 --> 00:28:28,792
Okay, what's the problem?

650
00:28:30,375 --> 00:28:31,500
I got called for jury

651
00:28:31,583 --> 00:28:33,458
duty, the Kendall Carta case.

652
00:28:35,042 --> 00:28:37,000
They found her body in a creek bed

653
00:28:38,458 --> 00:28:39,708
about a quarter mile from Rowdy's

654
00:28:39,792 --> 00:28:40,875
hideaway last October.

655
00:28:44,083 --> 00:28:45,208
What are you telling me?

656
00:28:49,125 --> 00:28:50,000
Maybe I didn't hit a deer.

657
00:28:54,458 --> 00:28:55,792
I don't know what to do.

658
00:28:56,792 --> 00:28:59,000
You were at a bar and you had a drink.

659
00:28:59,542 --> 00:29:00,583
Yes, but I didn't touch it.

660
00:29:00,917 --> 00:29:01,500
Doesn't matter.

661
00:29:02,000 --> 00:29:03,917
Given your history, there

662
00:29:04,000 --> 00:29:04,792
isn't a jury in the world

663
00:29:04,875 --> 00:29:05,958
that would believe you were sober.

664
00:29:06,583 --> 00:29:08,167
But if I was coming forward voluntarily,

665
00:29:08,250 --> 00:29:09,458
that has to count for something, right?

666
00:29:09,542 --> 00:29:10,208
If I come forward and

667
00:29:10,292 --> 00:29:11,125
I tell them the truth.

668
00:29:11,208 --> 00:29:12,708
And your prior DUIs and the

669
00:29:12,792 --> 00:29:13,667
fact that you were at a bar

670
00:29:13,750 --> 00:29:14,875
gives a state reason to

671
00:29:14,958 --> 00:29:15,875
charge you with first degree

672
00:29:15,958 --> 00:29:18,125
vehicular homicide or even felony murder.

673
00:29:18,500 --> 00:29:19,542
That's 30 years to life.

674
00:29:20,083 --> 00:29:20,375
What?

675
00:29:21,250 --> 00:29:22,667
If you were to come forward right now,

676
00:29:22,750 --> 00:29:23,583
you would be completely screwed.

677
00:29:27,000 --> 00:29:27,500
That's it?

678
00:29:28,125 --> 00:29:28,333
Yeah.

679
00:29:31,833 --> 00:29:33,833
I'm sorry.

680
00:29:37,125 --> 00:29:38,000
The defense calls

681
00:29:38,083 --> 00:29:39,333
James Seith, your honor.

682
00:29:43,042 --> 00:29:44,208
Please raise your right hand.

683
00:29:45,375 --> 00:29:46,583
Do you swear to tell the

684
00:29:46,667 --> 00:29:48,167
truth, the whole truth,

685
00:29:48,250 --> 00:29:49,167
and nothing but the

686
00:29:49,250 --> 00:29:50,167
truth, so help you God?

687
00:29:50,250 --> 00:29:59,500
Yes, your honor. Have a seat.
Please state your name for the record.

688
00:30:00,042 --> 00:30:01,500
James Michael Seith.

689
00:30:04,125 --> 00:30:04,958
Ms. Resnick, your witness.

690
00:30:05,792 --> 00:30:06,750
Okay, James, let's

691
00:30:06,833 --> 00:30:07,875
talk about what happened

692
00:30:07,958 --> 00:30:09,458
the night of October 25th.

693
00:30:09,542 --> 00:30:10,458
Can you tell us what happened?

694
00:30:11,167 --> 00:30:14,042
Yeah, um, Kendall and I went to Rowdy's

695
00:30:14,125 --> 00:30:16,583
to have a few drinks, get some food.

696
00:30:17,167 --> 00:30:18,000
We were having fun,
you know, shots in pool.

697
00:30:18,083 --> 00:30:18,251
We were having fun,
you know, we were having

698
00:30:18,263 --> 00:30:18,419
fun, you know, we
were having fun, you

699
00:30:18,431 --> 00:30:18,792
know, we were having fun, you know, we were
having fun, you know, we were having fun,

700
00:30:19,125 --> 00:30:20,125
you know, shots in pool,

701
00:30:20,375 --> 00:30:21,625
played some darts, you know.

702
00:30:22,667 --> 00:30:23,125
Now there's been

703
00:30:23,208 --> 00:30:25,958
testimony that you guys argued.

704
00:30:26,042 --> 00:30:27,667
You don't deny that, do you?

705
00:30:28,333 --> 00:30:31,250
No, no, um, she got really drunk

706
00:30:31,583 --> 00:30:33,375
and she was, she was

707
00:30:33,458 --> 00:30:34,125
giving me a hard time.

708
00:30:34,917 --> 00:30:35,500
What do you mean?

709
00:30:37,208 --> 00:30:37,875
She'd been going on

710
00:30:37,958 --> 00:30:39,167
about us moving in together

711
00:30:39,583 --> 00:30:40,708
for a couple weeks and

712
00:30:40,792 --> 00:30:42,208
I, she kept telling her

713
00:30:42,292 --> 00:30:43,917
that I didn't think that I was ready.

714
00:30:45,125 --> 00:30:45,500
We'll see.

715
00:30:47,500 --> 00:30:48,167
We'll see.

716
00:30:48,250 --> 00:30:49,250
What do you mean we're not safe?

717
00:30:49,667 --> 00:30:50,917
I guess she just wasn't having it.

718
00:30:51,000 --> 00:30:51,958
She said I didn't love her.

719
00:30:53,917 --> 00:30:55,083
And she stormed up.

720
00:30:56,000 --> 00:30:56,583
And then what happened?

721
00:30:58,083 --> 00:30:59,750
We argued in the parking lot.

722
00:31:00,625 --> 00:31:01,583
I don't wanna do this anymore.

723
00:31:01,917 --> 00:31:02,292
Do what?

724
00:31:02,583 --> 00:31:03,167
I'm gonna go home.

725
00:31:04,458 --> 00:31:04,750
You're done.

726
00:31:05,500 --> 00:31:06,333
Frank, get out of here.

727
00:31:06,542 --> 00:31:06,958
Don't walk home.

728
00:31:09,250 --> 00:31:10,042
Don't walk home then.

729
00:31:10,750 --> 00:31:10,958
In the rain.

730
00:31:12,958 --> 00:31:17,208
She was just out of her head, you know,

731
00:31:17,625 --> 00:31:19,750
screaming at me and walked off.

732
00:31:21,208 --> 00:31:21,917
And what did you do?

733
00:31:23,417 --> 00:31:25,458
Followed her at first, but

734
00:31:25,542 --> 00:31:27,417
it was cold, it was raining.

735
00:31:28,875 --> 00:31:29,625
I remember getting in my

736
00:31:29,708 --> 00:31:32,458
car, so I was parked next to

737
00:31:32,542 --> 00:31:33,875
Ronald Parker in 217.

738
00:31:36,708 --> 00:31:38,625
My niece is born February
17th, so that's just the end

739
00:31:38,708 --> 00:31:41,917
of the day. I was born
February 17th, so that's just,

740
00:31:43,792 --> 00:31:44,333
pulled me out of

741
00:31:44,417 --> 00:31:46,417
everything and turned around

742
00:31:46,500 --> 00:31:48,583
and just drove home.

743
00:31:55,333 --> 00:31:57,250
And we'd see each other the

744
00:31:57,333 --> 00:31:59,333
next day and we'd work it out.

745
00:31:59,708 --> 00:32:01,875
Like, like always.

746
00:32:03,375 --> 00:32:08,250
Look, was I stupid for not

747
00:32:08,333 --> 00:32:09,417
wanting to move in with her

748
00:32:10,750 --> 00:32:12,167
so I could see her face every day?

749
00:32:14,583 --> 00:32:15,417
Absolutely, yeah.

750
00:32:17,208 --> 00:32:18,292
I could never put my

751
00:32:18,375 --> 00:32:19,833
hands on her like that.

752
00:32:22,333 --> 00:32:25,250
I couldn't do that to her.

753
00:32:26,542 --> 00:32:27,708
I loved her.

754
00:32:30,542 --> 00:32:31,125
Now look, I understand.

755
00:32:33,458 --> 00:32:35,917
My past, the mistakes that I've made,

756
00:32:36,542 --> 00:32:37,042
I know what you're

757
00:32:37,125 --> 00:32:39,292
thinking, I do, and I get it.

758
00:32:41,750 --> 00:32:44,875
But I'm not that guy anymore.

759
00:32:46,375 --> 00:32:47,208
Okay, I've changed.

760
00:32:49,792 --> 00:32:50,375
I left that life

761
00:32:50,458 --> 00:32:51,833
behind me and I, you know,

762
00:32:51,917 --> 00:32:53,042
I thought I was doing really good.

763
00:32:56,583 --> 00:32:57,542
I don't know what happened.

764
00:32:58,792 --> 00:33:01,333
I went home, I drove home.

765
00:33:08,083 --> 00:33:08,792
I know how difficult

766
00:33:08,875 --> 00:33:09,958
this is for you, James.

767
00:33:11,292 --> 00:33:12,958
You take your time.

768
00:33:14,375 --> 00:33:15,042
Let me know when you're ready.

769
00:33:17,583 --> 00:33:17,875
I'm good.

770
00:33:21,042 --> 00:33:23,083
I'm gonna show you a video now, okay?

771
00:33:23,417 --> 00:33:23,750
And then I'm gonna

772
00:33:23,833 --> 00:33:24,792
ask you some questions.

773
00:33:27,125 --> 00:33:37,792
(dramatic music) Did you see that?

774
00:33:40,917 --> 00:33:45,875
Did you miss or make?

775
00:33:46,333 --> 00:33:47,292
I didn't miss.

776
00:33:47,375 --> 00:33:47,542
You missed.

777
00:33:48,333 --> 00:33:49,250
I'll let me help you.

778
00:33:49,708 --> 00:33:50,333
You're a good luck.

779
00:33:50,875 --> 00:33:51,083
Yeah.

780
00:33:52,292 --> 00:33:52,333
I was.

781
00:33:52,375 --> 00:33:53,500
I'll let you.

782
00:34:00,333 --> 00:34:01,083
Okay, damn it.

783
00:34:01,458 --> 00:34:02,417
Okay.

784
00:34:06,375 --> 00:34:07,708
Who took that video?

785
00:34:08,792 --> 00:34:09,083
Kendall.

786
00:34:11,792 --> 00:34:12,083
When?

787
00:34:13,375 --> 00:34:16,292
October 25th of last year.

788
00:34:17,458 --> 00:34:17,875
And where?

789
00:34:19,375 --> 00:34:20,917
The Roudish Hideaway.

790
00:34:24,708 --> 00:34:26,500
Thank you, James. No more questions.

791
00:34:30,708 --> 00:34:31,750
Prosecution, your witness.

792
00:34:33,042 --> 00:34:35,042
Mr. Seuss, you just stated

793
00:34:35,125 --> 00:34:36,833
that you loved Kendall Carter.

794
00:34:37,375 --> 00:34:37,875
Is that right?

795
00:34:39,167 --> 00:34:39,875
More than anything.

796
00:34:41,625 --> 00:34:43,500
And on the night of October 25th, you and

797
00:34:43,583 --> 00:34:45,042
Kendall drove to the Roudish Hideaway.

798
00:34:45,125 --> 00:34:45,500
Is that right?

799
00:34:46,542 --> 00:34:47,417
We took my car in.

800
00:34:48,708 --> 00:34:49,458
And when you got there, the

801
00:34:49,542 --> 00:34:50,333
two of you started drinking.

802
00:34:50,542 --> 00:34:50,875
Is that right?

803
00:34:52,417 --> 00:34:54,000
Yeah, it's a bar.

804
00:34:54,667 --> 00:34:56,125
And then the two of you started arguing.

805
00:34:56,792 --> 00:34:57,417
Is that right?

806
00:34:58,708 --> 00:34:58,917
Yeah.

807
00:35:00,750 --> 00:35:02,792
And during this argument, you knocked a

808
00:35:02,875 --> 00:35:04,208
beer bottle off the table.

809
00:35:04,750 --> 00:35:05,500
Is that right?

810
00:35:07,417 --> 00:35:08,167
Yeah, it was an accident.

811
00:35:09,875 --> 00:35:12,500
And then she left and you went after her.

812
00:35:12,792 --> 00:35:13,375
Is that right?

813
00:35:14,000 --> 00:35:14,292
Yeah.

814
00:35:14,375 --> 00:35:17,167
And outside, the argument continued.

815
00:35:17,833 --> 00:35:21,708
And it is your sworn testimony that you

816
00:35:21,792 --> 00:35:22,708
lift Kendall Carter

817
00:35:22,792 --> 00:35:24,958
alone to walk down a narrow,

818
00:35:25,375 --> 00:35:28,083
two-lane road in the dark, drunk in the

819
00:35:28,167 --> 00:35:29,375
pouring rain in the

820
00:35:29,458 --> 00:35:30,750
middle of a thunderstorm.

821
00:35:32,125 --> 00:35:34,583
Is that how you treat someone you love?

822
00:35:40,375 --> 00:35:40,875
No, Your Honor.

823
00:35:40,958 --> 00:35:44,792
Are there any further

824
00:35:44,875 --> 00:35:46,000
questions from the defense?

825
00:35:46,667 --> 00:35:48,125
No, Your Honor. The defense rests.

826
00:35:49,875 --> 00:35:50,667
Thank you for your

827
00:35:50,750 --> 00:35:52,333
testimony. You can step down.

828
00:36:01,625 --> 00:36:02,583
Members of the jury, the

829
00:36:02,667 --> 00:36:04,542
evidence in this case is now closed.

830
00:36:05,250 --> 00:36:06,458
Attorneys, you may give your closing

831
00:36:06,542 --> 00:36:07,458
arguments at this time.

832
00:36:08,375 --> 00:36:10,542
Ladies and gentlemen of the jury,

833
00:36:13,083 --> 00:36:15,167
Kendall Carter's murder was a savage

834
00:36:15,250 --> 00:36:18,333
crime committed by an evil man.

835
00:36:19,542 --> 00:36:20,917
An innocent man.

836
00:36:21,667 --> 00:36:25,833
An innocent man who was shattered from

837
00:36:25,917 --> 00:36:27,292
losing the love of his life.

838
00:36:28,833 --> 00:36:30,167
We have an eyewitness who saw him at the

839
00:36:30,250 --> 00:36:32,000
crime scene at the time of death.

840
00:36:32,875 --> 00:36:33,917
In the middle of the

841
00:36:34,000 --> 00:36:36,125
night, in a blinding rainstorm.

842
00:36:37,375 --> 00:36:38,250
It could have been anyone.

843
00:36:38,958 --> 00:36:40,417
When she broke up with him that night,

844
00:36:40,917 --> 00:36:44,000
and he realized she meant it, he snapped.

845
00:36:46,000 --> 00:36:46,958
And so he bludgeoned her.

846
00:36:47,458 --> 00:36:49,417
No murder weapon was

847
00:36:49,500 --> 00:36:52,125
recovered. Nothing. Nothing.

848
00:36:52,750 --> 00:36:55,333
The defendant's DNA was all over the

849
00:36:55,417 --> 00:36:57,333
victim. No one else's.

850
00:36:57,708 --> 00:36:59,958
The state says there was DNA. Of course

851
00:37:00,042 --> 00:37:01,083
there was DNA. Of

852
00:37:01,167 --> 00:37:03,333
course. They were a couple.

853
00:37:04,375 --> 00:37:07,375
Until they weren't.

854
00:37:08,042 --> 00:37:12,125
James Seif bravely took the stand and

855
00:37:12,208 --> 00:37:14,042
admitted to some difficult truths.

856
00:37:15,292 --> 00:37:16,958
That? That was all a

857
00:37:17,042 --> 00:37:18,667
performance. Nothing else.

858
00:37:19,708 --> 00:37:23,667
Look, I think we can all agree on this.

859
00:37:24,667 --> 00:37:27,083
The person responsible for Kendall

860
00:37:27,167 --> 00:37:30,333
Carter's death deserves to face justice.

861
00:37:31,375 --> 00:37:34,083
That person is James Seif.

862
00:37:35,083 --> 00:37:37,500
But that person, that

863
00:37:37,583 --> 00:37:41,042
evil man, is still out there.

864
00:37:42,875 --> 00:37:45,625
All I ask is that you deliver a verdict

865
00:37:45,708 --> 00:37:47,375
that speaks the truth.

866
00:37:49,125 --> 00:37:50,833
The truth about what happened to Kendall.

867
00:37:52,250 --> 00:37:53,375
The truth about what happened on Old

868
00:37:53,458 --> 00:37:54,458
Choir Road that night.

869
00:37:56,417 --> 00:37:57,375
And the truth about him.

870
00:38:01,667 --> 00:38:04,833
And the truth about him is that James

871
00:38:04,917 --> 00:38:07,958
Michael Seif is guilty.

872
00:38:09,667 --> 00:38:10,458
Find him guilty.

873
00:38:12,833 --> 00:38:18,000
The truth is, James Seif is not guilty.

874
00:38:21,375 --> 00:38:24,875
Find James Seif. Not guilty.

875
00:38:27,375 --> 00:38:28,333
Thank you.

876
00:38:33,708 --> 00:38:34,917
Good luck.

877
00:38:35,625 --> 00:38:39,083
Thanks. Um, excuse me everyone. If, if

878
00:38:39,167 --> 00:38:41,000
nobody objects, I'd really like to throw

879
00:38:41,083 --> 00:38:42,167
my name into the ring

880
00:38:42,250 --> 00:38:43,083
to be the four woman.

881
00:38:43,583 --> 00:38:44,417
I've served on multiple

882
00:38:44,500 --> 00:38:45,500
juries. I know the ropes.

883
00:38:46,000 --> 00:38:46,208
Cool.

884
00:38:46,500 --> 00:38:47,458
Yeah, I'm sure I have.

885
00:38:47,542 --> 00:38:48,958
Okay, great. Thanks.

886
00:38:49,500 --> 00:38:52,625
Okay, so right now we can do one of two

887
00:38:52,708 --> 00:38:54,125
things. We can vote and

888
00:38:54,208 --> 00:38:56,000
talk or talk and vote.

889
00:38:56,208 --> 00:38:58,167
I suggest that we just vote and just get

890
00:38:58,250 --> 00:38:58,917
an idea where we all

891
00:38:59,000 --> 00:38:59,292
stand. Does that sound good?

892
00:38:59,375 --> 00:39:00,458
Yeah.

893
00:39:00,750 --> 00:39:03,333
Okay, so I vote guilty.

894
00:39:04,000 --> 00:39:04,875
Yes, ma'am. Me too.

895
00:39:06,625 --> 00:39:08,500
Me three. This whole

896
00:39:08,583 --> 00:39:09,750
thing's such a shame.

897
00:39:11,042 --> 00:39:13,417
Yeah, I definitely think that you did it.

898
00:39:13,917 --> 00:39:16,542
Definitely. I agree.

899
00:39:18,333 --> 00:39:19,167
Everything fits together.

900
00:39:20,625 --> 00:39:22,458
Yeah, let them rock.

901
00:39:23,708 --> 00:39:23,917
Amen.

902
00:39:25,375 --> 00:39:28,250
Nine. So that is nine for guilty.

903
00:39:30,500 --> 00:39:30,833
You sir?

904
00:39:31,375 --> 00:39:34,250
Yeah, oh yeah. Yeah, guilty's cool.

905
00:39:35,917 --> 00:39:37,625
Okay. And...

906
00:39:38,583 --> 00:39:40,125
Oh, you sir. How about you?

907
00:39:40,667 --> 00:39:41,792
Kids should have played it out.

908
00:39:44,375 --> 00:39:45,458
And then there was one.

909
00:39:55,375 --> 00:39:59,292
All right, so what's it

910
00:39:59,375 --> 00:40:00,333
gonna be? Whether it's a what?

911
00:40:03,875 --> 00:40:09,375
Don't you want to get

912
00:40:09,458 --> 00:40:10,417
on to your pregnant wife?

913
00:40:10,750 --> 00:40:11,708
Of course I do.

914
00:40:11,792 --> 00:40:12,958
All right, so what's the problem?

915
00:40:15,417 --> 00:40:16,708
Now, if this is somebody's life we're

916
00:40:16,792 --> 00:40:17,292
dealing with, we

917
00:40:17,375 --> 00:40:18,958
shouldn't at least talk about it.

918
00:40:21,375 --> 00:40:22,792
This is a joke.

919
00:40:24,625 --> 00:40:26,958
No, it's a deliberation. You were ready

920
00:40:27,042 --> 00:40:28,083
to send this man to prison.

921
00:40:28,958 --> 00:40:30,208
Maybe forever, just like that.

922
00:40:30,500 --> 00:40:30,708
And?

923
00:40:32,708 --> 00:40:34,167
I heard the facts of the case, did you?

924
00:40:34,583 --> 00:40:36,833
All right. Will he improve beyond a

925
00:40:36,917 --> 00:40:38,792
reasonable doubt that he was innocent?

926
00:40:39,292 --> 00:40:40,500
Well, he doesn't have to. The burden of

927
00:40:40,583 --> 00:40:41,667
proof is on the prosecution.

928
00:40:43,000 --> 00:40:44,417
Does anyone have even the slightest

929
00:40:44,500 --> 00:40:45,958
hesitation that James Seitz is guilty?

930
00:40:47,542 --> 00:40:48,000
I mean...

931
00:40:49,375 --> 00:40:50,250
Look, if you have to

932
00:40:50,333 --> 00:40:52,000
think, you aren't sure.

933
00:40:52,083 --> 00:40:54,958
No. What I'm sure of is I got three kids

934
00:40:55,042 --> 00:40:56,125
at home I gotta get back to.

935
00:40:56,583 --> 00:40:57,958
But we all have lives,

936
00:40:58,042 --> 00:40:59,083
none of us want to be here.

937
00:40:59,292 --> 00:41:01,500
Okay, how about we... Why don't you just

938
00:41:01,583 --> 00:41:04,292
tell us what your issue is, or your

939
00:41:04,375 --> 00:41:06,542
issues are, and then we

940
00:41:06,625 --> 00:41:07,292
can all talk through it.

941
00:41:07,375 --> 00:41:08,708
Oh, I don't have an issue.

942
00:41:10,625 --> 00:41:11,083
Okay, so you just

943
00:41:11,167 --> 00:41:12,333
like pissing me off then?

944
00:41:12,417 --> 00:41:12,917
By what?

945
00:41:13,375 --> 00:41:15,000
Look, I have questions.

946
00:41:15,375 --> 00:41:17,792
Nah, that's just your guilt talking.

947
00:41:19,667 --> 00:41:20,208
What do you mean?

948
00:41:24,250 --> 00:41:25,792
You want to go home to your little

949
00:41:25,875 --> 00:41:28,458
neighborhood and tell them, "Well, you

950
00:41:28,542 --> 00:41:31,250
did right by that boy. We gave him a fair

951
00:41:31,333 --> 00:41:32,875
shake just like anybody else."

952
00:41:33,375 --> 00:41:34,625
Oh, man, hold up. Why are

953
00:41:34,708 --> 00:41:35,500
you getting on him like that?

954
00:41:35,583 --> 00:41:37,042
Hey, mind your own damn business, all

955
00:41:37,125 --> 00:41:37,875
right, little fella?

956
00:41:37,958 --> 00:41:38,583
Excuse me.

957
00:41:38,667 --> 00:41:39,875
Every... Enough of, Sophie.

958
00:41:42,875 --> 00:41:44,333
Please, Mr. Kent, go on.

959
00:41:45,375 --> 00:41:46,167
Thank you, ma'am.

960
00:41:47,542 --> 00:41:49,250
All I'm trying to say is let's put

961
00:41:49,333 --> 00:41:50,625
everything else aside for a minute and

962
00:41:50,708 --> 00:41:51,792
just remember two key points.

963
00:41:53,375 --> 00:41:55,333
One, Syth went to trial and said taking a

964
00:41:55,417 --> 00:41:57,292
plea, and two, he testified

965
00:41:57,375 --> 00:41:58,542
instead of taking the fifth.

966
00:41:59,708 --> 00:42:02,167
Right? I mean, it doesn't mean he's

967
00:42:02,250 --> 00:42:03,583
innocent, but I think he's earned just a

968
00:42:03,667 --> 00:42:05,333
few hours of our time just to be sure.

969
00:42:06,375 --> 00:42:09,000
He's right. Right. We should take the

970
00:42:09,083 --> 00:42:10,542
time and we should go over it.

971
00:42:11,375 --> 00:42:14,208
Fine. Fine. But it's a waste of time. Any

972
00:42:14,292 --> 00:42:15,750
other group of 12 people would arrive at

973
00:42:15,833 --> 00:42:17,250
the exact same decision we did.

974
00:42:17,583 --> 00:42:19,500
Mm-hmm. That part right there.

975
00:42:21,292 --> 00:42:23,708
The state has the truth on its side.

976
00:42:24,500 --> 00:42:25,583
James' side is going

977
00:42:25,667 --> 00:42:26,542
to pay for what it did.

978
00:42:26,917 --> 00:42:28,958
And I will get justice for Kendall Carter

979
00:42:29,042 --> 00:42:30,583
and every woman who is a

980
00:42:30,667 --> 00:42:32,375
victim of domestic abuse.

981
00:42:33,083 --> 00:42:34,542
How do you feel about the latest polling

982
00:42:34,625 --> 00:42:36,250
that a verdict in the side trial carries

983
00:42:36,333 --> 00:42:37,417
a five-point swing in the

984
00:42:37,500 --> 00:42:38,292
district attorney reign?

985
00:42:38,375 --> 00:42:40,875
Oh, come on. You know I can't comment on

986
00:42:40,958 --> 00:42:42,542
that. Okay. Thank you, everybody.

987
00:42:49,958 --> 00:42:53,208
So I'm just going to start with what I

988
00:42:53,292 --> 00:42:56,917
think is the most damning evidence, which

989
00:42:57,000 --> 00:43:02,208
was the man who saw Syth on the road at

990
00:43:02,292 --> 00:43:03,917
the railing directly above where Kendall

991
00:43:04,000 --> 00:43:05,167
Carter's body was found.

992
00:43:05,375 --> 00:43:07,542
Yes, exactly. So what's

993
00:43:07,625 --> 00:43:08,542
Lutte even talk about?

994
00:43:09,000 --> 00:43:10,333
I mean, he was a few hundred feet away

995
00:43:10,417 --> 00:43:12,125
looking from across the bridge. And it

996
00:43:12,208 --> 00:43:13,000
was the middle of the

997
00:43:13,083 --> 00:43:14,708
night through pouring rain.

998
00:43:15,750 --> 00:43:16,875
Yeah, and I've actually done a bunch of

999
00:43:16,958 --> 00:43:18,708
landscaping work up there. That whole

1000
00:43:18,792 --> 00:43:19,917
area is covered by

1001
00:43:20,000 --> 00:43:21,167
trees, it'd be hard to see.

1002
00:43:21,375 --> 00:43:23,542
The man made a positive identification.

1003
00:43:24,125 --> 00:43:26,208
Yeah, but dude's kind of ancient, though.

1004
00:43:27,458 --> 00:43:29,083
Well, this old bird has

1005
00:43:29,167 --> 00:43:31,292
20-20 vision with my glasses.

1006
00:43:31,375 --> 00:43:34,042
Come on, y'all. It's his testimony. He's

1007
00:43:34,125 --> 00:43:36,000
not lying. Why would he lie? And the

1008
00:43:36,083 --> 00:43:37,375
question here means that we think he's

1009
00:43:37,458 --> 00:43:38,667
lying. I don't think he's

1010
00:43:38,750 --> 00:43:40,208
lying. Think he's lying?

1011
00:43:40,750 --> 00:43:41,750
No, I don't think he's lying.

1012
00:43:41,833 --> 00:43:42,458
Okay, so what the hell

1013
00:43:42,542 --> 00:43:43,250
are we talking about?

1014
00:43:43,625 --> 00:43:45,833
Look, I'm just saying, okay, the man, he

1015
00:43:45,917 --> 00:43:47,167
saw somebody at the railing, right? Can

1016
00:43:47,250 --> 00:43:48,167
we all agree on that?

1017
00:43:48,542 --> 00:43:49,083
Yeah, sure.

1018
00:43:49,292 --> 00:43:51,625
Okay, so isn't it possible that he saw

1019
00:43:51,708 --> 00:43:53,000
someone other than James Syth?

1020
00:43:53,375 --> 00:43:54,875
No, we can go back and forth all day on

1021
00:43:54,958 --> 00:43:56,292
possibilities. That's not helpful.

1022
00:43:56,542 --> 00:43:57,292
Well, I think we should.

1023
00:43:57,375 --> 00:43:59,292
No, no, no, no. That's not our job. Our

1024
00:43:59,375 --> 00:44:00,667
job is to just weigh the facts.

1025
00:44:03,042 --> 00:44:05,958
Okay, fact. 32% of homicides occur

1026
00:44:06,042 --> 00:44:07,292
between domestic partners.

1027
00:44:08,042 --> 00:44:09,875
Fact, the police arrested James Syth two

1028
00:44:09,958 --> 00:44:12,000
days after they found the body. Fact,

1029
00:44:12,167 --> 00:44:14,083
they never questioned any other suspects.

1030
00:44:14,667 --> 00:44:16,375
You watch too much TV, old man.

1031
00:44:19,833 --> 00:44:20,042
Okay.

1032
00:44:26,667 --> 00:44:27,167
Here a cop.

1033
00:44:29,542 --> 00:44:32,875
I was. 22 years robbery homicide.

1034
00:44:35,167 --> 00:44:36,917
Bonnie took the buyout, came down here to

1035
00:44:37,000 --> 00:44:38,667
get away from those brutal Midwest

1036
00:44:38,750 --> 00:44:40,583
winters and be closer to the grandkids.

1037
00:44:40,833 --> 00:44:42,542
Why didn't you tell the lawyers?

1038
00:44:43,083 --> 00:44:43,292
Because nobody asked.

1039
00:44:43,375 --> 00:44:43,875
What do you ask?

1040
00:44:45,167 --> 00:44:49,083
About that. Their loss is our gain. So

1041
00:44:49,167 --> 00:44:50,458
what do you think an officer?

1042
00:44:51,833 --> 00:44:55,792
Detective. Look, I think it seems to me

1043
00:44:55,875 --> 00:44:57,958
like the police, you know, follow the

1044
00:44:58,042 --> 00:44:58,833
evidence, found their

1045
00:44:58,917 --> 00:45:00,000
guy, built their case.

1046
00:45:00,583 --> 00:45:01,542
Okay, so what's that?

1047
00:45:02,625 --> 00:45:04,292
Maybe nothing, but tunnel vision like

1048
00:45:04,375 --> 00:45:05,333
that can really bite you in the ass.

1049
00:45:06,875 --> 00:45:09,042
They feed side to that eyewitness. So of

1050
00:45:09,125 --> 00:45:11,125
course that's who we IDs. Now they're

1051
00:45:11,208 --> 00:45:12,250
sure they got their guy.

1052
00:45:12,333 --> 00:45:14,208
So they just ignore anything that doesn't

1053
00:45:14,292 --> 00:45:15,250
help their case. They

1054
00:45:15,333 --> 00:45:17,000
stop asking questions.

1055
00:45:17,958 --> 00:45:18,750
Confirmation bias.

1056
00:45:19,750 --> 00:45:21,375
Confirmation bias. Exactly.

1057
00:45:22,500 --> 00:45:24,625
There's no bad intentions. It's just a

1058
00:45:24,708 --> 00:45:26,708
bunch of people trying to do the right

1059
00:45:26,792 --> 00:45:28,667
thing and can't see

1060
00:45:28,750 --> 00:45:29,792
everything they're doing wrong.

1061
00:45:30,542 --> 00:45:31,333
It's a good point.

1062
00:45:32,375 --> 00:45:35,208
And what about this blunt instrument

1063
00:45:35,292 --> 00:45:37,542
murder weapon they kept talking about?

1064
00:45:38,500 --> 00:45:39,458
Prosecutors said they couldn't recover

1065
00:45:39,542 --> 00:45:42,667
it. So we got rid of it. It's easy to do.

1066
00:45:43,083 --> 00:45:44,542
Or he could have killed her with

1067
00:45:44,625 --> 00:45:46,125
something other than a blunt instrument.

1068
00:45:47,375 --> 00:45:47,708
Like what?

1069
00:45:49,917 --> 00:45:52,417
Like a car? It could

1070
00:45:52,500 --> 00:45:53,292
have been a hit and run.

1071
00:45:55,542 --> 00:45:56,167
Holy shit.

1072
00:45:56,667 --> 00:45:58,000
Here, you're looking at me.

1073
00:45:58,083 --> 00:45:58,292
Sorry, I'm sorry.

1074
00:45:58,375 --> 00:46:02,250
You know, that's a really, really good

1075
00:46:02,333 --> 00:46:03,542
theory. Hit and run.

1076
00:46:03,958 --> 00:46:04,125
Yeah.

1077
00:46:04,792 --> 00:46:05,875
I mean, it's raining, it's night,

1078
00:46:06,125 --> 00:46:07,542
visibility has got to be terrible.

1079
00:46:08,000 --> 00:46:08,875
What we know is slippery

1080
00:46:08,958 --> 00:46:10,625
from the hikers testimony.

1081
00:46:11,167 --> 00:46:12,000
Wandering around in the

1082
00:46:12,083 --> 00:46:14,500
dark in the hills. Kids today.

1083
00:46:16,375 --> 00:46:18,833
It explains how she could

1084
00:46:18,917 --> 00:46:19,875
have ended up in a creek.

1085
00:46:21,000 --> 00:46:24,333
Okay, so side mowed her down instead of

1086
00:46:24,417 --> 00:46:25,542
bashing her head in. What

1087
00:46:25,625 --> 00:46:26,292
are we talking about here?

1088
00:46:26,375 --> 00:46:27,875
What difference does it

1089
00:46:27,958 --> 00:46:29,917
make? The guy is a piece of shit.

1090
00:46:31,250 --> 00:46:32,500
Look, my God is telling me

1091
00:46:32,583 --> 00:46:34,208
that that kid is not a killer.

1092
00:46:35,083 --> 00:46:36,750
Okay, the other day you voted guilty.

1093
00:46:37,583 --> 00:46:40,667
No, no, I never said guilty. I said he

1094
00:46:40,750 --> 00:46:41,792
should have taken the plea bargain.

1095
00:46:42,625 --> 00:46:43,917
He's got a weak case.

1096
00:46:44,375 --> 00:46:45,583
Maybe there's a reason for that.

1097
00:46:46,083 --> 00:46:47,542
Yeah, it's called a public defender.

1098
00:46:49,000 --> 00:46:50,167
I mean, nothing against this guy. He

1099
00:46:50,250 --> 00:46:53,375
seems pretty smart, but the PDs are

1100
00:46:53,458 --> 00:46:55,375
working ten times the caseload
of the DA's office on a friend.

1101
00:46:56,375 --> 00:46:56,833
The protection of the

1102
00:46:56,917 --> 00:46:59,167
budget is just not a fair fight.

1103
00:46:59,750 --> 00:47:01,000
Yeah, well nothing is anymore.

1104
00:47:02,125 --> 00:47:03,292
We'll just do the best we can.

1105
00:47:04,083 --> 00:47:04,542
I hear you.

1106
00:47:06,458 --> 00:47:08,958
And I got 22 years on the street that is

1107
00:47:09,042 --> 00:47:10,958
telling me there's a lot

1108
00:47:11,042 --> 00:47:12,333
more to this case than we know.

1109
00:47:13,208 --> 00:47:15,083
All right, then if you were still a

1110
00:47:15,167 --> 00:47:16,708
detective, what would you do?

1111
00:47:17,083 --> 00:47:17,292
Yeah.

1112
00:47:19,375 --> 00:47:21,292
All right, y'all. That's it for today.

1113
00:47:22,125 --> 00:47:23,125
See you back here at

1114
00:47:23,208 --> 00:47:24,917
9 a.m. Monday morning.

1115
00:47:26,375 --> 00:47:27,917
I almost forgot. Happy Halloween.

1116
00:47:28,583 --> 00:47:29,292
Happy Halloween.

1117
00:47:29,625 --> 00:47:30,000
Happy Halloween.

1118
00:47:32,375 --> 00:47:36,125
Hey, yeah, it has been a minute, but I

1119
00:47:36,208 --> 00:47:37,417
was hoping you could do me a solid.

1120
00:47:39,000 --> 00:47:39,500
Hang on a second.

1121
00:47:45,375 --> 00:47:46,208
Yeah, I'll be here.

1122
00:47:57,375 --> 00:48:06,000
We cannot break the law. We can only

1123
00:48:06,083 --> 00:48:07,917
break ourselves off the law.

1124
00:48:12,167 --> 00:48:13,833
No decision yet. We're

1125
00:48:13,917 --> 00:48:14,833
breaking for the weekend.

1126
00:48:14,917 --> 00:48:16,792
You're kidding. You never know what it

1127
00:48:16,875 --> 00:48:17,875
does in Strange to Gone Do.

1128
00:48:18,250 --> 00:48:19,542
Clearly. Okay, well

1129
00:48:19,625 --> 00:48:20,500
thanks for letting me know.

1130
00:48:20,792 --> 00:48:21,375
See you Monday.

1131
00:48:22,083 --> 00:48:22,500
Drink a drink.

1132
00:48:22,750 --> 00:48:23,375
Yeah, have a good one.

1133
00:48:56,375 --> 00:48:58,375
[music]

1134
00:49:29,542 --> 00:49:30,000
Hey, Ellen.

1135
00:49:30,750 --> 00:49:31,000
Yeah.

1136
00:49:31,833 --> 00:49:32,375
We're back at the job right now.

1137
00:49:56,375 --> 00:50:03,833
[door opens]

1138
00:50:06,083 --> 00:50:06,208
Hey.

1139
00:50:07,375 --> 00:50:08,000
Hi.

1140
00:50:08,500 --> 00:50:09,125
You got my text?

1141
00:50:12,042 --> 00:50:14,167
Oh, shit. Sorry.

1142
00:50:15,792 --> 00:50:16,917
Sorry, I forgot.

1143
00:50:18,125 --> 00:50:19,000
Does everything look okay?

1144
00:50:21,833 --> 00:50:22,375
You okay?

1145
00:50:27,375 --> 00:50:30,792
Hey, hey, what's wrong?

1146
00:50:31,500 --> 00:50:31,667
I'm scared.

1147
00:50:33,375 --> 00:50:35,583
I'm scared. We didn't make it this far

1148
00:50:35,667 --> 00:50:38,000
last time, but I'm just scared.

1149
00:50:39,875 --> 00:50:41,167
I don't want to be doing this alone. I

1150
00:50:41,250 --> 00:50:42,458
don't want to go to these things alone.

1151
00:50:44,125 --> 00:50:44,917
It's going to be okay.

1152
00:50:45,208 --> 00:50:46,458
It's going to be all right.

1153
00:50:46,542 --> 00:50:47,333
I don't understand why

1154
00:50:47,417 --> 00:50:48,208
you weren't there today.

1155
00:50:51,958 --> 00:50:52,667
How much longer is the

1156
00:50:52,750 --> 00:50:53,333
trial going to go on for?

1157
00:50:54,375 --> 00:50:57,208
I have no idea.

1158
00:50:58,208 --> 00:50:59,667
Are you close to a verdict?

1159
00:51:00,333 --> 00:51:01,708
I'm not supposed to discuss it.

1160
00:51:01,792 --> 00:51:03,083
Justin, are you close to a verdict?

1161
00:51:03,708 --> 00:51:06,292
It's ten to two. We're guilty.

1162
00:51:08,750 --> 00:51:11,083
So then Monday, can you just go in and

1163
00:51:11,167 --> 00:51:12,125
sway the two holdouts

1164
00:51:12,208 --> 00:51:13,125
and then be done with this?

1165
00:51:14,000 --> 00:51:16,042
Well, I'm one of them.

1166
00:51:19,000 --> 00:51:19,042
Why?

1167
00:51:19,375 --> 00:51:20,292
I'm sorry, but they took one
look at this guy and that was it.

1168
00:51:20,375 --> 00:51:23,917
No discussion of the evidence? Nothing. I

1169
00:51:24,000 --> 00:51:24,667
have to do something.

1170
00:51:28,250 --> 00:51:29,458
Everyone deserves a chance, right?

1171
00:51:31,625 --> 00:51:32,625
I can think of where I'd be

1172
00:51:32,708 --> 00:51:33,667
if you hadn't given me one.

1173
00:51:39,708 --> 00:51:41,125
Can I ask you something?

1174
00:51:43,250 --> 00:51:44,333
Yeah, sure. What?

1175
00:51:45,375 --> 00:51:47,417
If I were to sell the forerunner without

1176
00:51:47,500 --> 00:51:49,667
telling someone it was in a wreck, but

1177
00:51:49,750 --> 00:51:50,875
they're happy with the deal

1178
00:51:50,958 --> 00:51:51,958
and there's no safety risks.

1179
00:51:52,042 --> 00:51:52,833
It was in the hat, Justin.

1180
00:51:52,917 --> 00:51:55,125
I know, I know, but just go with me. If

1181
00:51:55,208 --> 00:51:57,083
they're never the wiser,

1182
00:51:57,333 --> 00:51:58,792
then did I do anything wrong?

1183
00:52:00,125 --> 00:52:02,833
No. I mean, I don't think so.

1184
00:52:04,958 --> 00:52:09,292
Going upstairs.

1185
00:52:09,375 --> 00:52:13,375
The food's in the fridge. See you upstairs.

1186
00:52:42,042 --> 00:52:44,625
There she is. Next round's on her.

1187
00:52:45,000 --> 00:52:46,542
Bourbon, meat, and

1188
00:52:46,625 --> 00:52:47,917
yeah, whatever he says.

1189
00:52:48,167 --> 00:52:53,083
What I'm having is a great evening. Isn't

1190
00:52:53,167 --> 00:52:54,625
it a beautiful evening?

1191
00:52:54,875 --> 00:52:55,792
Should have been a two hour verdict.

1192
00:52:56,958 --> 00:52:58,125
What can I tell you? They're taking their

1193
00:52:58,208 --> 00:52:59,208
jobs seriously. I gave

1194
00:52:59,292 --> 00:53:00,208
them a lot to think about.

1195
00:53:00,750 --> 00:53:03,083
How can a man live in it? You

1196
00:53:03,167 --> 00:53:04,500
gave them smoke and mirrors.

1197
00:53:04,792 --> 00:53:06,000
When they smoke, there's fire.

1198
00:53:06,375 --> 00:53:09,167
I admire your optimism.

1199
00:53:10,500 --> 00:53:11,667
Look, here's the thing. You walk into

1200
00:53:11,750 --> 00:53:12,958
court convinced of the

1201
00:53:13,042 --> 00:53:13,875
guilt of the defendant.

1202
00:53:14,375 --> 00:53:17,458
I have no illusions about what I do. A

1203
00:53:17,542 --> 00:53:19,042
lot of my clients aren't guilty and my

1204
00:53:19,125 --> 00:53:20,083
job is to help make the

1205
00:53:20,167 --> 00:53:22,042
best of a bad situation.

1206
00:53:22,292 --> 00:53:24,958
But I'm telling you, I'm telling you,

1207
00:53:25,042 --> 00:53:26,000
this guy didn't do it.

1208
00:53:28,583 --> 00:53:31,667
And the fact that the jury's taking a

1209
00:53:31,750 --> 00:53:33,958
little time gives me hope that things are

1210
00:53:34,042 --> 00:53:35,125
working the way they should.

1211
00:53:37,375 --> 00:53:40,542
Well, you enjoy that while it lasts.

1212
00:53:44,375 --> 00:53:45,708
To the justice system.

1213
00:53:47,167 --> 00:53:49,667
Ain't perfect. That's the best we got.

1214
00:53:50,375 --> 00:54:08,875
I know I can tell them. Trust your gut.

1215
00:54:09,792 --> 00:54:10,750
You do the right thing.

1216
00:54:12,083 --> 00:54:13,833
Oh, wait, wait, wait.

1217
00:54:14,375 --> 00:54:18,833
What's that?

1218
00:54:19,458 --> 00:54:20,042
It's my pitchfork.

1219
00:54:20,792 --> 00:54:21,083
Nice!

1220
00:54:21,875 --> 00:54:23,167
Hey, oh, maybe.

1221
00:54:26,375 --> 00:54:28,042
Hey, hey, hey, happy all the way in.

1222
00:54:29,000 --> 00:54:30,667
I love your costumes. Take two, everyone.

1223
00:54:33,542 --> 00:54:35,000
Oliver? Hey, Ms. Curson.

1224
00:54:36,208 --> 00:54:36,833
Oliver, I didn't even

1225
00:54:36,917 --> 00:54:38,250
recognize you. How are you?

1226
00:54:39,792 --> 00:54:40,333
Hey, Mr. Kim.

1227
00:54:40,500 --> 00:54:41,375
Hey, how's the writing going?

1228
00:54:41,958 --> 00:54:42,292
I want you to pay for now.

1229
00:54:42,375 --> 00:54:44,708
No way. That's awesome. Congrats.

1230
00:54:45,625 --> 00:54:46,292
Hey, have fun tonight.

1231
00:54:46,542 --> 00:54:47,875
We will. See you back at school?

1232
00:54:48,500 --> 00:54:49,583
Yeah. Next year.

1233
00:54:49,667 --> 00:54:50,958
Okay. Well, bye.

1234
00:54:51,625 --> 00:54:51,875
Bye.

1235
00:54:53,125 --> 00:54:53,917
God, he's a giant.

1236
00:54:54,333 --> 00:54:54,500
No.

1237
00:55:01,375 --> 00:55:02,042
Thanks.

1238
00:55:13,375 --> 00:55:15,375
Hey.

1239
00:55:16,250 --> 00:55:16,500
Hey.

1240
00:55:16,917 --> 00:55:17,542
Would you follow me

1241
00:55:17,625 --> 00:55:18,583
after court on Friday?

1242
00:55:19,833 --> 00:55:20,833
I picked your tail up like

1243
00:55:20,917 --> 00:55:22,125
halfway out of the parking lot.

1244
00:55:22,208 --> 00:55:24,208
I mean, green Toyota 4Runner, right?

1245
00:55:24,833 --> 00:55:27,375
Yeah. Well, you're not allowed to

1246
00:55:27,458 --> 00:55:28,167
investigate the case

1247
00:55:28,250 --> 00:55:29,167
outside the jury room.

1248
00:55:30,500 --> 00:55:32,792
Yeah. Yeah, I know. But...

1249
00:55:34,167 --> 00:55:35,125
I mean, somebody's got to.

1250
00:55:36,125 --> 00:55:36,792
Don't you want to know

1251
00:55:36,875 --> 00:55:37,417
what really happened?

1252
00:55:38,042 --> 00:55:38,250
Yeah.

1253
00:55:38,500 --> 00:55:38,833
Of course.

1254
00:55:39,958 --> 00:55:41,000
Look, I, uh...

1255
00:55:41,375 --> 00:55:42,750
I did some digging.

1256
00:55:44,875 --> 00:55:46,667
This is every registered car in the

1257
00:55:46,750 --> 00:55:48,083
county that was in for bodywork

1258
00:55:48,167 --> 00:55:49,500
between October 26th

1259
00:55:49,583 --> 00:55:50,375
and the end of last year.

1260
00:55:50,458 --> 00:55:51,083
You're still with the

1261
00:55:51,167 --> 00:55:51,875
hit and run, come on.

1262
00:55:51,958 --> 00:55:52,750
Yeah, because that's

1263
00:55:52,833 --> 00:55:53,750
a really good theory.

1264
00:55:54,375 --> 00:55:55,875
Now, the automakers keep a

1265
00:55:55,958 --> 00:55:57,292
detailed list of these repairs,

1266
00:55:57,542 --> 00:55:59,250
strictly for R&D purposes.

1267
00:55:59,875 --> 00:56:00,375
They collect it from

1268
00:56:00,458 --> 00:56:01,875
the dealer's pro forma

1269
00:56:01,958 --> 00:56:02,958
and then pay the mom and

1270
00:56:03,042 --> 00:56:04,333
pop shops under the table.

1271
00:56:04,417 --> 00:56:05,833
My partner and I recovered more cars than

1272
00:56:05,917 --> 00:56:06,917
an impound this way.

1273
00:56:07,250 --> 00:56:08,250
Right. But there must be

1274
00:56:08,333 --> 00:56:09,167
hundreds of cars in there.

1275
00:56:09,500 --> 00:56:10,292
Yeah. So, process it all.

1276
00:56:10,375 --> 00:56:12,500
Process the elimination, which is what I

1277
00:56:12,583 --> 00:56:13,750
spend my whole weekend doing.

1278
00:56:14,375 --> 00:56:15,458
I mean, anything there's

1279
00:56:15,542 --> 00:56:16,875
already a police report for,

1280
00:56:17,375 --> 00:56:18,083
crossed off the list.

1281
00:56:18,875 --> 00:56:19,458
Mm-hmm.

1282
00:56:19,542 --> 00:56:20,417
And there's only going to be a very

1283
00:56:20,500 --> 00:56:21,583
specific kind of damage

1284
00:56:21,667 --> 00:56:22,750
with this kind of hit and run.

1285
00:56:23,125 --> 00:56:25,708
So, I had light, grill, hood,

1286
00:56:26,292 --> 00:56:28,292
and narrowed down to 15 vehicles

1287
00:56:28,375 --> 00:56:30,500
that match that description on this list,

1288
00:56:30,750 --> 00:56:32,250
one of which, by the way, a

1289
00:56:32,333 --> 00:56:34,500
96-digoto 4Runner, 4-screen.

1290
00:56:35,292 --> 00:56:35,917
I mean, that's the exact

1291
00:56:36,000 --> 00:56:37,125
same car as yours, right?

1292
00:56:37,375 --> 00:56:39,292
I mean, if that is your car, we can just

1293
00:56:39,375 --> 00:56:40,250
cross it off the list.

1294
00:56:41,500 --> 00:56:43,500
Right. Yeah. So, it's

1295
00:56:43,583 --> 00:56:45,375
the plan with both of us.

1296
00:56:46,042 --> 00:56:46,958
If you don't mind helping.

1297
00:56:47,583 --> 00:56:48,750
There's only so many hours in the day,

1298
00:56:48,833 --> 00:56:50,042
and we've got to spend most of them here.

1299
00:56:50,125 --> 00:56:50,542
So, you want to help

1300
00:56:50,625 --> 00:56:51,417
me with the light work

1301
00:56:51,500 --> 00:56:52,792
and see if we can find our guy.

1302
00:56:53,042 --> 00:56:54,417
Yeah. Okay. Yeah.

1303
00:56:54,500 --> 00:56:55,292
You're reaching, but...

1304
00:56:55,917 --> 00:56:57,458
Look, it's a hit and run, kid.

1305
00:56:57,542 --> 00:56:58,292
I feel it in my bones.

1306
00:56:58,583 --> 00:56:59,375
Dumbers to donuts.

1307
00:56:59,458 --> 00:57:00,542
Our guy is on this list.

1308
00:57:00,792 --> 00:57:01,583
Oh, good morning.

1309
00:57:02,833 --> 00:57:04,375
Party time, y'all. Let's go.

1310
00:57:07,583 --> 00:57:09,083
Fellas, wrap it up. Thanks.

1311
00:57:13,250 --> 00:57:13,583
Let's go.

1312
00:57:16,458 --> 00:57:17,042
Goddamn it.

1313
00:57:17,667 --> 00:57:17,875
Uh...

1314
00:57:19,542 --> 00:57:20,792
Everything all right over here?

1315
00:57:21,375 --> 00:57:21,417
Mm-hmm.

1316
00:57:22,333 --> 00:57:23,750
Yeah, I'm working my nerves, Dave.

1317
00:57:25,875 --> 00:57:26,542
What is all this?

1318
00:57:31,708 --> 00:57:33,542
Just...you two, wait for me.

1319
00:57:36,292 --> 00:57:39,500
Read instruction 0.01 for me, please.

1320
00:57:44,083 --> 00:57:44,292
Uh...

1321
00:57:44,625 --> 00:57:45,208
"To maintain the

1322
00:57:45,292 --> 00:57:46,500
integrity of the jury system,

1323
00:57:46,583 --> 00:57:47,208
I remind you that you

1324
00:57:47,292 --> 00:57:48,083
must decide this case

1325
00:57:48,375 --> 00:57:49,500
based only on the evidence

1326
00:57:49,583 --> 00:57:50,583
admitted during the trial

1327
00:57:50,667 --> 00:57:52,667
and the law I will explain to you.

1328
00:57:52,750 --> 00:57:53,625
You may not conduct

1329
00:57:53,708 --> 00:57:54,792
any research on your own

1330
00:57:54,875 --> 00:57:56,292
about this case or about any people

1331
00:57:56,375 --> 00:57:57,792
or places mentioned during the trial."

1332
00:57:59,167 --> 00:58:00,583
Sounds to me like you two violated

1333
00:58:00,667 --> 00:58:02,292
every sentence of that paragraph.

1334
00:58:02,375 --> 00:58:04,000
Your Honor, I move for a missed trial.

1335
00:58:04,083 --> 00:58:05,917
He's a former cop who knows what ideas he

1336
00:58:06,000 --> 00:58:06,958
put into juries' heads.

1337
00:58:07,417 --> 00:58:08,208
Failure to elicit his

1338
00:58:08,292 --> 00:58:10,292
previous employment during four-dear

1339
00:58:10,375 --> 00:58:11,958
is on you, Mr. Wesley.

1340
00:58:12,375 --> 00:58:12,792
It's misconduct.

1341
00:58:13,333 --> 00:58:14,042
Kick him off, Judge.

1342
00:58:14,125 --> 00:58:15,542
There's no need to start over.

1343
00:58:15,625 --> 00:58:16,458
Our resources are

1344
00:58:16,542 --> 00:58:17,750
already stretched so thin.

1345
00:58:21,042 --> 00:58:21,542
She's right.

1346
00:58:22,333 --> 00:58:23,958
Motion denied. Your Honor, you know.

1347
00:58:25,208 --> 00:58:25,958
As for you two...

1348
00:58:29,167 --> 00:58:30,583
You violated your oath. That's yours.

1349
00:58:33,583 --> 00:58:36,375
Your Honor, if I may, I, uh...

1350
00:58:36,792 --> 00:58:37,667
I upheld the oath I

1351
00:58:37,750 --> 00:58:38,875
took as a police officer

1352
00:58:38,958 --> 00:58:40,625
to never betray my

1353
00:58:40,708 --> 00:58:41,917
character, my integrity,

1354
00:58:42,250 --> 00:58:43,208
or the public trust.

1355
00:58:49,375 --> 00:58:50,167
Mr. Joukowsky,

1356
00:58:50,583 --> 00:58:53,583
you are hereby removed from jurorservice.

1357
00:58:55,500 --> 00:58:56,833
On account of your background, I'm going

1358
00:58:56,917 --> 00:58:57,792
to make an exception

1359
00:58:57,875 --> 00:59:00,333
and not find you in contempt of court.

1360
00:59:01,375 --> 00:59:02,792
Thank you, Your Honor.

1361
00:59:04,958 --> 00:59:07,458
So, Mr. Kemp, you are not a retired law

1362
00:59:07,542 --> 00:59:08,542
enforcement officer, are you?

1363
00:59:08,917 --> 00:59:09,958
No, no, Your Honor.

1364
00:59:10,458 --> 00:59:12,625
So, how do you explain your involvement

1365
00:59:12,708 --> 00:59:14,625
in this transgression?

1366
00:59:16,083 --> 00:59:16,958
I obtained those

1367
00:59:17,042 --> 00:59:18,792
documents on my own, Your Honor.

1368
00:59:18,875 --> 00:59:20,792
He didn't have anything to do with it.

1369
00:59:22,292 --> 00:59:22,708
Is that true?

1370
00:59:24,750 --> 00:59:26,208
I mean, did you look at these documents

1371
00:59:26,292 --> 00:59:27,292
or help to procure them

1372
00:59:27,375 --> 00:59:29,000
or know what Mr.

1373
00:59:29,083 --> 00:59:30,542
Joukowsky was intending to do?

1374
00:59:31,125 --> 00:59:32,583
No, Your Honor, I did not

1375
00:59:32,667 --> 00:59:34,250
look at them and I didn't help.

1376
00:59:36,542 --> 00:59:38,500
So, do you think that you can disregard

1377
00:59:38,583 --> 00:59:40,167
everything that you heard just now

1378
00:59:40,375 --> 00:59:41,833
and remain an unbiased

1379
00:59:41,917 --> 00:59:43,000
member of this panel?

1380
00:59:43,250 --> 00:59:44,250
Yes, I can.

1381
00:59:46,292 --> 00:59:47,708
I'm going to take you at your word,

1382
00:59:48,958 --> 00:59:49,792
if I let you go up.

1383
00:59:49,875 --> 00:59:50,625
Please escort Mr. Kemp

1384
00:59:50,708 --> 00:59:51,750
back to the juror room.

1385
00:59:53,833 --> 00:59:55,875
Mr. Joukowsky, you are dismissed.

1386
00:59:58,000 --> 00:59:59,375
I would ask that a copy of these

1387
00:59:59,458 --> 01:00:00,458
documents be made part

1388
01:00:00,542 --> 01:00:01,292
of the court's records

1389
01:00:01,375 --> 01:00:02,792
for purposes of appeal and

1390
01:00:02,875 --> 01:00:04,083
again, I move that Mr. R...

1391
01:00:04,167 --> 01:00:05,333
The documents will be

1392
01:00:05,417 --> 01:00:07,333
marked as courts exhibit one.

1393
01:00:08,292 --> 01:00:09,250
Your motion for a

1394
01:00:09,333 --> 01:00:12,208
mistrial is denied, Mr. Resnick.

1395
01:00:12,792 --> 01:00:13,958
Is that understood?

1396
01:00:15,208 --> 01:00:16,833
Yes, Your Honor. It's understood.

1397
01:00:17,958 --> 01:00:20,375
Good. Then we are done here.

1398
01:00:27,375 --> 01:00:30,167
You've got to be kidding me.

1399
01:00:30,250 --> 01:00:30,417
What?

1400
01:00:30,833 --> 01:00:32,792
Are resources a stretch so thin?

1401
01:00:34,042 --> 01:00:34,750
You are something.

1402
01:00:39,000 --> 01:00:39,417
Okay.

1403
01:00:47,208 --> 01:00:47,875
Counselor.

1404
01:00:48,083 --> 01:00:49,292
Hey, it's okay. I'm not on the jury

1405
01:00:49,375 --> 01:00:50,375
anymore. I don't have to.

1406
01:00:50,917 --> 01:00:52,125
Yeah, make sure of that.

1407
01:00:55,583 --> 01:00:56,458
You're feeling the pressure, huh?

1408
01:00:57,750 --> 01:00:58,500
In this job?

1409
01:00:59,458 --> 01:00:59,625
Yeah.

1410
01:01:02,875 --> 01:01:02,958
Okay.

1411
01:01:10,375 --> 01:01:12,583
Hey, I'm sorry, but I just...

1412
01:01:12,667 --> 01:01:14,208
I can't not say this. You...

1413
01:01:16,375 --> 01:01:18,000
You got this case all wrong.

1414
01:01:19,542 --> 01:01:19,750
Oh, really?

1415
01:01:20,125 --> 01:01:20,333
Yeah.

1416
01:01:21,375 --> 01:01:22,000
It's a hit and run.

1417
01:01:23,125 --> 01:01:24,958
No way. Emmy would have flagged it.

1418
01:01:25,208 --> 01:01:26,167
Wow. Yeah, you'd think.

1419
01:01:27,417 --> 01:01:28,875
I counted five autopsies

1420
01:01:28,958 --> 01:01:30,917
that day. One day, I checked.

1421
01:01:31,833 --> 01:01:32,958
Doesn't mean anything.

1422
01:01:37,375 --> 01:01:39,417
Let me just ask you one thing.

1423
01:01:40,750 --> 01:01:41,458
Did you guys ever look

1424
01:01:41,542 --> 01:01:42,708
at any other suspect?

1425
01:01:45,000 --> 01:01:45,792
We did our job.

1426
01:01:47,375 --> 01:01:48,625
I'll do respect, Counselor. If you'd have

1427
01:01:48,708 --> 01:01:49,833
done your job, I don't think we'd be

1428
01:01:49,917 --> 01:01:51,083
standing here right now.

1429
01:01:51,167 --> 01:01:52,875
Well, that guy is bad news.

1430
01:01:55,417 --> 01:01:55,625
Maybe.

1431
01:01:58,833 --> 01:01:59,792
But he didn't kill that girl.

1432
01:02:17,375 --> 01:02:18,625
Alright, so with that being said, Judge

1433
01:02:18,708 --> 01:02:21,083
Stewart thanks you for your patience and

1434
01:02:21,167 --> 01:02:23,125
apologizes for any inconvenience.

1435
01:02:24,042 --> 01:02:25,500
Jury number 13 is now a

1436
01:02:25,583 --> 01:02:27,750
voting member of this panel. Okay?

1437
01:02:29,083 --> 01:02:30,583
I'll let you guys get back to it.

1438
01:02:34,125 --> 01:02:34,875
So what happened?

1439
01:02:36,125 --> 01:02:37,667
What was this misconduct?

1440
01:02:38,792 --> 01:02:40,083
The lies between him and the judge.

1441
01:02:40,500 --> 01:02:41,417
Bullshit. You were

1442
01:02:41,500 --> 01:02:43,333
there. What did Harold do?

1443
01:02:44,375 --> 01:02:48,375
He was investigating the case on his own.

1444
01:02:49,042 --> 01:02:49,625
The judge sent him home.

1445
01:02:51,333 --> 01:02:52,625
What about that stack of papers?

1446
01:02:53,000 --> 01:02:55,167
What papers? The ones Harold gave.

1447
01:02:55,250 --> 01:02:56,125
Don't you drop them all

1448
01:02:56,208 --> 01:02:57,542
over the floor. We all saw it.

1449
01:02:57,833 --> 01:02:58,583
The bailiff was on us

1450
01:02:58,667 --> 01:02:59,458
before I left the papers.

1451
01:03:00,958 --> 01:03:03,167
You were talking for quite a while. Did

1452
01:03:03,250 --> 01:03:04,458
he tell you what was in them?

1453
01:03:06,958 --> 01:03:09,583
Uh, yes, he did. It was a printout.

1454
01:03:10,000 --> 01:03:11,083
Names, vehicle registrations.

1455
01:03:11,375 --> 01:03:14,125
He said that it could

1456
01:03:14,208 --> 01:03:15,500
prove James Sykes is.

1457
01:03:17,000 --> 01:03:17,375
So what?

1458
01:03:18,083 --> 01:03:18,833
Were you supposed to believe

1459
01:03:18,917 --> 01:03:20,250
you now and change our vote?

1460
01:03:20,333 --> 01:03:21,750
I'm just telling you what I know.

1461
01:03:23,917 --> 01:03:25,375
He thinks it was a hit and win.

1462
01:03:58,250 --> 01:04:00,750
So if he thinks it was a hit and win,

1463
01:04:05,708 --> 01:04:07,042
Kendall was by five.

1464
01:04:08,250 --> 01:04:11,958
If she was hunched over and

1465
01:04:12,042 --> 01:04:14,583
the car was in SUV or a truck,

1466
01:04:15,000 --> 01:04:16,500
she could have easily then hit smack

1467
01:04:16,583 --> 01:04:18,000
across the head and torso.

1468
01:04:20,750 --> 01:04:21,250
Look at the way her

1469
01:04:21,333 --> 01:04:22,250
shoulders are fractured.

1470
01:04:23,375 --> 01:04:25,375
I'm sorry, but are you a doctor?

1471
01:04:26,042 --> 01:04:26,333
Not yet. Fairly a master.

1472
01:04:26,917 --> 01:04:31,458
I mean, I think we should

1473
01:04:31,542 --> 01:04:32,417
leave that to the professionals,

1474
01:04:32,625 --> 01:04:33,458
the medical examiner

1475
01:04:33,542 --> 01:04:35,042
who examined the body.

1476
01:04:35,125 --> 01:04:36,833
Well, I mean, doctors can be careless.

1477
01:04:37,583 --> 01:04:38,917
Look, one time they told my daddy he was

1478
01:04:39,000 --> 01:04:39,583
having a heart attack.

1479
01:04:40,292 --> 01:04:41,333
Turned out it was just gas.

1480
01:04:43,083 --> 01:04:45,417
You're always in such a rush. Go ahead,

1481
01:04:45,500 --> 01:04:46,500
dear. Speak your mind.

1482
01:04:50,583 --> 01:04:52,292
The right and left club we call.
Both show a very clean break.

1483
01:04:52,375 --> 01:04:59,250
What's this about? She
couldn't get that from the phone.

1484
01:05:00,125 --> 01:05:00,750
It's not likely.

1485
01:05:02,208 --> 01:05:05,708
Both phones had to be broken by a single,

1486
01:05:06,083 --> 01:05:09,125
sharp posterior impact.

1487
01:05:11,000 --> 01:05:11,208
Pow.

1488
01:05:12,833 --> 01:05:13,875
Dude, we know if

1489
01:05:13,958 --> 01:05:15,542
Slice's car had any damage.

1490
01:05:16,708 --> 01:05:17,292
No, the police would have
noted it in their report if it did.

1491
01:05:17,375 --> 01:05:21,879
Not if they thought it
was irrelevant. Caught

1492
01:05:21,891 --> 01:05:25,917
it. So you sent my
secret copy on to it?

1493
01:05:26,125 --> 01:05:28,125
No. I'm a dog groomer,

1494
01:05:28,208 --> 01:05:29,708
but I watch and listen

1495
01:05:29,792 --> 01:05:30,833
to a lot of true crime,

1496
01:05:31,292 --> 01:05:33,458
and the first rule is the husband did it.

1497
01:05:34,042 --> 01:05:36,125
Okay, well, husband,

1498
01:05:36,208 --> 01:05:37,250
boyfriend, same difference.

1499
01:05:37,500 --> 01:05:39,000
You agree that he's guilty, right?

1500
01:05:39,083 --> 01:05:40,708
He is a perfect suspect.

1501
01:05:40,792 --> 01:05:41,417
All right, thank you.

1502
01:05:41,625 --> 01:05:43,167
But the second rule of true crime

1503
01:05:43,250 --> 01:05:44,292
is that it's never the perfect suspect.

1504
01:05:44,375 --> 01:05:45,083
Oh, my God. I'm sorry. I'm sorry.
I'm sorry. I'm sorry. Perfect suspect.

1505
01:05:46,375 --> 01:05:47,792
Oh, my God.

1506
01:05:47,875 --> 01:05:50,083
I'm just sharing with you my experiences.

1507
01:05:50,792 --> 01:05:51,583
Your experiences.

1508
01:05:52,125 --> 01:05:53,625
Listening to crime podcasts.

1509
01:05:53,875 --> 01:05:54,542
Well, hold on.

1510
01:05:54,750 --> 01:05:55,458
And watching "Dayline."

1511
01:05:55,542 --> 01:05:56,125
Okay, well, that doesn't

1512
01:05:56,208 --> 01:05:57,792
make you Sherlock Holmes.

1513
01:05:58,625 --> 01:05:59,333
Well, thank you.

1514
01:06:00,042 --> 01:06:01,958
No, you burned through enough cases,

1515
01:06:02,042 --> 01:06:04,000
and you start to see certain patterns.

1516
01:06:04,708 --> 01:06:06,000
But I leave the detective

1517
01:06:06,083 --> 01:06:07,125
work to the foreign pointers.

1518
01:06:07,542 --> 01:06:08,083
Good, good. Good, because we're not

1519
01:06:08,167 --> 01:06:09,208
here to solve a mystery, okay?

1520
01:06:09,292 --> 01:06:11,542
All we're here to do is to sign if we're

1521
01:06:11,625 --> 01:06:12,292
positive James Seidt

1522
01:06:12,375 --> 01:06:14,000
that killed Kendall Carter.

1523
01:06:15,208 --> 01:06:15,375
Man.

1524
01:06:16,042 --> 01:06:16,500
I'm not.

1525
01:06:19,125 --> 01:06:21,375
Old poor we roll fees into the highway.

1526
01:06:22,292 --> 01:06:23,125
When traffic's heavy,

1527
01:06:23,458 --> 01:06:24,625
GPS will send you that way.

1528
01:06:25,167 --> 01:06:25,708
It gets busy.

1529
01:06:26,458 --> 01:06:28,917
Yeah, and at night, I mean, it's gnarly.

1530
01:06:29,000 --> 01:06:30,167
I nearly mowed down a deer once.

1531
01:06:31,458 --> 01:06:32,417
What if that's what they thought?

1532
01:06:33,875 --> 01:06:34,417
Who thought?

1533
01:06:36,750 --> 01:06:38,333
Whoever hit Kendall Carter.

1534
01:06:41,375 --> 01:06:42,167
Yeah, man, I mean, that

1535
01:06:42,250 --> 01:06:43,458
all makes sense, but...

1536
01:06:44,333 --> 01:06:45,000
what about our eyewitness?

1537
01:06:47,125 --> 01:06:48,250
Maybe he saw someone else?

1538
01:06:48,833 --> 01:06:49,875
Okay, hold up. Wait a minute.

1539
01:06:49,958 --> 01:06:51,208
Y'all got way too many

1540
01:06:51,292 --> 01:06:52,708
maybes for my liking, huh?

1541
01:06:53,000 --> 01:06:54,833
And too many maybes is reasonable now.

1542
01:06:55,500 --> 01:06:56,500
I agree with Justin.

1543
01:06:58,083 --> 01:06:58,292
Yeah.

1544
01:07:01,000 --> 01:07:01,125
Okay.

1545
01:07:01,958 --> 01:07:02,292
Kayco?

1546
01:07:02,375 --> 01:07:06,958
Ellie?

1547
01:07:09,708 --> 01:07:11,292
I'm not sure anymore that

1548
01:07:11,375 --> 01:07:12,875
this young man is guilty.

1549
01:07:13,250 --> 01:07:15,083
Right. Okay. Anyone else?

1550
01:07:16,667 --> 01:07:17,292
Not guilty.

1551
01:07:18,292 --> 01:07:18,458
Okay.

1552
01:07:25,375 --> 01:07:28,292
I fell asleep on Highway
17 and woke up in the ditch.

1553
01:07:28,375 --> 01:07:34,958
I think I had the hospital's close.

1554
01:07:36,667 --> 01:07:36,917
Hmm.

1555
01:07:38,375 --> 01:07:38,625
Okay.

1556
01:07:40,833 --> 01:07:41,833
Thank you for your time.

1557
01:07:42,333 --> 01:07:42,542
Yep.

1558
01:07:43,375 --> 01:08:03,375
We were street racing down Greek
Road. It was dumb, you know. [door closes]

1559
01:08:16,125 --> 01:08:16,292
Guilty.

1560
01:08:19,000 --> 01:08:19,208
Guilty?

1561
01:08:23,375 --> 01:08:23,875
Not guilty.

1562
01:08:27,125 --> 01:08:27,583
Guilty.

1563
01:08:32,708 --> 01:08:36,500
All right. Looks like we're 6 to 6.

1564
01:08:37,833 --> 01:08:38,292
We're deadlocked.

1565
01:08:39,083 --> 01:08:40,250
Okay, so what do we do now?

1566
01:08:40,875 --> 01:08:41,625
Feels like the more we

1567
01:08:41,708 --> 01:08:43,125
talk, the less we know.

1568
01:08:43,667 --> 01:08:45,167
I'm so tired.

1569
01:08:46,292 --> 01:08:48,500
You're so stoned in.

1570
01:08:49,083 --> 01:08:50,458
Let's go back to the beginning.

1571
01:08:51,125 --> 01:08:52,583
Be with that case. Piece by piece.

1572
01:08:52,667 --> 01:08:53,292
No, no. Let's stop wasting our damn time.

1573
01:08:53,375 --> 01:08:59,958
I'm not gonna do it. Take a
breath. It's been a long day.

1574
01:09:00,042 --> 01:09:01,917
But, you know, votes have changed, right?

1575
01:09:02,000 --> 01:09:03,333
The process is working.

1576
01:09:03,542 --> 01:09:05,500
No, it's not. You are wearing us down.

1577
01:09:06,708 --> 01:09:08,125
Talking a lot but saying nothing.

1578
01:09:09,208 --> 01:09:09,958
You know, you go over

1579
01:09:10,042 --> 01:09:11,292
anything enough times,

1580
01:09:11,750 --> 01:09:12,917
yeah, we'll start to question it.

1581
01:09:13,250 --> 01:09:14,708
Yeah, like which shoes to wear.

1582
01:09:15,583 --> 01:09:16,125
Yeah, look.

1583
01:09:18,083 --> 01:09:19,083
We got all these theories,

1584
01:09:19,375 --> 01:09:20,208
y'all, but no new evidence.

1585
01:09:20,292 --> 01:09:20,333
Yeah, but those theories
are making some of us question it.

1586
01:09:20,375 --> 01:09:26,167
Yeah, I'm not gonna
lie. No, no, no, you can

1587
01:09:26,250 --> 01:09:27,292
question it all you want,

1588
01:09:27,375 --> 01:09:29,000
but I know he's guilty.

1589
01:09:31,125 --> 01:09:32,292
Just look at his damn neck.

1590
01:09:34,458 --> 01:09:36,208
Okay, my man, I know you got a picture of

1591
01:09:36,292 --> 01:09:37,000
him in that book of yours.

1592
01:09:39,208 --> 01:09:40,833
I mean, yeah, not today.

1593
01:09:41,375 --> 01:09:42,375
It's not perfect, but...

1594
01:09:43,542 --> 01:09:45,500
Yes, see? Right there.

1595
01:09:46,250 --> 01:09:46,292
Snake and the crown.

1596
01:09:46,375 --> 01:09:47,583
That's the west side crowns. They're the
biggest of the world. Snake and the crown.

1597
01:09:48,583 --> 01:09:49,792
That's the west side crowns.

1598
01:09:49,875 --> 01:09:50,333
They're the biggest

1599
01:09:50,417 --> 01:09:51,750
drug pushers in the city.

1600
01:09:52,750 --> 01:09:53,542
How do you know that?

1601
01:09:53,958 --> 01:09:55,625
Because I run the Boys and Girls Club.

1602
01:09:56,375 --> 01:09:57,125
These guys are

1603
01:09:57,208 --> 01:09:58,833
poisoning their own community.

1604
01:10:02,375 --> 01:10:03,625
This case is personal to you.

1605
01:10:03,708 --> 01:10:05,000
Yeah, well, you're damn right it is.

1606
01:10:07,583 --> 01:10:10,458
My little brother was

1607
01:10:10,542 --> 01:10:13,500
14 when he got inked.

1608
01:10:16,375 --> 01:10:17,708
A month before his 17th

1609
01:10:17,792 --> 01:10:18,583
birthday, he was dead.

1610
01:10:20,083 --> 01:10:21,125
Caught a straight bullet in

1611
01:10:21,208 --> 01:10:25,333
some tit for tat turf bullshit.

1612
01:10:27,833 --> 01:10:30,000
I'm sorry, I had no idea.

1613
01:10:30,250 --> 01:10:32,750
Yeah, that's right. You have no idea.

1614
01:10:36,417 --> 01:10:39,125
Look, Seythe did say that

1615
01:10:39,208 --> 01:10:40,125
he left that life behind.

1616
01:10:41,750 --> 01:10:43,292
There's only one way to leave that crew.

1617
01:10:45,833 --> 01:10:47,500
So you can keep

1618
01:10:47,583 --> 01:10:49,458
talking about your theories?

1619
01:10:50,625 --> 01:10:52,000
Look, people can change.

1620
01:10:52,208 --> 01:10:53,500
Yeah, keep telling yourself that.

1621
01:10:53,583 --> 01:10:54,708
I do every day.

1622
01:10:54,792 --> 01:10:57,125
Well, I drive a bus, and I see the same

1623
01:10:57,208 --> 01:10:58,417
people day in and day

1624
01:10:58,500 --> 01:10:59,792
out, and they do not change.

1625
01:11:00,000 --> 01:11:01,083
Well, then how am I sitting here?

1626
01:11:02,792 --> 01:11:03,375
What are you talking about?

1627
01:11:03,667 --> 01:11:04,250
I should be dead.

1628
01:11:05,625 --> 01:11:06,042
I should.

1629
01:11:07,000 --> 01:11:10,667
A little over four years ago, I wrapped

1630
01:11:10,750 --> 01:11:11,708
my car around a tree with

1631
01:11:11,792 --> 01:11:13,292
a blood alcohol that'll...

1632
01:11:13,375 --> 01:11:15,583
Probably should have killed me before I

1633
01:11:15,667 --> 01:11:16,417
even got in the car.

1634
01:11:16,750 --> 01:11:19,625
And somehow, I walked

1635
01:11:19,708 --> 01:11:20,625
away with barely a scratch.

1636
01:11:21,000 --> 01:11:21,750
Lucky you.

1637
01:11:22,833 --> 01:11:23,750
Yeah, part of my

1638
01:11:23,833 --> 01:11:25,250
sentence was community service.

1639
01:11:25,333 --> 01:11:26,292
I spent three days a week in an

1640
01:11:26,375 --> 01:11:27,125
elementary school teaching

1641
01:11:27,208 --> 01:11:30,500
kids how to write alcoholics.

1642
01:11:31,625 --> 01:11:32,375
We can charm anybody.

1643
01:11:33,167 --> 01:11:36,292
But the teacher I was reporting to, she

1644
01:11:36,375 --> 01:11:38,083
was Teflon, she saw right through me.

1645
01:11:38,375 --> 01:11:42,125
She made me finally want to, you know,

1646
01:11:42,542 --> 01:11:44,417
all my shit, and just take

1647
01:11:44,500 --> 01:11:45,625
responsibility for myself.

1648
01:11:48,500 --> 01:11:50,958
I'm still not sure what I did to get a

1649
01:11:51,042 --> 01:11:52,750
woman like her to give me a chance, but

1650
01:11:52,833 --> 01:11:56,833
her belief and believing in myself that I

1651
01:11:56,917 --> 01:11:57,833
could change, that was...

1652
01:11:58,917 --> 01:12:00,750
That was, you know, the first step.

1653
01:12:01,833 --> 01:12:07,375
And, look, the journey never ends, I know

1654
01:12:07,458 --> 01:12:12,833
that, but that's four years.

1655
01:12:13,708 --> 01:12:15,542
And am I the same man that I was four

1656
01:12:15,625 --> 01:12:18,458
years ago? No. Absolutely not.

1657
01:12:19,375 --> 01:12:23,708
Yeah, well, now I can see you. You

1658
01:12:23,792 --> 01:12:26,583
changed. But guys like

1659
01:12:26,667 --> 01:12:29,250
James Seidt, they don't change.

1660
01:12:30,375 --> 01:12:32,833
Okay, think back to his testimony. That

1661
01:12:32,917 --> 01:12:36,000
was raw and real, and I believed it.

1662
01:12:36,500 --> 01:12:38,750
Wait, hold on, gang. If

1663
01:12:38,833 --> 01:12:40,042
Seidt didn't do it, then who did?

1664
01:12:40,458 --> 01:12:41,708
We don't have to answer that.

1665
01:12:43,042 --> 01:12:44,458
So no one's gonna pay for it after that?

1666
01:12:44,542 --> 01:12:45,542
No, someone will pay.

1667
01:12:45,625 --> 01:12:46,250
How do you know that?

1668
01:12:46,708 --> 01:12:49,292
Because somebody always does. I get how

1669
01:12:49,375 --> 01:12:50,708
you feel, but you can't

1670
01:12:50,792 --> 01:12:51,875
let your feelings sway you.

1671
01:12:52,750 --> 01:12:54,292
You don't know anything about me, man.

1672
01:12:54,375 --> 01:13:01,375
How old's your daughter? That's her on

1673
01:13:01,458 --> 01:13:02,167
the keychain, right?

1674
01:13:05,000 --> 01:13:08,083
Yeah, she turned 16 in March.

1675
01:13:09,167 --> 01:13:10,333
How often do you get to see her?

1676
01:13:13,250 --> 01:13:13,833
I'm often enough.

1677
01:13:15,000 --> 01:13:16,667
You know, during the trial, I was sat

1678
01:13:16,750 --> 01:13:18,292
right in Kendall's parents' eyeline.

1679
01:13:18,375 --> 01:13:23,708
I could see, I mean, their pain each day,

1680
01:13:24,000 --> 01:13:24,917
and, you know, what if

1681
01:13:25,000 --> 01:13:25,667
she were your daughter?

1682
01:13:28,042 --> 01:13:29,208
You want justice,

1683
01:13:29,417 --> 01:13:30,458
right? An eye for an eye.

1684
01:13:30,542 --> 01:13:32,667
Right, yeah. But then James Seidt's

1685
01:13:32,750 --> 01:13:33,917
family was in court each day, too.

1686
01:13:34,167 --> 01:13:35,167
You know, his grandma and his niece.

1687
01:13:36,625 --> 01:13:41,458
What if he were your son, right? When you

1688
01:13:41,542 --> 01:13:42,375
want justice for him, too?

1689
01:13:45,083 --> 01:13:47,125
Yeah. Yeah, I suppose I would.

1690
01:14:25,583 --> 01:14:37,500
So, how can I help you?

1691
01:14:37,833 --> 01:14:39,250
Well, I just want to have a little chat

1692
01:14:39,333 --> 01:14:40,583
about what happened here.

1693
01:14:40,667 --> 01:14:41,292
Just have a little one-on-one.

1694
01:14:41,375 --> 01:14:43,833
Maybe I could get some more information,

1695
01:14:44,125 --> 01:14:45,375
something that came to you new, you know?

1696
01:14:47,375 --> 01:14:49,042
Well, like I said at the trial, the

1697
01:14:49,125 --> 01:14:52,250
police come by, show me a picture, ask me

1698
01:14:52,333 --> 01:14:54,208
if he was a man I saw that night.

1699
01:14:55,042 --> 01:14:56,458
They'd show you any other pictures?

1700
01:14:57,000 --> 01:15:00,000
Oh, no, they knew it was him. They just

1701
01:15:00,083 --> 01:15:01,042
needed me to confirm it.

1702
01:15:01,750 --> 01:15:01,958
Right.

1703
01:15:03,667 --> 01:15:04,875
I was happy to do so.

1704
01:15:05,417 --> 01:15:06,583
Everyone was so generous.

1705
01:15:08,000 --> 01:15:09,875
And if I could say so, it felt pretty

1706
01:15:09,958 --> 01:15:12,583
good to be needed again.

1707
01:15:14,042 --> 01:15:14,875
I'm sure it did.

1708
01:15:16,000 --> 01:15:17,375
Right. Well, if there's anything else I

1709
01:15:17,458 --> 01:15:18,333
can do for you, just give

1710
01:15:18,417 --> 01:15:19,917
a holler. Tea's always hot.

1711
01:15:20,875 --> 01:15:22,042
Okay. Thank you so much.

1712
01:15:22,125 --> 01:15:22,917
Thanks for your time, sir.

1713
01:15:23,375 --> 01:15:27,625
James Seidt, it did

1714
01:15:27,708 --> 01:15:29,333
kill that girl, right?

1715
01:15:38,250 --> 01:15:39,667
Okay, so does anybody

1716
01:15:39,750 --> 01:15:41,292
else want to change the vote?

1717
01:15:43,458 --> 01:15:47,458
Um, well, it doesn't matter anyway.

1718
01:15:47,833 --> 01:15:48,375
What do you mean?

1719
01:15:49,583 --> 01:15:52,167
Because I haven't changed my mind.

1720
01:15:52,542 --> 01:15:53,542
All right, well, let's just keep talking.

1721
01:15:53,625 --> 01:15:56,458
No. No, I'm done talking.

1722
01:15:57,542 --> 01:15:57,750
Marcus.

1723
01:15:58,708 --> 01:16:01,333
So what, you're gonna tell the judge we

1724
01:16:01,417 --> 01:16:03,167
can't reach a verdict?

1725
01:16:04,458 --> 01:16:05,542
It is what it is.

1726
01:16:06,292 --> 01:16:07,667
But we're actually making progress.

1727
01:16:08,875 --> 01:16:09,083
Progress?

1728
01:16:09,750 --> 01:16:10,292
Yeah.

1729
01:16:10,958 --> 01:16:11,917
How can we continue if

1730
01:16:12,000 --> 01:16:12,750
we can't reach a verdict?

1731
01:16:13,417 --> 01:16:14,708
I've been at this for I don't even know

1732
01:16:14,792 --> 01:16:18,250
how long my kids need me.

1733
01:16:19,667 --> 01:16:23,042
I'm just trying to do my job here. Okay.

1734
01:16:23,792 --> 01:16:25,917
Um, Courtney, what about

1735
01:16:26,000 --> 01:16:27,042
you? Do you want to keep going?

1736
01:16:27,375 --> 01:16:30,250
I don't know. Look, he yelled at her. He

1737
01:16:30,333 --> 01:16:32,250
grabbed her arm. He called her a bitch.

1738
01:16:32,917 --> 01:16:34,917
He was possessive and temperamental.

1739
01:16:35,167 --> 01:16:37,917
No, he was abusive. Screw him.

1740
01:16:39,333 --> 01:16:42,667
Yeah. You're right. Screw him.

1741
01:16:43,208 --> 01:16:45,583
Great. For the third time, I get to go

1742
01:16:45,667 --> 01:16:46,333
home and tell my

1743
01:16:46,417 --> 01:16:47,375
husband, "Guess what, honey?"

1744
01:16:47,667 --> 01:16:50,667
I did nothing. He gets

1745
01:16:50,750 --> 01:16:51,917
a real kick out of that.

1746
01:16:52,333 --> 01:16:53,250
I'm sorry, Denise. I'm

1747
01:16:53,333 --> 01:16:54,167
not changing my vote.

1748
01:16:55,333 --> 01:16:55,958
Neither am I.

1749
01:16:56,375 --> 01:16:58,625
Yeah. Me too.

1750
01:17:03,833 --> 01:17:04,542
So what do we do then?

1751
01:17:05,792 --> 01:17:09,542
Um, there's one thing we could try.

1752
01:17:12,750 --> 01:17:13,542
Madam Foreperson,

1753
01:17:15,625 --> 01:17:17,417
sending a jury to visit a crime scene

1754
01:17:17,500 --> 01:17:19,375
once deliberations have begun is not

1755
01:17:19,458 --> 01:17:21,000
something I would typically allow.

1756
01:17:21,542 --> 01:17:23,167
With all due respect, your honor, this

1757
01:17:23,250 --> 01:17:25,292
has not been a typical deliberation.

1758
01:17:25,375 --> 01:17:27,833
But I do think it will be beneficial in

1759
01:17:27,917 --> 01:17:28,833
helping us reach a verdict.

1760
01:17:29,833 --> 01:17:30,375
I see.

1761
01:17:33,500 --> 01:17:34,458
Mr. Resnick, any objections?

1762
01:17:35,708 --> 01:17:36,250
No, Your Honor.

1763
01:17:37,375 --> 01:17:38,208
Okay. Ms. Kilbrue?

1764
01:17:40,583 --> 01:17:41,500
The state's fine with it.

1765
01:17:42,125 --> 01:17:42,833
All right, then.

1766
01:17:44,292 --> 01:17:45,417
Here are the rules.

1767
01:17:46,792 --> 01:17:49,000
During your visit, you are not to speak

1768
01:17:49,083 --> 01:17:51,167
to anyone outside of your jury panel,

1769
01:17:51,375 --> 01:17:52,583
nor are you to speak to

1770
01:17:52,667 --> 01:17:54,750
each other about this case.

1771
01:17:56,000 --> 01:17:57,250
All right, you are there to view the

1772
01:17:57,333 --> 01:17:58,708
locations in and around

1773
01:17:58,792 --> 01:18:00,583
where the crime took place,

1774
01:18:01,375 --> 01:18:02,583
and you are not to

1775
01:18:02,667 --> 01:18:04,750
collect evidence of any kind.

1776
01:18:05,875 --> 01:18:07,667
Does everyone understand these rules?

1777
01:18:08,375 --> 01:18:08,833
Yes, ma'am.

1778
01:18:10,000 --> 01:18:10,667
All right.

1779
01:18:12,375 --> 01:18:13,500
This court is adjourned.

1780
01:18:15,583 --> 01:18:17,667
Hey, hey, can we talk?

1781
01:18:19,375 --> 01:18:21,500
Great, great. I'll see you there. Thanks.

1782
01:18:32,708 --> 01:18:36,333
Hello?

1783
01:18:39,375 --> 01:18:41,500
Oh, hey, are you Allison Curzon?

1784
01:18:42,000 --> 01:18:43,542
Yes, I am. Yeah. Who are you?

1785
01:18:44,000 --> 01:18:46,458
I'm Faith Kilbrue. I'm a prosecutor with

1786
01:18:46,542 --> 01:18:47,292
the District Adjourners Office.

1787
01:18:47,375 --> 01:18:48,875
Do you mind if we talk?

1788
01:18:50,417 --> 01:18:51,292
I was just about to lay

1789
01:18:51,375 --> 01:18:52,208
down, but what is this about?

1790
01:18:52,292 --> 01:18:53,000
It'll only be a minute.

1791
01:18:54,333 --> 01:18:57,125
Okay, come in. Okay, thank you.

1792
01:19:02,375 --> 01:19:05,333
Sorry for the intrusion. I won't be long.

1793
01:19:06,333 --> 01:19:08,833
I'm following up on a few different

1794
01:19:08,917 --> 01:19:10,500
accidents from October last year,

1795
01:19:10,792 --> 01:19:12,500
just doing routine checks on any cars

1796
01:19:12,583 --> 01:19:14,042
that were serviced for major

1797
01:19:14,125 --> 01:19:15,542
body damage around that time.

1798
01:19:15,625 --> 01:19:15,833
Okay.

1799
01:19:16,792 --> 01:19:19,292
So on October 25th last year, did you own

1800
01:19:19,375 --> 01:19:22,042
a 1996 green Toyota 4Runner?

1801
01:19:23,042 --> 01:19:23,250
Yes.

1802
01:19:23,917 --> 01:19:25,500
Do you remember having anybody worked on

1803
01:19:25,583 --> 01:19:26,292
it around that time?

1804
01:19:26,792 --> 01:19:27,000
Yeah.

1805
01:19:27,958 --> 01:19:30,500
Okay. And how were your car damaged?

1806
01:19:31,292 --> 01:19:32,708
My husband Justin hit a deer.

1807
01:19:32,958 --> 01:19:34,500
Okay. Any idea where?

1808
01:19:35,625 --> 01:19:36,542
About in Brimstone Pass.

1809
01:19:38,000 --> 01:19:38,458
You sure?

1810
01:19:40,208 --> 01:19:40,583
Yeah.

1811
01:19:42,167 --> 01:19:44,083
Could it have been Old Quarry Road, or...

1812
01:19:45,958 --> 01:19:47,458
No, it was Brimstone Pass.

1813
01:19:49,167 --> 01:19:49,625
You're positive.

1814
01:19:51,667 --> 01:19:51,875
Positive.

1815
01:19:54,458 --> 01:19:57,042
Okay, great. Well, that's all I have.

1816
01:19:58,958 --> 01:19:59,667
Thank you very much for

1817
01:19:59,750 --> 01:20:00,625
your time, Mrs. Crucie.

1818
01:20:01,542 --> 01:20:03,875
And congratulations. What do you do?

1819
01:20:05,417 --> 01:20:07,458
Uh, yeah, any day now.

1820
01:20:07,917 --> 01:20:09,958
Good luck with that. You want me to do

1821
01:20:10,042 --> 01:20:10,708
anything before I go?

1822
01:20:11,083 --> 01:20:11,583
No, no.

1823
01:20:11,875 --> 01:20:12,667
Okay, well, I'll just see myself.

1824
01:20:12,917 --> 01:20:13,500
No, I'll get you out.

1825
01:20:13,708 --> 01:20:14,292
No, it's good.

1826
01:20:14,375 --> 01:20:15,417
Have a good one.

1827
01:20:15,500 --> 01:20:16,583
Thank you. Thanks for your time.

1828
01:20:16,667 --> 01:20:17,042
Bye.

1829
01:20:17,125 --> 01:20:17,875
Bye now.

1830
01:20:39,375 --> 01:20:41,292
Hey. Sorry I couldn't meet you earlier.

1831
01:20:41,375 --> 01:20:42,375
No worries.

1832
01:20:43,083 --> 01:20:43,583
What's on your mind?

1833
01:20:44,083 --> 01:20:44,500
The trial.

1834
01:20:45,125 --> 01:20:46,000
Oh, yeah, I figured.

1835
01:20:46,917 --> 01:20:48,125
It's headed for a hung jury.

1836
01:20:48,625 --> 01:20:48,875
Justin?

1837
01:20:50,708 --> 01:20:50,833
Thanks.

1838
01:20:51,250 --> 01:20:53,167
I got you a coffee.

1839
01:20:53,458 --> 01:20:53,833
Thanks.

1840
01:20:55,292 --> 01:20:56,792
Obviously, I want to acquit the guy,

1841
01:20:57,083 --> 01:20:58,333
but if the jury hangs,

1842
01:20:58,417 --> 01:20:59,250
it's a mistrial, right?

1843
01:20:59,625 --> 01:21:00,083
That's right.

1844
01:21:00,167 --> 01:21:01,208
So, problem solved.

1845
01:21:02,083 --> 01:21:03,833
Well, given all the press on this case,

1846
01:21:04,208 --> 01:21:06,208
the public's gonna demand a retrial.

1847
01:21:06,292 --> 01:21:06,833
It's gonna have to do it

1848
01:21:06,917 --> 01:21:08,000
all over again with sight,

1849
01:21:08,625 --> 01:21:09,250
unless the district

1850
01:21:09,333 --> 01:21:10,292
attorney's office decides

1851
01:21:10,375 --> 01:21:11,500
that he's not the guy,

1852
01:21:11,583 --> 01:21:12,917
then they'll find the guy.

1853
01:21:14,208 --> 01:21:14,958
There's no way that this

1854
01:21:15,042 --> 01:21:16,042
case ends without a verdict.

1855
01:21:16,708 --> 01:21:18,167
Once they get that, then, yeah, that's

1856
01:21:18,250 --> 01:21:18,917
over, then it's done.

1857
01:21:19,167 --> 01:21:20,542
So you're saying I need a verdict?

1858
01:21:21,625 --> 01:21:22,250
I'm afraid so.

1859
01:21:40,250 --> 01:21:41,792
Hey, can you meet me at county?)

1860
01:21:53,375 --> 01:22:04,250
(Hey.)

1861
01:22:04,333 --> 01:22:08,958
(Hey, is it okay?)

1862
01:22:09,042 --> 01:22:14,333
(Just checking the car.
I might have a blighter.)

1863
01:22:17,958 --> 01:22:18,958
Why'd you hit that deer again?

1864
01:22:21,208 --> 01:22:22,292
Up on Brimstone Pass, right?

1865
01:22:22,375 --> 01:22:22,813
(I'm sorry, I'm sorry.)
(I'm sorry.) (I'm sorry.) (I'm

1866
01:22:22,825 --> 01:22:23,292
sorry.) (I'm sorry.) (I'm
sorry.) Brimstone Pass, right?

1867
01:22:25,125 --> 01:22:26,958
(Hmm.)

1868
01:22:27,875 --> 01:22:28,667
You're sure that it was

1869
01:22:28,750 --> 01:22:29,542
an old court of your own?

1870
01:22:31,083 --> 01:22:32,875
(I'm positive.)

1871
01:22:33,250 --> 01:22:33,458
That's...

1872
01:22:34,833 --> 01:22:35,708
Just as if that's...

1873
01:22:37,208 --> 01:22:39,042
positive that's what I said to the

1874
01:22:39,125 --> 01:22:41,167
prosecutor from your trial

1875
01:22:41,375 --> 01:22:41,792
when she just

1876
01:22:41,875 --> 01:22:43,500
interrogated me in her living room.

1877
01:22:44,417 --> 01:22:45,708
(What? She was here?)

1878
01:22:45,792 --> 01:22:45,958
Yeah.

1879
01:22:47,375 --> 01:22:48,583
I looked her up. She wanted

1880
01:22:48,667 --> 01:22:49,625
to know about your accident.

1881
01:22:50,375 --> 01:22:53,708
(Okay.)

1882
01:22:53,792 --> 01:22:55,417
(What'd you tell her?)

1883
01:22:55,750 --> 01:22:56,125
The truth...

1884
01:22:59,417 --> 01:23:02,417
that you hit a deer up on Brimstone Pass.

1885
01:23:04,208 --> 01:23:08,708
That is the truth, right?

1886
01:23:11,500 --> 01:23:13,583
Did you take the shortcut home through

1887
01:23:13,667 --> 01:23:14,458
old quarry that night?

1888
01:23:16,750 --> 01:23:18,708
Did you stop at Rowdy's Hideaway?

1889
01:23:20,375 --> 01:23:25,458
(I'm sorry.)

1890
01:23:30,333 --> 01:23:30,833
Did you drink?

1891
01:23:40,000 --> 01:23:40,208
Did you?

1892
01:23:43,000 --> 01:23:44,792
Justin? Did you drink?

1893
01:23:46,583 --> 01:23:47,125
Talk to me.

1894
01:23:47,375 --> 01:23:49,250
No, I didn't drink. I

1895
01:23:49,333 --> 01:23:51,042
didn't drink, okay? I...

1896
01:23:54,500 --> 01:23:56,875
I stopped and I... I ordered the drink

1897
01:23:56,958 --> 01:23:57,875
but I didn't touch it.

1898
01:23:57,958 --> 01:23:58,583
Ordered but didn't drink?

1899
01:23:58,667 --> 01:23:59,417
Why would I believe that?

1900
01:23:59,500 --> 01:24:01,250
Because that's the truth. I swear.

1901
01:24:01,542 --> 01:24:02,917
Why should I believe that? Why should I

1902
01:24:03,000 --> 01:24:03,583
believe anything that

1903
01:24:03,667 --> 01:24:04,250
you're saying anymore?

1904
01:24:04,375 --> 01:24:04,917
I swear to Jesus.

1905
01:24:05,000 --> 01:24:05,917
You swear to me.

1906
01:24:06,000 --> 01:24:06,542
I swear.

1907
01:24:06,625 --> 01:24:07,000
Don't lie to me.

1908
01:24:07,083 --> 01:24:08,417
I'm not lying. I promise. I

1909
01:24:08,500 --> 01:24:10,625
promise. That is the truth. Okay?

1910
01:24:12,375 --> 01:24:13,125
Look, it...

1911
01:24:15,500 --> 01:24:15,625
It...

1912
01:24:18,375 --> 01:24:20,500
It was the twins due date and I could

1913
01:24:20,583 --> 01:24:22,042
deal with the feelings I was having.

1914
01:24:22,125 --> 01:24:23,375
I couldn't deal with them so I... I

1915
01:24:23,458 --> 01:24:23,958
didn't want to bring them

1916
01:24:24,042 --> 01:24:25,125
home and put them on you.

1917
01:24:26,208 --> 01:24:28,667
So I went there. I sat there for a while

1918
01:24:28,750 --> 01:24:30,333
and then I... and then I came home.

1919
01:24:31,167 --> 01:24:32,750
Why didn't you tell me that it was me?

1920
01:24:33,375 --> 01:24:33,583
No.

1921
01:24:33,667 --> 01:24:35,333
Did you get this from... you could?

1922
01:24:35,417 --> 01:24:37,458
I wanted to but you were in so much pain.

1923
01:24:37,667 --> 01:24:39,083
Of course I was in pain.

1924
01:24:39,833 --> 01:24:40,625
I kept thinking that I

1925
01:24:40,708 --> 01:24:41,500
was somehow responsible.

1926
01:24:41,833 --> 01:24:42,583
That it was my fault.

1927
01:24:42,792 --> 01:24:43,458
That it's still my fault.

1928
01:24:43,542 --> 01:24:44,250
No, it was not your fault.

1929
01:24:44,333 --> 01:24:45,208
They were my baby.

1930
01:24:45,292 --> 01:24:45,708
It's not.

1931
01:24:46,375 --> 01:24:47,333
They were our babies.

1932
01:24:47,417 --> 01:24:49,875
I know. None of this is your fault.

1933
01:24:51,042 --> 01:24:52,958
We were both hurting. Still hurts.

1934
01:24:55,833 --> 01:24:56,458
I'm still hurting.

1935
01:25:00,583 --> 01:25:01,375
Me too.

1936
01:25:03,500 --> 01:25:04,958
No. No.

1937
01:25:10,375 --> 01:25:12,333
I'm not doing this alone.

1938
01:25:13,375 --> 01:25:16,042
No, you're not. You're not. You are not.

1939
01:25:16,583 --> 01:25:17,833
I will... I will

1940
01:25:17,917 --> 01:25:19,333
protect our family. I will.

1941
01:25:21,375 --> 01:25:22,417
I promise.

1942
01:25:23,042 --> 01:25:23,250
Okay.

1943
01:25:26,167 --> 01:25:26,833
Come here.

1944
01:25:43,375 --> 01:25:45,917
What the hell's going on?

1945
01:25:46,000 --> 01:25:47,583
I need to see him.

1946
01:25:47,875 --> 01:25:48,042
Why?

1947
01:25:48,292 --> 01:25:49,125
I need him to look me in the

1948
01:25:49,208 --> 01:25:50,667
eye and tell me he didn't do it.

1949
01:25:52,583 --> 01:25:53,333
So you're having douse?

1950
01:25:53,750 --> 01:25:54,083
I'm right.

1951
01:25:54,417 --> 01:25:54,708
Your dad...

1952
01:25:54,792 --> 01:25:56,458
I don't know.

1953
01:25:56,958 --> 01:25:57,792
What do you mean you don't know?

1954
01:25:58,208 --> 01:25:59,500
Come on, you know something isn't right

1955
01:25:59,583 --> 01:26:01,125
here. The jury knows it. It's just...

1956
01:26:02,000 --> 01:26:03,208
Can you prove that's what happened?

1957
01:26:03,667 --> 01:26:05,542
Can you prove it didn't? Can you?

1958
01:26:06,167 --> 01:26:07,375
I don't know. Just get me in there.

1959
01:26:12,375 --> 01:26:13,958
[doorbell rings]

1960
01:26:14,042 --> 01:26:24,500
What are you doing here?

1961
01:26:26,542 --> 01:26:27,292
Have a seat.

1962
01:26:29,375 --> 01:26:30,500
I shouldn't be talking to you.

1963
01:26:31,500 --> 01:26:32,042
It's okay.

1964
01:26:35,208 --> 01:26:39,333
What do you want?

1965
01:26:41,458 --> 01:26:42,500
Same thing as you.

1966
01:26:43,625 --> 01:26:44,792
Justice for Kendall Carter.

1967
01:26:45,333 --> 01:26:47,167
So go find the son of a bitch who did it.

1968
01:26:49,875 --> 01:26:51,458
There's no jury, no

1969
01:26:51,542 --> 01:26:53,250
judge, no cameras, so just...

1970
01:26:54,333 --> 01:26:55,458
Tell me what happened that night.

1971
01:26:55,542 --> 01:26:56,917
I told you. I went home.

1972
01:26:59,792 --> 01:27:01,667
Right, but first you...

1973
01:27:02,333 --> 01:27:03,667
you followed her, right?

1974
01:27:05,083 --> 01:27:06,125
Yeah. I mean, she was wasted.

1975
01:27:07,375 --> 01:27:10,750
You felt angry and, I don't

1976
01:27:10,833 --> 01:27:11,958
know, sick of being played.

1977
01:27:12,042 --> 01:27:14,042
No, no. That wasn't it, okay?

1978
01:27:15,708 --> 01:27:16,625
It's just how Kenny was.

1979
01:27:17,583 --> 01:27:19,125
She'd get all worked up, you know, talk

1980
01:27:19,208 --> 01:27:20,500
to this big game, and the next day it'd

1981
01:27:20,583 --> 01:27:21,250
be like nothing happened.

1982
01:27:22,500 --> 01:27:23,792
She just needed to chill out.

1983
01:27:27,667 --> 01:27:28,250
Yes, okay.

1984
01:27:30,167 --> 01:27:32,917
I know our relationship wasn't perfect.

1985
01:27:35,542 --> 01:27:36,833
But we did love each other.

1986
01:27:39,625 --> 01:27:42,250
Now listen, lady, I've done a lot of

1987
01:27:42,333 --> 01:27:45,750
things in my life that I'm not proud of.

1988
01:27:47,417 --> 01:27:49,250
But I didn't do this.

1989
01:27:53,375 --> 01:27:57,750
The biggest regret of my wife...

1990
01:27:59,375 --> 01:28:01,042
He said I didn't go after

1991
01:28:01,125 --> 01:28:03,000
Kendall in my car that night.

1992
01:28:04,750 --> 01:28:05,458
Because if I did,

1993
01:28:07,708 --> 01:28:08,542
Kenny would still be alive.

1994
01:28:12,542 --> 01:28:12,833
I'm done.

1995
01:28:29,458 --> 01:28:29,917
All right, everybody

1996
01:28:30,000 --> 01:28:31,208
on the bus. Let's go.

1997
01:28:58,875 --> 01:29:01,375
Look, but don't touch.

1998
01:29:58,375 --> 01:30:08,542
(singing)

1999
01:30:12,417 --> 01:30:14,208
Okay, you ready to go?

2000
01:30:29,250 --> 01:30:37,958
(footsteps)

2001
01:30:38,042 --> 01:30:42,292
(sighs)

2002
01:30:47,083 --> 01:30:48,500
So this is where they fought.

2003
01:30:49,583 --> 01:30:52,167
(somber music)

2004
01:31:26,083 --> 01:31:51,833
movie promo music) (birds chirping)

2005
01:31:53,458 --> 01:31:54,833
Hey, you all right?

2006
01:31:56,083 --> 01:31:57,333
Yeah, you'll find things.

2007
01:31:58,542 --> 01:31:59,125
No, man.

2008
01:32:01,000 --> 01:32:02,417
You haven't been fine since the start.

2009
01:32:05,083 --> 01:32:05,708
I think you've been

2010
01:32:05,792 --> 01:32:06,833
playing us this whole time.

2011
01:32:08,458 --> 01:32:09,250
I don't know what you mean.

2012
01:32:12,042 --> 01:32:13,208
The day you got in the jury,

2013
01:32:13,292 --> 01:32:16,042
you were puking in the bathroom,

2014
01:32:17,500 --> 01:32:18,625
all that stuff with the

2015
01:32:18,708 --> 01:32:20,042
Flower Man cop in those papers.

2016
01:32:22,667 --> 01:32:23,958
You claim to be the voice of reason,

2017
01:32:24,042 --> 01:32:24,708
but you really just

2018
01:32:24,792 --> 01:32:26,875
tell us what we wanna hear.

2019
01:32:36,083 --> 01:32:36,542
Now, I don't know what

2020
01:32:36,625 --> 01:32:37,500
game you're playing, man,

2021
01:32:37,583 --> 01:32:38,458
but I see you.

2022
01:32:42,292 --> 01:32:43,417
Do I know exactly

2023
01:32:43,500 --> 01:32:44,542
what happened that night?

2024
01:32:44,917 --> 01:32:45,083
No.

2025
01:32:46,333 --> 01:32:48,833
But neither do you.

2026
01:32:49,833 --> 01:32:51,542
And you can't be any more sure

2027
01:32:52,292 --> 01:32:54,292
that James Saib got in his

2028
01:32:54,375 --> 01:32:55,917
car and drove home that night,

2029
01:32:56,000 --> 01:32:59,625
but I'm sure he picked

2030
01:32:59,708 --> 01:33:00,792
up one of these rocks

2031
01:33:01,458 --> 01:33:03,667
and bashed that poor girl's head in

2032
01:33:05,000 --> 01:33:06,167
and threw her body in the creek.

2033
01:33:06,625 --> 01:33:10,333
(water splashing)

2034
01:33:12,917 --> 01:33:13,708
Jesus, man.

2035
01:33:15,042 --> 01:33:16,250
You nearly slipped, yeah.

2036
01:33:22,542 --> 01:33:23,500
Maybe that hiker was right.

2037
01:33:25,000 --> 01:33:27,542
Could've slipped, yeah, maybe, maybe.

2038
01:33:28,417 --> 01:33:29,333
But it doesn't matter.

2039
01:33:33,500 --> 01:33:34,500
That piece of shit

2040
01:33:34,583 --> 01:33:36,042
left her there that night.

2041
01:33:37,083 --> 01:33:40,000
Alone to die in a ditch.

2042
01:33:42,875 --> 01:33:44,333
Her death is on him,

2043
01:33:44,542 --> 01:33:45,875
which is why I will never

2044
01:33:45,958 --> 01:33:48,917
acquit James Saib, ever.

2045
01:33:53,792 --> 01:33:55,458
The Stralians are only two ways,

2046
01:33:55,542 --> 01:33:57,917
either with conviction or a hung jury.

2047
01:33:59,250 --> 01:33:59,583
All right, is

2048
01:33:59,667 --> 01:34:00,792
everybody ready to head home?

2049
01:34:03,667 --> 01:34:04,958
Is everybody done here, please?

2050
01:34:07,417 --> 01:34:07,625
Yeah.

2051
01:34:12,875 --> 01:34:13,333
Let's go.

2052
01:34:14,958 --> 01:34:17,833
Have you seen enough?

2053
01:34:19,208 --> 01:34:19,417
Yeah.

2054
01:34:22,458 --> 01:34:24,875
(ominous music)

2055
01:34:36,625 --> 01:34:39,375
(engine revving)

2056
01:35:06,625 --> 01:35:15,000
(ominous music)

2057
01:35:25,833 --> 01:35:26,750
All rise.

2058
01:35:37,333 --> 01:35:41,458
(footsteps thudding)

2059
01:35:47,542 --> 01:35:48,292
Madam poor person.

2060
01:35:52,083 --> 01:35:53,292
Hasn't your every just a verdict?

2061
01:35:54,458 --> 01:35:55,042
Yes, your honor.

2062
01:35:56,208 --> 01:35:57,500
And is that verdict unanimous?

2063
01:35:59,125 --> 01:35:59,708
Yes, your honor.

2064
01:36:06,625 --> 01:36:17,583
(footsteps thudding)

2065
01:36:27,542 --> 01:36:28,792
Will the defendant please stand

2066
01:36:28,875 --> 01:36:29,833
for the reading of the verdict?

2067
01:36:37,042 --> 01:36:38,375
In the matter of State of

2068
01:36:38,458 --> 01:36:40,542
Georgia versus James Michael Saib,

2069
01:36:41,250 --> 01:36:46,000
case number CR20211715532,

2070
01:36:47,417 --> 01:36:49,417
we the jury find the

2071
01:36:49,500 --> 01:36:51,000
defendant James Michael Saib

2072
01:36:51,958 --> 01:36:54,250
guilty of count one malice murder.

2073
01:36:55,833 --> 01:36:56,750
Signed and dated this

2074
01:36:56,833 --> 01:36:59,917
day, Denise Allworth-Pors.

2075
01:37:02,292 --> 01:37:03,000
Madam poor person.

2076
01:37:04,667 --> 01:37:05,542
To the best of your knowledge,

2077
01:37:05,625 --> 01:37:07,792
was this your verdict in the jury room?

2078
01:37:08,417 --> 01:37:10,417
Was it freely and voluntarily given

2079
01:37:10,583 --> 01:37:11,875
and is this still your verdict?

2080
01:37:13,958 --> 01:37:14,542
Yes, your honor.

2081
01:37:15,167 --> 01:37:15,708
Very well.

2082
01:37:16,458 --> 01:37:18,417
Then the defender is hereby remanded

2083
01:37:18,750 --> 01:37:20,083
to the custody of the state.

2084
01:37:21,375 --> 01:37:23,125
Sentencing will be at a later date.

2085
01:37:34,167 --> 01:37:35,042
Thank you for your service.

2086
01:37:36,167 --> 01:37:37,167
It is now concluded.

2087
01:37:38,833 --> 01:37:43,292
This court is adjourned.

2088
01:37:44,167 --> 01:37:56,208
(somber music)

2089
01:38:05,625 --> 01:38:16,667
(asau

2090
01:38:16,750 --> 01:38:16,917
subatory can hear the vacancy beeps)

2091
01:38:17,000 --> 01:38:25,667
(enchanting siren sound)

2092
01:38:25,750 --> 01:38:28,667
(siren continues to pasta fanfare)

2093
01:38:28,750 --> 01:38:31,375
(much louder caterpillar
sound) (eerie music)

2094
01:38:58,875 --> 01:39:07,167
(eerie music)

2095
01:39:08,875 --> 01:39:09,083
Hey.

2096
01:39:09,542 --> 01:39:10,000
Hey.

2097
01:39:11,875 --> 01:39:12,708
Hey.

2098
01:39:13,542 --> 01:39:14,500
What time is it, sorry.

2099
01:39:14,833 --> 01:39:15,917
Soon, I'm ahead of.

2100
01:39:16,083 --> 01:39:16,875
You sure you wanna go?

2101
01:39:17,625 --> 01:39:19,750
Hey, Justin, he wasn't a good guy.

2102
01:39:20,833 --> 01:39:21,458
It's not your fault.

2103
01:39:24,583 --> 01:39:25,875
I didn't stand up for him.

2104
01:39:26,917 --> 01:39:28,833
I told him what they needed to hear

2105
01:39:28,917 --> 01:39:30,458
and said he couldn't change.

2106
01:39:32,000 --> 01:39:33,708
And I have to live with that, so.

2107
01:39:37,500 --> 01:39:38,875
At least I can do his beat here.

2108
01:39:41,792 --> 01:39:41,958
(door slams)

2109
01:39:42,042 --> 01:39:43,833
(door creaks)

2110
01:39:44,542 --> 01:39:45,375
Hi, Peter.

2111
01:39:46,958 --> 01:39:47,417
(crying)

2112
01:39:55,917 --> 01:39:58,917
(footsteps)

2113
01:40:00,667 --> 01:40:01,292
This came for you?

2114
01:40:11,625 --> 01:40:11,833
Okay.

2115
01:40:25,917 --> 01:40:34,917
(footsteps)

2116
01:40:35,000 --> 01:40:35,292
Will the defendant

2117
01:40:35,375 --> 01:40:37,000
please stand for sentencing?

2118
01:40:41,583 --> 01:40:42,667
The murder of Kendall

2119
01:40:42,750 --> 01:40:45,583
Carter was violent and senseless.

2120
01:40:47,208 --> 01:40:48,375
The jury has found you

2121
01:40:48,458 --> 01:40:49,833
guilty of that murder

2122
01:40:49,917 --> 01:40:51,167
for which this court

2123
01:40:51,250 --> 01:40:52,833
sentences you as follows.

2124
01:40:54,083 --> 01:40:56,000
Count one, malice murder,

2125
01:40:58,250 --> 01:40:59,750
life in prison without

2126
01:40:59,833 --> 01:41:01,083
the possibility of parole.

2127
01:41:03,208 --> 01:41:05,125
The defendant is hereby remanded

2128
01:41:05,458 --> 01:41:06,875
to the Department of Corrections

2129
01:41:07,083 --> 01:41:09,083
to serve the rest of his life in prison.

2130
01:41:24,083 --> 01:41:28,083
(footsteps)

2131
01:41:34,667 --> 01:41:35,750
My husband Justin hit a tear.

2132
01:41:35,833 --> 01:41:37,250
My wife is of a high-risk pregnancy.

2133
01:41:40,000 --> 01:41:41,333
(sighs)

2134
01:41:51,750 --> 01:41:53,125
This court is now adjourned.

2135
01:41:54,042 --> 01:42:04,875
(footsteps)

2136
01:42:14,875 --> 01:42:15,042
Hey.

2137
01:42:16,375 --> 01:42:18,583
I'm surprised you came today.

2138
01:42:22,208 --> 01:42:23,375
I wanted to see this through.

2139
01:42:24,750 --> 01:42:25,250
Yeah, me too.

2140
01:42:30,500 --> 01:42:31,500
I'm tired.

2141
01:42:34,750 --> 01:42:35,000
Likewise.

2142
01:42:37,000 --> 01:42:38,125
I have a new baby at home.

2143
01:42:39,833 --> 01:42:40,583
That's not what I meant.

2144
01:42:48,458 --> 01:42:49,750
Congratulations on winning your election.

2145
01:42:49,958 --> 01:42:50,583
I saw it in the paper.

2146
01:42:50,667 --> 01:42:51,833
Oh yeah, thank you.

2147
01:42:51,917 --> 01:42:52,625
It's a pretty big deal.

2148
01:42:52,708 --> 01:42:53,625
I've also worked hard for it.

2149
01:42:53,708 --> 01:42:54,417
Oh, I did.

2150
01:42:57,125 --> 01:42:57,708
There's a lot of good you can

2151
01:42:57,792 --> 01:42:58,792
do in that job, I'd imagine.

2152
01:43:00,500 --> 01:43:00,875
Sometimes.

2153
01:43:03,500 --> 01:43:04,625
It's not as easy as you think, though.

2154
01:43:07,042 --> 01:43:07,292
Ever as.

2155
01:43:09,458 --> 01:43:10,625
Sometimes you try to do the right thing

2156
01:43:10,708 --> 01:43:12,042
only to realize you got it all wrong.

2157
01:43:17,042 --> 01:43:19,250
And when you figure things out,

2158
01:43:20,542 --> 01:43:21,042
you realize the guy

2159
01:43:21,125 --> 01:43:23,875
you're after isn't some psycho.

2160
01:43:25,292 --> 01:43:26,500
He's not even really a criminal.

2161
01:43:28,833 --> 01:43:30,250
He's just a regular guy.

2162
01:43:34,375 --> 01:43:35,375
What I feel was an accident.

2163
01:43:35,792 --> 01:43:36,708
It's just no accident.

2164
01:43:40,708 --> 01:43:42,458
It's impossible to prove either way.

2165
01:43:42,958 --> 01:43:43,458
You know, just like him

2166
01:43:43,542 --> 01:43:44,625
not realizing at the time

2167
01:43:45,292 --> 01:43:46,458
that he hit someone with his cards.

2168
01:43:50,583 --> 01:43:52,000
You just have to trust him.

2169
01:43:54,042 --> 01:43:54,750
Why would I do that?

2170
01:43:56,375 --> 01:43:57,167
Because he's a good person.

2171
01:43:58,500 --> 01:43:59,958
He's caught in terrible circumstances.

2172
01:44:01,208 --> 01:44:01,542
Mm-hmm.

2173
01:44:02,250 --> 01:44:02,792
No, you're right.

2174
01:44:02,875 --> 01:44:04,458
This is a tough one.

2175
01:44:07,500 --> 01:44:09,000
He has a family depending on him,

2176
01:44:09,083 --> 01:44:09,542
just like you have

2177
01:44:09,625 --> 01:44:10,542
people depending on you.

2178
01:44:12,250 --> 01:44:13,250
And what about justice?

2179
01:44:20,083 --> 01:44:22,750
Well, sometimes the truth isn't justice.

2180
01:44:24,750 --> 01:44:26,042
You really believe that?

2181
01:44:32,125 --> 01:44:34,458
If you keep going with this,

2182
01:44:34,542 --> 01:44:37,042
the press will eat you alive, okay?

2183
01:44:37,208 --> 01:44:38,833
This case will follow you forever.

2184
01:44:38,917 --> 01:44:40,375
In the meantime, some

2185
01:44:40,458 --> 01:44:41,750
politician will take your job.

2186
01:44:42,583 --> 01:44:44,083
A criminal goes back on the street

2187
01:44:45,000 --> 01:44:45,667
and a good man and his

2188
01:44:45,750 --> 01:44:48,917
family will be just destroyed.

2189
01:44:50,708 --> 01:44:50,917
Yeah.

2190
01:44:52,917 --> 01:44:54,458
Where's the justice in that?

2191
01:45:01,042 --> 01:45:07,875
(tense music)

2192
01:45:19,583 --> 01:45:22,042
(birds chirping)

2193
01:45:27,708 --> 01:45:43,375
(tense music)

2194
01:45:44,917 --> 01:45:48,917
Looks like the storm passed.

2195
01:45:50,333 --> 01:45:51,708
Yeah, I think so.

2196
01:45:52,375 --> 01:46:15,458
(tense music)

2197
01:46:16,250 --> 01:46:18,000
Hello, where's our new DA?

2198
01:46:19,833 --> 01:46:20,708
Hey. Hey.

2199
01:46:20,792 --> 01:46:22,958
What's up, new DA? No.

2200
01:46:24,125 --> 01:46:25,333
Thanks. Yeah, that's real.

2201
01:46:26,458 --> 01:46:29,292
Easy plan, take care of it.

2202
01:46:29,958 --> 01:46:31,208
Really thrives on neglect.

2203
01:46:32,583 --> 01:46:34,000
How you did it.

2204
01:46:36,250 --> 01:46:37,792
Hope it was worth it.

2205
01:46:43,958 --> 01:46:45,875
Hail house later, goodbye.

2206
01:46:56,958 --> 01:47:09,000
(tense music)

2207
01:47:09,750 --> 01:47:10,042
Kung Fu.

2208
01:47:11,917 --> 01:47:14,500
And the four rudder is officially sold.

2209
01:47:15,458 --> 01:47:15,792
Okay.

2210
01:47:20,792 --> 01:47:25,542
(tense music)

2211
01:47:27,000 --> 01:47:29,375
Hi, what the fuck?

2212
01:47:29,667 --> 01:47:30,542
Good morning. Good data.

2213
01:47:31,167 --> 01:47:32,833
Yeah, there it goes. Yeah.

2214
01:47:32,917 --> 01:47:34,167
Come here, here we go.

2215
01:47:34,833 --> 01:47:36,625
Yeah, you're doing good.

2216
01:47:37,208 --> 01:47:38,375
Hi. It sucks.

2217
01:47:38,750 --> 01:47:39,875
I think she has my eyes.

2218
01:47:40,667 --> 01:47:41,458
Really? Yeah.

2219
01:47:42,000 --> 01:47:42,833
Oh. Yeah.

2220
01:47:44,000 --> 01:47:44,917
You're beautiful, I smell.

2221
01:47:46,417 --> 01:47:47,167
Look, I think maybe

2222
01:47:47,250 --> 01:47:49,000
mine changing a little bit.

2223
01:47:50,167 --> 01:47:50,833
Yeah, I...

2224
01:47:51,375 --> 01:47:53,625
She has my mouth. Hope not.

2225
01:47:57,458 --> 01:47:58,667
Definitely your elbows though.

2226
01:47:58,750 --> 01:48:00,500
My elbow, my elbow.

2227
01:48:01,417 --> 01:48:02,500
Look at your beautiful

2228
01:48:02,583 --> 01:48:03,500
elbows, you're blessed.

2229
01:48:04,333 --> 01:48:05,375
My greatest feature.

2230
01:48:09,417 --> 01:48:09,667
Hi.

2231
01:48:12,417 --> 01:48:15,375
My girls, my girls with beautiful elbows.

2232
01:48:15,917 --> 01:48:16,125
Yeah.

2233
01:48:16,833 --> 01:48:21,167
(knocking) Oh, could
that be a time like this?

2234
01:48:22,333 --> 01:48:22,875
Hey, Peanut. Hello.

2235
01:48:23,542 --> 01:48:26,500
Hi, Eddie. Oh, okay.

2236
01:48:27,167 --> 01:48:28,750
(door opens)

2237
01:48:28,833 --> 01:48:32,458
(crickets chirping)

2238
01:48:32,542 --> 01:48:43,625
(crickets chirping)

2239
01:48:43,708 --> 01:48:46,875
(piano music)